基于Meta分析的张掖黑河湿地生态系统服务价值评估

doi:10.19741/j.issn.1673-4831.2022.0157

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 通过Meta分析构建了张掖黑河湿地生态系统服务价值数据库和价值转移模型,对张掖黑河不同类型湿地价值进行有效评估,并对价值的影响因素进行综合分析,最后对模型的有效性进行检验。结果表明:(1)张掖黑河湿地生态系统服务总价值为19.41亿元,不同类型湿地价值由大到小依次为河流湿地(6.18亿元)、沼泽湿地(5.11亿元)、人工湿地(4.42亿元)、其他湿地(3.40亿元)和湖泊湿地(0.3亿元)。(2)Meta回归结果表明评估方法、湿地类型、生态系统服务类型、湿地面积是影响张掖黑河湿地生态系统服务价值变化的主要因素。(3)有效性检验结果表明,转移误差在可接受范围内,因此,将所构建的Meta分析价值转移模型应用于张掖黑河湿地生态系统服务价值评估是一种有效的方法。

关键词: Meta分析, 张掖黑河湿地, 生态系统, 服务价值

Abstract: Through the Meta analysis, the service value database and value transfer model of Zhangye Heihe wetland ecosystem was constructed for the effective evaluation of the value of different types of wetlands in Heihe of Zhangye, and for the comprehensive analysis of the influencing factors of the value. The test on the validity of the model was then conducted. The results indicate that: (1) The service value of Zhangye Heihe wetland ecosystem is RMB 1.941 billion in total, and the value of different types of wetlands from large to small are river wetlands (RMB 618 million), swamp wetlands (RMB 511 million), artificial wetlands (RMB 442 million), other wetlands (RMB 340 million) and lake wetlands (RMB 30 million). (2) The meta regression results reveal that the main factors affecting the change of the service value of Zhangye Heihe wetland ecosystem include the assessment methods, wetland types, ecosystem service types, and wetland area. (3) The validity test results suggest that the transfer error is within the acceptable range. Therefore, applying the constructed meta analysis value transfer model to the evaluation of the service value of Zhangye Heihe wetland ecosystem is an effective method.

Key words: meta analysis, Zhangye Heihe wetland, ecosystem, service value

中图分类号:

杨鑫, 海新权, 杨玉婷. 基于Meta分析的张掖黑河湿地生态系统服务价值评估[J]. 生态与农村环境学报, 2023, 39(1): 60-68.

YANG Xin, HAI Xin-quan, YANG Yu-ting. Meta-analysis-based Assessment of Ecosystem Service Value of Heihe Wetland in Zhangye[J]. Journal of Ecology and Rural Environment, 2023, 39(1): 60-68.

