现代生态保护理念在生态保护中的应用

doi:10.11934/j.issn.1673-4831.2017.10.001

摘要/Abstract

摘要：

生态环境问题的日益突出催生了一系列生态保护理论。总结了系统生态学保护、景观生态学保护、可持续发展保护和生态安全/风险保护4大类生态保护理念的核心思想及特点。结合4大理念在生态环境保护实践中的应用，进一步阐明相关生态保护理念的内涵以及这些生态理念对生态保护方式、生态评价方法和国家保护政策的影响。基于生态安全/风险理念，面对我国生态环境总体脆弱、生态安全形势严峻的现实，中国生态学家进一步提出了生态保护红线理论，划定并严守生态保护红线，实现一条红线管控重要生态空间，确保生态功能不降低、面积不减少和性质不改变，是构筑我国生态安全格局的有效手段。最后，总结了现代生态保护理念发展的共同趋势，即现代生态保护理念不仅是一种理念，而且伴随有一套可操作的技术方法。

关键词: 生态保护理念, 生态系统保护, 景观生态学, 生态风险, 生态安全, 生态保护红线

Abstract:

The currently aggravating eco-environment problems have given birth to a series of ecological protection theories, which could be summarized into four groups of ecological protection concepts by core ideas and characteristics, namely, system ecology protection, landscape ecology protection, sustainable development protection, and ecological safety/risk protection. Connotations of these ecological protection concepts and effects of the ecological protection concepts on ecological protection mode, ecological evaluation method and national protection policies were further illuminated by examples of the eco-environmental protection practices. Based on the concept of ecological security and the reality of severe ecological security situation which has a fragile ecological environment, Chinese ecologists have put forward the theory of ecological protection redline. Delineation and strict protection of ecological protection redline, it is an effective means to construct the ecological security pattern of China, and to ensure that the ecological function is not decreased, the area is not reduced and the nature is not changed. In the end, a common developing tendency of the modern ecological protection concepts was summarized as that the modern ecological protection concepts are not merely a kind of concepts, but they also have a set of matching operable technical methods.

Key words: ecological protection concept, ecosystem protection, landscape ecology, ecological risk, ecological security, ecological protection redline

中图分类号:

王丽霞, 邹长新, 王燕, 林乃峰. 现代生态保护理念在生态保护中的应用[J]. 生态与农村环境学报, 2017, 33(10): 865-871.

WANG Li-xia, ZOU Chang-xin, WANG Yan, LIN Nai-feng. Modern Ecological Protection Concept and Its Application to Ecological Protection[J]. Journal of Ecology and Rural Environment, 2017, 33(10): 865-871.

