茶农绿色生产行为多主体协同治理效应及影响因素

doi:10.19741/j.issn.1673-4831.2022.1237

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 根据协同治理理论，构建茶农绿色生产行为多主体治理协同度测度指标体系，采用复合系统协同度模型和验证性因素分析模型，利用福建省安溪县、武夷山市和福鼎市872份样本数据，评估茶农绿色生产行为多主体协同治理效应并实证分析其影响因素。结果表明：（1）研究区域茶农绿色生产行为多主体协同治理系统中各子系统有序度较低且存在失衡；（2）安溪县、武夷山市和福鼎市茶农绿色生产行为多主体治理协同度均处于一般协同形态，未达到最优协同状态；（3）治理主体参与度、治理客体发展度、治理机制保障度、治理目标导向度和治理环境促进度5个维度的测度指标均会对茶农绿色生产行为多主体协同治理效应产生显著正向影响且存在差异性。据此提出以下政策建议：充分发挥各治理主体的协同作用，提高茶农绿色生产行为治理参与程度；完善多主体协同治理的实现机制，保障茶农绿色生产行为治理高效协同；健全多主体协同治理的系统结构，增强茶农绿色生产行为治理要素功能。

关键词: 绿色生产行为, 多主体协同治理, 协同治理效应, 复合系统协同度模型, 茶农

Abstract: According to the theory of collaborative governance, an indicator system was constructed to measure the collaborative degree of multi-agent governance of tea farmers' green production behavior. A sample dataset of 872 cases from Anxi County, Wuyishan City and Fuding City, Fujian Province, were used to evaluate the collaborative effect of multi-agent collaborative governance of tea farmers' green production behavior and empirically analyze its influencing factors, where a collaborative degree model of compound system and a confirmatory factor analysis model were employed. Results show that:(1) The order degree of each subsystem in the multi-agent collaborative governance system of green production behavior among tea farmers in the research area is low and imbalance. (2) The multi-agent collaborative governance synergy degree of green production behavior among tea farmers in Anxi County, Wuyishan City and Fuding City is in the general collaborative form, and has not reached the optimal collaborative state. (3) The five dimensions of measurement indicators, namely, governance agent participation, governance object development, governance mechanism assurance, governance goal orientation and governance environment promotion, have a significant positive impact on the multi-agent collaborative governance effect of green production behavior among tea farmers, while variations exist among the five dimensions. Based on these findings, the following policy recommendations are put forward:harness the collaborative role of various governance agent, enhance the participation level of governance in the governance of green production behavior among tea farmers, improve the realization mechanism of multi-agent collaborative governance and ensure the efficient coordination of governance of green production behavior among tea farmers, improve the system structure of multi-agent collaborative governance and enhance the function of governance elements of green production behavior among tea farmers.

Key words: green production behavior, multi-agent collaborative governance, collaborative governance effect, collaborative degree model of compound system, tea farmer

中图分类号:

F323.3

纪金雄, 卓凯彬, 谢屹. 茶农绿色生产行为多主体协同治理效应及影响因素[J]. 生态与农村环境学报, 2023, 39(11): 1441-1452.

JI Jin-xiong, ZHUO Kai-bin, XIE Yi. The Effect and Influencing Factors of Multi-agent Collaborative Governance of Tea Farmers' Green Production Behavior[J]. Journal of Ecology and Rural Environment, 2023, 39(11): 1441-1452.