参考文献

[1] 严有龙,王军,王金满,等.湿地生态补偿研究进展[J].生态与农村环境学报,2020,36(5):618-625.[YAN You-long,WANG Jun,WANG Jin-man,et al.Study of Wetland Ecological Compensation:A Review[J].Journal of Ecology and Rural Environment,2020,36(5):618-625.]
[2] 胡晓燕,于法稳,徐湘博.用效益转移法评估生态系统服务价值:研究进展、挑战及展望[J/OL].长江流域资源与环境.(2021-10-22)[2022-03-05].https://kns.cnki.net/kcms/detail/42.1320.X.20211022.1336.002.html.[HU Xiao-yan,YU Fa-wen,XU Xiang-bo.Evaluation of Ecosystem Services by Benefit Transfer Method:Research Progress,Challenges and Outlook[J/OL].Resources and Environment of the Yangtze River Basin.(2021-10-22)[2022-03-05].https://kns.cnki.net/kcms/detail/42.1320.X.20211022.1336.002.html.]
[3] 赵玲,王尔大.评述效益转移法在资源游憩价值评价中的应用[J].中国人口·资源与环境,2011,21(增刊2):490-495.[ZHAO Ling,WANG Er-da.An Overview of the Applications of Benefit Transfer Method in Recreation Resources Economic Valuation[J].China Population,Resources and Environment,2011,21(Suppl. 2):490-495.]
[4] 张玲,李小娟,周德民,等.基于Meta分析的中国湖沼湿地生态系统服务价值转移研究[J].生态学报,2015,35(16):5507-5517.[ZHANG Ling,LI Xiao-juan,ZHOU De-min,et al.An Empirical Study of Meta-analytical Value Transfer of Lake and Marsh Ecosystem Services in China[J].Acta Ecologica Sinica,2015,35(16):5507-5517.]
[5] BRANDER L M,FLORAX R J G M,VERMAAT J E.The Empirics of Wetland Valuation:A Comprehensive Summary and a Meta-analysis of the Literature[J].Environmental and Resource Economics,2006,33(2):223-250.
[6] BRANDER L M,VAN BEUKERING P,CESAR H S J.The Recreational Value of Coral Reefs:A Meta-analysis[J].Ecological Economics,2007,63(1):209-218.
[7] VAN HOUTVEN G,POWERS J,PATTANAYAK S K.Valuing Water Quality Improvements in the United States Using Meta-analysis:Is the Glass Half-full or Half-empty for National Policy Analysis?[J].Resource and Energy Economics,2007,29(3):206-228.
[8] SHRESTHA R K,LOOMIS J B.Testing a Meta-analysis Model for Benefit Transfer in International Outdoor Recreation[J].Ecological Economics,2001,39(1):67-83.
[9] ZHAO L,WANG E D.An Empirical Study on Valuing Natural Resources Economic Values Using Benefit Transfer Method[J].Advanced Materials Research,2012,573/574:1017-1021.
[10] JOHNSTON R J,BESEDIN E Y,STAPLER R.Enhanced Geospatial Validity for Meta-analysis and Environmental Benefit Transfer:An Application to Water Quality Improvements[J].Environmental and Resource Economics,2017,68(2):343-375.
[11] BRANDER L M,WAGTENDONK A J,HUSSAIN S S,et al.Ecosystem Service Values for Mangroves in Southeast Asia:A Meta-analysis and Value Transfer Application[J].Ecosystem Services,2012,1(1):62-69.
[12] CHAIKUMBUNG M,DOUCOULIAGOS H,SCARBOROUGH H.The Economic Value of Wetlands in Developing Countries:A Meta-regression Analysis[J].Ecological Economics,2016,124:164-174.
[13] DE GROOT R,BRANDER L,VAN DER PLOEG S,et al.Global Estimates of the Value of Ecosystems and Their Services in Monetary Units[J].Ecosystem Services,2012,1(1):50-61.
[14] BROUWER R,LANGFORD I H,BATEMAN I J,et al.A Meta-analysis of Wetland Contingent Valuation Studies[J].Regional Environmental Change,1999,1(1):47-57.
[15] 孙宝娣,崔丽娟,李伟,等.湿地价值评估尺度转换方法:Meta分析研究概述[J].湿地科学与管理,2016,12(1):58-62.[SUN Bao-di,CUI Li-juan,LI Wei,et al.A Method of Scale Conversion for Wetland Valuation:An Overview on Meta-analysis[J].Wetland Science & Management,2016,12(1):58-62.]
[16] 杨玲,孔范龙,郗敏,等.基于Meta分析的青岛市湿地生态系统服务价值评估[J].生态学杂志,2017,36(4):1038-1046.[YANG Ling,KONG Fan-long,XI Min,et al.Ecosystem Services Assessment of Wetlands in Qingdao Based on Meta-analysis[J].Chinese Journal of Ecology,2017,36(4):1038-1046.]