参考文献

[1] WU Y,SHENG J C,HUANG F.China's Future Investments in Environmental Protection and Control of Manufacturing Industry:Lessons From Developed Countries[J].Natural Hazards,2015,77(3):1889-1901.
[2] 王树义,黄莎.中国传统文化中的和谐理念与环境保护[J].河南省政法管理干部学院学报,2006(2):76-81.[WANG Shu-yi,HUANG Sha.Harmonious Idea in Chinese Traditional Culture and Environment Protection[J].Journal of Henan Adminstrative Institute of Politics and Law,2006(2):76-81.]
[3] JONGE V N.Toward the Application of Ecological Concepts in EU Coastal Water Management[J].Marine Pollution Bulletin,2007,55(10/11/12):407-414.
[4] 刘涛.基于耗散结构的农村生态环境保护动态熵模型研究[J].生态经济,2012(12):185-188.[LIU Tao.The Study of Dynamic Entropy Model of Rural Ecological Environment Protection Based on Dissipation Structure[J].Ecological Economy,2012(12):185-188.]
[5] 张洪福,宋胜帮,屈维意.基于熵视角的南京城市生态环境系统可持续发展能力研究[J].生态经济,2016,32(6):168-173.[ZHANG Hong-fu,SONG Sheng-bang,QU Wei-yi.Assessment for Nanjing's Sustainable Development Capacity on Ecological Environment System Based on Entropy Change Perspective[J].Ecological Economy,2016,32(6):168-173.]
[6] 何伟军,杨淼,袁亮,等.基于熵值法的武陵山片区生态经济发展状况评价[J].生态科学,2016,35(2):143-149.[HE Wei-jun,YANG Miao,YUAN Liang,et al.Ecological and Economic Evaluation of Wuling Mountain Area Using the Entropy Method[J].Ecological Science,2016,35(2):143-149.]
[7] 孙贤斌,刘红玉,李玉凤,等.基于CA-Markov模型土地利用对景观格局影响辨识[J].生态与农村环境学报,2009,25(1):1-7.[SUN Xian-bin,LIU Hong-yu,LI Yu-feng,et al.CA-Markov Model-Based Identification of Impacts of Land Use on Landscape Pattern[J].Journal of Ecology and Rural Environment,2009,25(1):1-7.]
[8] TURNHOUT E.The Rise and Fall of a Policy:Policy Succession and the Attempted Termination of Ecological Corridors Policy in the Netherlands[J].Policy Science,2009,42(1):57-72.
[9] FERRETTI V,POMARICO S.An Integrated Approach for Studying the Land Suitability for Ecological Corridors Through Spatial Multicriteria Evaluations[J].Environment,Development and Sustainability,2013,15(3):859-885.
[10] MARTIN J F,ROY E D,DIEMONT S A W.Traditional Ecological Knowledge (TEK):Ideas,Inspiration,and Designs for Ecological Engineering[J].Ecological Engineering,2010,36(7):839-849.
[11] HUGGETT A J.The Concept and Utility of Ecological Thresholds in Biodiversity Conservation[J].Biological Conservation,2005,124(3):301-310.
[12] KATO S,AHERN J.The Concept of Threshold and Its Potential Application to Landscape Planning[J].Landscape Ecological Engineering,2011,7:275-282.
[13] 高吉喜,邹长新,杨兆平,等.划定生态红线保障生态安全[N].中国环境报,2012-10-18(2).[GAO Ji-xi,ZOU Chang-xin,YANG Zhao-ping,et al.Delineation of Ecological Red Line to Protect Ecological Security[N].China Environment News,2012-10-18(2).]
[14] 柳新伟,周厚诚,李萍.生态系统稳定性定义剖析[J].生态学报,2004,24(11):2635-2640.[LIU Xin-wei,ZHOU Hou-cheng,LI Ping,et al.A Conceptual Analysis of Ecosystem Stability[J].Acta Ecologica Sinica,2004,24(11):2635-2640.]
[15] JABLONSKA E,FALKOWSKI T,CHORMANSKI J,et al.Understanding the Long Term Ecosystem Stability of a Fen Mire by Analyzing Subsurface Geology,Eco-Hydrology and Nutrient Stoichiometry:Case Study of the Rospuda Valley (NE Poland)[J].Wetlands,2014,34(4):815-828.
[16] GALOUX A B J.Ecosystem,Open Thermodynamic System:The Oak Forest of Virelles-Blaimont[J].Radiation and Environmental Biophysics,1978,15(2):113-130.