参考文献

[1] 陈彦丽, 赵慧.地理标志农产品质量安全协同治理机制研究[M].北京:经济科学出版社, 2021:1-4.[CHEN Yan-li, ZHAO Hui.Study on Collaborative Governance Mechanism of Quality and Safety of Geographical Indications Agricultural Products[M].Beijing:Economic Science Press, 2021:1-4.]
[2] 刘迪, 孙剑, 黄梦思, 等.市场与政府对农户绿色防控技术采纳的协同作用分析[J].长江流域资源与环境, 2019, 28(5):1154-1163.[LIU Di, SUN Jian, HUANG Meng-si, et al.Research on Cooperative Effect of Market and Government on Farmers' Adoption of Integrated Pest Management Technology[J].Resources and Environment in the Yangtze Basin, 2019, 28(5):1154-1163.]
[3] 黄祖辉, 钟颖琦, 王晓莉.不同政策对农户农药施用行为的影响[J].中国人口·资源与环境, 2016, 26(8):148-155.[HUANG Zu-hui, ZHONG Ying-qi, WANG Xiao-li.Study on the Impacts of Government Policy on Farmers' Pesticide Application Behavior[J].China Population, Resources and Environment, 2016, 26(8):148-155.]
[4] 于艳丽, 李桦.多主体协同治理下茶农绿色生产绩效[J].长江流域资源与环境, 2021, 30(9):2299-2310.[YU Yan-li, LI Hua.Performance Analysis of Tea Farmers' Green Production under Multi-agent Collaborative Governance[J].Resources and Environment in the Yangtze Basin, 2021, 30(9):2299-2310.]
[5] 刘承毅, 王建明.声誉激励、社会监督与质量规制:城市垃圾处理行业中的博弈分析[J].产经评论, 2014, 5(2):93-106.[LIU Cheng-yi, WANG Jian-ming.Reputation Incentive, Social Supervision and Quality Regulation:Game Analysis in the Waste Disposal Industry[J].Industrial Economic Review, 2014, 5(2):93-106.]
[6] 何悦, 漆雁斌.农户绿色生产行为形成机理的实证研究:基于川渝地区860户柑橘种植户施肥行为的调查[J].长江流域资源与环境, 2021, 30(2):493-506.[HE Yue, QI Yan-bin.An Empirical Study on the Formation Mechanism of Farmers' Green Production Behavior:Based on the Investigation of Fertilization Behavior of 860 Citrus Growers in Sichuan and Chongqing[J].Resources and Environment in the Yangtze Basin, 2021, 30(2):493-506.]
[7] 祝国平, 焦灵玉, 刘星.产业链参与、技术选择与农户绿色生产行为[J].经济纵横, 2022(8):88-97.[ZHU Guo-ping, JIAO Ling-yu, LIU Xing.Industry Chain Participation, Technology Choice and Farmers' Green Production Behavior[J].Economic Review Journal, 2022(8):88-97.]
[8] 刘杰, 李聪, 王刚毅.农户组织化促进了绿色技术采纳?[J].农村经济, 2022(1):69-78.[LIU Jie, LI Cong, WANG Gang-yi.Will Farmer Organization Promotes Adoption of Green Technology?[J].Rural Economy, 2022(1):69-78.]
[9] 徐志刚, 张炯, 仇焕广.声誉诉求对农户亲环境行为的影响研究:以家禽养殖户污染物处理方式选择为例[J].中国人口·资源与环境, 2016, 26(10):44-52.[XU Zhi-gang, ZHANG Jiong, QIU Huan-guang.Effects of Reputation Demands on Farmers' Pro-environmental Behavior:Taking the Farmers' Disposal Behavior of Poultry Waste as an Example[J].China Population, Resources and Environment, 2016, 26(10):44-52.]
[10] 唐林, 罗小锋, 张俊飚.社会监督、群体认同与农户生活垃圾集中处理行为:基于面子观念的中介和调节作用[J].中国农村观察, 2019(2):18-33.[TANG Lin, LUO Xiao-feng, ZHANG Jun-biao.Social Supervision, Group Identity and Farmers' Domestic Waste Centralized Disposal Behavior:An Analysis Based on Mediation Effect and Regulation Effect of the Face Concept[J].China Rural Survey, 2019(2):18-33.]
[11] 张丰翼, 颜廷武, 张俊飚.社会互动对农户绿色技术采纳行为的影响:基于湖北省1004份农户调查数据的分析[J].生态与农村环境学报, 2022, 38(1):43-51.[ZHANG Feng-yi, YAN Ting-wu, ZHANG Jun-biao.Effect of Social Interaction on Farmers' Adoption of Green Technologies:Evidence from 1004 Household Survey Data in Hubei Province[J].Journal of Ecology and Rural Environment, 2022, 38(1):43-51.]
[12] 李芬妮, 张俊飚, 何可.非正式制度、环境规制对农户绿色生产行为的影响:基于湖北1105份农户调查数据[J].资源科学, 2019, 41(7):1227-1239.[LI Fen-ni, ZHANG Jun-biao, HE Ke.Impact of Informal Institutions and Environmental Regulations on Farmers' Green Production Behavior:Based on Survey Data of 1105 Households in Hubei Province[J].Resources Science, 2019, 41(7):1227-1239.]
[13] BAILEY A P, GARFORTH C.An Industry Viewpoint on the Role of Farm Assurance in Delivering Food Safety to the Consumer:The Case of the Dairy Sector of England and Wales[J].Food Policy, 2014, 45:14-24.
[14] 赵晓颖, 郑军, 张明月, 等."茶农+种植合作社"模式下茶农绿色生产行为影响因素分析:基于委托-代理理论[J].世界农业, 2020(1):72-80, 130.[ZHAO Xiao-ying, ZHENG Jun, ZHANG Ming-yue, et al.Analysis of Green Production Behavior in the " Tea Farmer+planting Cooperative" Model Based on the Principalagent Theory[J].World Agriculture, 2020(1):72-80, 130.]