[17] 张翼然.基于效益转换的中国湖沼湿地生态系统服务功能价值估算[D].北京:首都师范大学,2014.[ZHANG Yi-ran.Estimation of Functional Value of Marsh Wetland Ecosystem in China Based on Benefit Conversion.Beijing:Capital Normal University,2014.]
[18] 邬紫荆,曾辉.基于meta分析的中国森林生态系统服务价值评估[J].生态学报,2021,41(14):5533-5545.[WU Zi-jing,ZENG Hui.Evaluation of Forest Ecosystem Services Value in China Based on Meta-analysis[J].Acta Ecologica Sinica,2021,41(14):5533-5545.]
[19] 杨慧英.基于Meta分析的流域生态融合评价模型研究[D].兰州:西北师范大学,2021.[YANG Hui-ying.Study on Fusion Evaluation Model of Basin Ecology Based on Meta Analysis[D].Lanzhou:Northwest Normal University,2021.]
[20] 周贵尧,吴沿友.放牧对草原生态系统不同气候区碳库影响的Meta分析[J].草业学报,2016,25(10):1-10.[ZHOU Gui-yao,WU Yan-you.Meta-analysis of Effects of Grazing on Carbon Pools in Grassland Ecosystems in Different Climatic Regions[J].Acta Prataculturae Sinica,2016,25(10):1-10.]
[21] 张丹.基于Meta分析的西北生态脆弱区土地生态服务价值评价研究[D].杨凌:西北农林科技大学,2020.[ZHANG Dan.A Study on Evaluation of Land Ecological Service Value in Northwest Ecological Fragile Areas Based on Meta Analysis[D].Yangling:Northwest A & F University,2020.]
[22] CHEN D R.Essays on Improving the Econometric Estimation of Wetlands Values via Meta-analysis[D].Columbus,OH,USA:Ohio State University,2010.
[23] 范玉龙,胡楠,丁圣彦.生态系统服务网及其生态学意义[J].生态学报,2020,40(19):6729-6737.[FAN Yu-long,HU Nan,DING Sheng-yan.Ecosystem Service Network and Its Ecology Significance[J].Acta Ecologica Sinica,2020,40(19):6729-6737.]
[24] 张振明,刘俊国.生态系统服务价值研究进展[J].环境科学学报,2011,31(9):1835-1842.[ZHANG Zhen-ming,LIU Jun-guo.Progress in the Valuation of Ecosystem Services[J].Acta Scientiae Circumstantiae,2011,31(9):1835-1842.]
[25] SALEM M E,MERCER D E.The Economic Value of Mangroves:A Meta-analysis[J].Sustainability,2012,4(3):359-383.
[26] GHERMANDI A,VAN DEN BERGH J C J M,BRANDER L M,et al.Values of Natural and Human-made Wetlands:A Meta-analysis[J].Water Resources Research,2010,46(12):1-12.
[27] WOODWARD R T,WUI Y S.The Economic Value of Wetland Services:A Meta-analysis[J].Ecological Economics,2001,37(2):257-270.
[28] 郑伟,石洪华,徐宗军,等.滨海湿地生态系统服务及其价值评估:以胶州湾为例[J].生态经济,2012,28(1):179-182.[ZHENG Wei,SHI Hong-hua,XU Zong-jun,et al.Valuation on Ecosystem Services of Coastal Wetland:A Case Study in Jiaozhou Bay[J].Ecological Economy,2012,28(1):179-182.]
[29] 张灏.张掖黑河湿地自然保护区生态服务功能价值的研究[D].兰州:甘肃农业大学,2013.[ZHANG Hao.Study on the Value of Ecosystem Service in the Heihe Wetland National Nature Reserve in Zhangye[D].Lanzhou:Gansu Agricultural University,2013.]
[30] COSTANZA R,D'ARGE R,DE GROOT R,et al.The Value of the World's Ecosystem Services and Natural Capital[J].Nature,1997,387(15):253-260.
[31] 陈仲新,张新时.中国生态系统效益的价值[J].科学通报,2000,45(1):17-22,113.[CHEN Zhong-xin,ZHANG Xin-shi.The Value of Ecosystem Benefits in China[J].Science Bulletin,2000,45(1):17-22,113.]
[32] 谢高地,鲁春霞,冷允法,等.青藏高原生态资产的价值评估[J].自然资源学报,2003,18(2):189-196.[XIE Gao-di,LU Chun-xia,LENG Yun-fa,et al.Ecological Assets Evaluation of the Qinghai-Tibetan Plateau[J].Journal of Natural Resources,2003,18(2):189-196.]
[33] 李永涛,杜振宇,王霞,等.黄河三角洲自然保护区湿地生态服务功能价值评估[J].海洋环境科学,2019,38(5):761-768.[LI Yong-tao,DU Zhen-yu,WANG Xia,et al.Evaluation of Wetland Ecosystem Services in Yellow River Delta Nature Reserve[J].Marine Environmental Science,2019,38(5):761-768.]
[34] 卢慧,陈克龙,曹生奎,等.青海湖流域生态系统服务功能与价值评估[J].生态经济,2011,27(11):145-147.[LU Hui,CHEN Ke-long,CAO Sheng-kui,et al.Ecosystem Services and Its Value Evaluation of Qinghai Lake Watershed[J].Ecological Economy,2011,27(11):145-147.]
[35] BROUWER R.Environmental Value Transfer:State of the Art and Future Prospects[J].Ecological Economics,2000,32(1):137-152.