[17] BONDAVALLI C,BODINI A,ROSSETTI G,et al.Detecting Stress at the Whole Ecosystem Level:The Case of a Mountain Lake (Lake Santo,Italy)[J].Ecosystems,2006,9(5):768-787.
[18] 张大勇,陈方正.基于耗散理论的土地利用与生态环境系统分析[J].学术论丛,2009(5):102-104.[ZHANG Da-yong,CHEN Fang-zheng.Analysis of Land Use and Ecological Environment System Based on Dissipative Theory[J].Academic Journal,2009(5):102-104.]
[19] NIENHUIS P H,BUIJSE A D,LEUVEN R S E W,et al.Ecological Rehabilitation of the Lowland Basin of the River Rhine (NW Europe)[J].Hydrobiologia,2002,478(1/2/3):53-72.
[20] WANG Y,FENG Q,CHEN L J,et al.Significance and Effect of Ecological Rehabilitation Project in Inland River Basins in Northwest China[J].Environmental Management,2013,52(1):209-220.
[21] PAVLIKAKIS G E,TSIHRINTZIS V A.Ecosystem Management:A Review of a New Concept and Methodology[J].Water Resources Management,2000,14(4):257-283.
[22] FAITH D P,MAGALLON S,HENDRY A P,et al.Ecosystem Services:An Evolutionary Perspective on the Links Between Biodiversity and Human Well-Being[J].Environmental Sustainability,2010,2(1/2):66-74.
[23] FISHER W S,JACKSON L E,SUTER G W,et al.Indicators for Human and Ecological Risk Assessment:A U. S. Environmental Protection Agency Perspective[J].Human and Ecological Risk Assessment,2001,7(5):961-970.
[24] 杨朝飞.生态保护理论创新及其现实意义[J].环境保护,2003(6):24-28.[YANG Chao-fei.Theory Innovation of Ecological Conservation and Its Reality Denotation[J].Nature Ecological Conservation,2003(6):24-28.]
[25] JENKINS C N,JOPPA L.Expansion of the Global Terrestrial Protected Area System[J].Biological Conservation,2009,142(10):2166-2174.
[26] GASTON K J,JACKSON S F,CANTU-SALAZAR L,et al.The Ecological Performance of Protected Areas[J].Annual Review of Ecology Evolution and Systematics,2008,39:93-113.
[27] MORRISSEY W A.An Ecosystem-Based Approach to Managing America's Resources:A View From the U. S. Capitol Hill[J].Landscape and Urban Planning,1998,40(1/2/3):203-210.
[28] 徐嵩龄."生态功能保护区"概念的行政透视[J].绿叶,2008(2):103-110.[XU Song-ling.Administrative Perspective on the Concept of Ecological Function Reserve[J].Green Leaf,2008(2):103-110.]
[29] 徐网谷,王智,钱者东,等.中国自然保护区范围界定和有效保护面积现状分析[J].生态与农村环境学报,2015,31(6):791-795.[XU Wang-gu,WANG Zhi,QIAN Zhe-dong,et al.Status Quo of Delineation of Ranges of Nature Reserves and Area of Nature Reserves Under Effective Protection in China[J].Journal of Ecology and Rural Environment,2015,31(6):791-795.]
[30] 陈利顶,孙然好,汲玉河.海河流域水生态功能分区研究[M].北京:科学出版社,2013:1-237.[CHEN Li-ding,SUN Ran-hao,JI Yu-he.Regionalization of Aquatic Ecoregions in Haihe River Basin,China[M].Beijing:Science Press,2013:1-237.]
[31] 王秋凤,于贵瑞,何洪林,等.中国自然保护区体系和综合管理体系建设的思考[J].资源科学,2015,37(7):1357-1366.[WANG Qiu-feng,YU Gui-rui,HE Hong-lin,et al.Thinking of Construction of the Nature Reserve System and Integrated Management System in China[J].Resources Science,2015,37(7):1357-1366.]
[32] STALMANS M,BALKWILL K,WITKOWSKI E T F,et al.A Landscape Ecological Approach to Address Scaling Problems in Conservation Management and Monitoring[J].Environmental Management,2001,28(3):389-401.
[33] 刘云慧,张鑫,张旭珠,等.生态农业景观与生物多样性保护及生态服务维持[J].中国生态农业学报,2012,20(7):819-824.[LIU Yun-hui,ZHANG Xin,ZHANG Xu-zhu,et al.Ecoagricultural Landscape for Biodiversity Conservation and Ecological Service Maintenance[J].Chinese Journal of Eco-Agriculture,2012,20(7):819-824.]