[15] 仇焕广, 栾昊, 李瑾, 等.风险规避对农户化肥过量施用行为的影响[J].中国农村经济, 2014(3):85-96.[QIU Huan-guang, LUAN Hao, LI Jin, et al.Influence of Risk Aversion on Farmers' Excessive Application of Chemical Fertilizers[J].Chinese Rural Economy, 2014(3):85-96.]
[16] 陈梅英, 黄守先, 张凡, 等.农业绿色生产技术采纳对农户收入的影响效应研究[J].生态与农村环境学报, 2021, 37(10):1310-1317.[CHEN Mei-ying, HUANG Shou-xian, ZHANG Fan, et al.Effect of Adopting Agricultural Green Production Technology on Farmers Income:Data Verification from Tea Farmers[J].Journal of Ecology and Rural Environment, 2021, 37(10):1310-1317.]
[17] 于艳丽, 李桦, 薛彩霞.政府规制与社区治理对茶农减量施药行为的影响[J].资源科学, 2019, 41(12):2227-2236.[YU Yan-li, LI Hua, XUE Cai-xia.Influence of Government Regulation and Community Governance on Tea Farmers' Behavior of Reducing Pesticide Use[J].Resources Science, 2019, 41(12):2227-2236.]
[18] 钱力, 倪修凤, 宋俊秀.乡村振兴多元主体协同治理效应研究[M].北京:经济科学出版社, 2021:11-13.[QIAN Li, NI Xiu-feng, SONG Jun-xiu.Study on Synergistic Governance Effect of Multi-subjects in Rural Revitalization[M].Beijing:Economic Science Press, 2021:11-13.]
[19] 李欣.食品安全多主体治理协同度研究[D].济南:山东财经大学, 2017.[LI Xin.A Study of Multi-agent Governance Synergy Degree of Food Safety[D].Jinan:Shandong University of Finance and Economics, 2017.]
[20] 聂法良.城市森林协同治理体系的协同度评价指标及应用:以青岛市为例[J].山东农业大学学报(自然科学版), 2015, 46(2):173-179.[NIE Fa-liang.Cooperative Degree Evaluation Index of City Forest Cooperative Governance System and Its Applications:Taking Qingdao City as a Case[J].Journal of Shandong Agricultural University (Natural Science Edition), 2015, 46(2):173-179.]
[21] 黄亚林, 李明贤.农业保险各主体利益的协同度评价[J].系统工程, 2014, 32(8):52-59.[HUANG Ya-lin, LI Ming-xian.Evaluation of the Interest Synergy Degree of Each Participator of Agricultural Insurance[J].Systems Engineering, 2014, 32(8):52-59.]
[22] 吴绒, 白世贞, 吴雪艳.农产品绿色供应链协同演化机理研究[J].科技管理研究, 2016, 36(3):235-239.[WU Rong, BAI Shi-zhen, WU Xue-yan.Research on Co-evolution Mechanism of Green Supply Chain for Agricultural Products[J].Science and Technology Management Research, 2016, 36(3):235-239.]
[23] 李豫新, 尹丽.基于复合系统协同度模型的西部省区城乡高质量融合发展研究[J].新疆大学学报(哲学·人文社会科学版), 2021, 49(6):10-20.[LI Yu-xin, YIN Li.High-quality Integrated Development of Urban and Rural Areas in Western Provinces Based on the Synergy Degree Model of Compound Systems[J].Journal of Xinjiang University (Philosophy, Humanities & Social Sciences), 2021, 49(6):10-20.]
[24] 谢志忠, 黄初升, 赵莹.福建省社会、经济、人口与环境资源发展的协调度分析[J].经济与管理评论, 2012, 28(1):133-137.[XIE Zhi-zhong, HUANG Chu-sheng, ZHAO Ying.Analysis on the Coordination Degree of Social, Economic, Population and Environmental Resources Development in Fujian Province[J].Review of Economy and Management, 2012, 28(1):133-137.]
[25] 王凯伟, 刘双燕, 燕博.行政监督系统协同度测评模型构建研究[J].湘潭大学学报(哲学社会科学版), 2016, 40(2):14-21.[WANG Kai-wei, LIU Shuang-yan, YAN Bo.On the Research about the Synergy Degree Evaluation Model to the Administrative Supervision System[J].Journal of Xiangtan University (Philosophy and Social Sciences), 2016, 40(2):14-21.]
[26] 冯锋, 汪良兵.技术创新链视角下我国区域科技创新系统协调发展度研究[J].中国科技论坛, 2012(3):36-42.[FENG Feng, WANG Liang-bing.Coordinated Development Degree of China Regional Innovation System in Technology Innovation Chain Perspective[J].Forum on Science and Technology in China, 2012(3):36-42.]
[27] 李海超, 盛亦隆.区域科技创新复合系统的协同度研究[J].科技管理研究, 2018, 38(21):29-34.[LI Hai-chao, SHENG Yi-long.Synergy Degree of Regional Sci-tech Innovation Complex System[J].Science and Technology Management Research, 2018, 38(21):29-34.]
[28] 李芬妮, 张俊飚, 何可.替代与互补:农民绿色生产中的非正式制度与正式制度[J].华中科技大学学报(社会科学版), 2019, 33(6):51-60, 94.[LI Fen-ni, ZHANG Jun-biao, HE Ke.Alternative and Complementary:Informal Institutions and Formal Institutions in Farmers' Green Production[J].Journal of Huazhong University of Science and Technology (Social Science Edition), 2019, 33(6):51-60, 94.]
[29] 余威震, 罗小锋, 唐林, 等.农户绿色生产技术采纳行为决策:政策激励还是价值认同?[J].生态与农村环境学报, 2020, 36(3):318-324.[YU Wei-zhen, LUO Xiao-feng, TANG Lin, et al.Farmers' Adoption of Green Production Technology:Policy Incentive or Value Identification?[J].Journal of Ecology and Rural Environment, 2020, 36(3):318-324.]