[34] VIGL L E,SCHIRPKE U,TASSER E,et al.Linking Long-Term Landscape Dynamics to the Multiple Interactions Among Ecosystem Services in the European Alps[J].Landscape Ecology,2016,31(9):1903-1918.
[35] BLASCHKE T.The Role of the Spatial Dimension Within the Framework of Sustainable Landscapes and Natural Capital[J].Landscape and Urban Planning,2005,75(3/4):198-226.
[36] WIENS J A,STENSETH N C,HORNE B V,et al.Ecological Mechanisms and Landscape Ecology[J].Oikos,1993,66(3):369-380.
[37] BATTISTI C.Habitat Fragmentation,Fauna and Ecological Network Planning:Toward a Theoretical Conceptual Framework[J].Italian Journal of Zoology,2003,70(3):241-247.
[38] BOITANI L,FALCUCCI A,MAIORANO L,et al.Ecological Networks as Conceptual Frameworks or Operational Tools in Conservation[J].Conservation Biology,2007,21(6):1414-1422.
[39] HOLE D G,WILLIS S G,PAIN D J,et al.Projected Impacts of Climate Change on a Continent Wide Protected Area Network[J].Ecology Letters,2009,12(5):420-431.
[40] HOCTOR T S,CARR M H,ZWICK P D.Identifying a Linked Reserve System Using a Regional Landscape Approach:The Florida Ecological Network[J].Conservation Biology,2000,14(4):984-1000.
[41] 张玉梅,郑达贤.陆域生物多样性保护区群网体系框架研究[J].亚热带资源与环境学报,2008,3(2):1-10.[ZHANG Yu-mei,ZHENG Da-xian.A Framework Study on the Construction of Terrestrial Biodiversity Conservation Network[J].Journal of Subtropical Resources and Environment,2008,3(2):1-10.]
[42] RODRIGUES A S L,AKCAKAYA H R,ANDELMAN H J,et al.Global Gap Analysis:Priority Regions for Expanding the Global Protected-Area Network[J].BioScience,2004,54(12):1092-1100.
[43] COSTANZA R.Ecosystem Health and Ecological Engineering Robert Costanza[J].Ecological Engineering,2012,45:24-29.
[44] 傅伯杰.区域生态环境预警的理论及其应用[J].应用生态学报,1993,4(4):436-439.[FU Bo-jie.Early Warning Theory on Regional Eco-Environmental Issues and Its Application[J].Chinese Journal of Applied Ecology,1993,4(4):436-439.]
[45] 王如松.生态整合与文明发展[J].生态学报,2013,33(1):1-11.[WANG Ru-song.Integrating Ecological Civilization Into Social-Economic Development[J].Acta Ecological Sinica,2013,33(1):1-11.]
[46] DEFRIES R,HANSEN A,TURNER B L,et al.Land Use Change Around Protected Areas:Management to Balance Human Needs and Ecological Function[J].Ecological Applications,2007,17(4):1031-1038.
[47] MARALE S M.Shifting Role of Ecology in Solving Global Environmental Problems:Selected Practical Tools[J].Environment,Development and Sustainability,2012,14(6):869-884.
[48] CALLICOTT J B,MUMFORD K.Ecological Sustainability as a Conservation Concept[J].Conservation Biology,1997,11(1):32-40.
[49] SCHLVTER M,MCALLISTER R R J,ARLINGHAUS R.New Horizons for Managing the Environment:A Review of Coupled Social-Ecological Systems Modeling[J].Natural Resource Modeling,2012,25(1):219-272.
[50] 李文涛.两汉时期的环境伦理初探[J].唐都学刊,2015,31(1):17-22.[LI Wen-tao.A Preliminary Study on Environmental Ethics in Han Dynasty[J].Tangdu Journal,2015,31(1):17-22.]
[51] WHITE P S,TUTTLE J P.Ecological Sustainability as the Fourth Landmark in the Development of Conservation Ethics[J].Conservation Biology,2013,27(5):952-957.
[52] 李志萌.构建环境经济社会和谐共生支持体系:基于生态功能保护区建设的思考[J].江西社会科学,2008(6):17-21.[LI Zhi-meng.Reflections on Constructing the Harmonious Symbiosis Support System of Environment,Economy and Society-Based on Construction of Ecological Function Protected Area[J].Jiangxi Social Sciences,2008(6):17-21.]
[53] REES W E.Economic Development and Environmental Protection:An Ecological Economics Perspective[J].Environmental Monitoring and Assessment,2003,86(1/2):29-45.
[54] 邹长新,徐梦佳,高吉喜,等.全国重要生态功能区生态安全评价[J].生态与农村环境学报,2014,30(6):688-693.[ZOU Chang-xin,XU Meng-jia,GAO Ji-xi,et al.Ecological Security Evaluation of National Important Ecological Function Areas[J].Journal of Ecology and Rural Environment,2014,30(6):688-693.]
[55] 龙涛,邓绍坡,吴运金,等.生态风险评价框架进展研究[J].生态与农村环境学报,2015,31(6):822-830.[LONG Tao,DENG Shao-po,WU Yun-jin,et al.Advancement in Study on Development of Ecological Risk Assessment Framework[J].Journal of Ecology and Rural Environment,2015,31(6):822-830.]
[56] TUVI E L,VELLAK A,REIER U,et al.Establishment of Protected Areas in Different Ecoregions,Ecosystems,and Diversity Hotspots Under Successive Political Systems[J].Biological Conservation,2011,144:1726-1732.
[57] HART B T,BURGMAN M,GRACE M,et al.Risk-Based Approaches to Managing Contaminants in Catchments[J].Human and Ecological Risk Assessment,2007,12(1):66-73.
[58] TIAN J Y,GANG G S.Research on Regional Ecological Security Assessment[J].Energy Procedia,2012,16:1180-1186.
[59] MCMAHON G,WIKEN E B,GAUTHIER D A.Toward a Scientifically Rigorous Basis for Developing Mapped Ecological Regions[J].Environmental Management,2004,34(Suppl. 1):111-124.
[60] 王永莉.主体功能区划背景下生态脆弱地区的功能探讨[J].社会科学家,2008(1):67-71.[WANG Yong-li.Discussion on the Function of Ecological Fragile Area in the Background of Main Function Zoning[J].Social Scientist,2008(1):67-71.]
[61] 赵广华,田瑜,唐志尧,等.中国国家级陆地自然保护区分布及其与人类活动和自然环境的关系[J].生物多样性,2013,21(6):658-665.[ZHAO Guang-hua,TIAN Yu,TANG Zhi-yao,et al.Distribution of Terrestrial National Nature Reserves in Relation to Human Activities and Natural Environments in China[J].Biodiversity Science,2013,21(6):658-665.]
[62] 王金南,许开鹏,王晶晶,等.国家"十三五"资源环境生态红线框架设计[J].环境保护,2016,44(8):22-25.[WANG Jin-nan,XU Kai-peng,WANG Jing-jing,et al.A Framework of Resource-Environment-Ecology Redline in the 13th Five-Year Plan[J].Environmental Protection,2016,44(8):22-25.]
[63] 刘冬,林乃峰,邹长新,等.国外生态保护地体系对我国生态保护红线划定与管理的启示[J].生物多样性,2015,23(6):708-715.[LIU Dong,LIN Nai-feng,ZOU Chang-xin,et al.Development of Foreign Ecological Protected Areas and Linkages to Ecological Protection Redline Delineation and Management in China[J].Biodiversity Science,2015,23(6):708-715.]
[64] 侍昊,李旭文,牛志春,等.浅谈生态保护红线区生态系统管理研究概念框架[J].环境监控与预警,2015,7(6):6-10.[SHI Hao,LI Xu-wen,NIU Zhi-chun,et al.Preliminary Discussion on the Conceptual Framework Research of Ecosystem Management in Ecological Protection Red Line Area[J].Environmental Monitoring and Forewarning,2015,7(6):6-10.]
[65] GOLDSTEIN P Z.Functional Ecosystems and Biodiversity Buzzwords[J].Conservation Biology,1999,13(2):247-255.
[66] GOSSELIN F.From Ecology to Ecological Engineering:Mainly Through Theory and Concepts?[J].Procedia Enviromental Sciences,2011,9:60-63.
[67] DRISCOLL D A,LINDENMAYER D B.Framework to Improve the Application of Theory in Ecology and Conservation[J].Ecological Monographs,2012,82(1):129-147.
[68] 高吉喜.探索我国生态保护红线划定与监管[J].生物多样性,2015,23(6):705-707.[GAO Ji-xi.Exploring the Delineation and Supervision of Ecological Protection Redlines in China[J].Biodiversity Science,2015,23(6):705-707.]