贫困地区农户参与生态补偿自愿性影响因素分析:以退耕还林和公益林补偿为例

doi:10.19741/j.issn.1673-4831.2019.0048

摘要/Abstract

摘要：

生态补偿政策中的自愿性能在很大程度上影响政策的实施效果。基于云南省屏边县和西畴县的615份农户访谈数据，运用二元Logistic模型，从参与条件、参与动力、参与能力和政策吸引力4个维度分别研究退耕还林和公益林政策中影响农户自愿性的因素，为更好地提高农户参与政策的自愿性、提升政策的执行效率提供技术支撑。结果表明，参与动力和政策吸引力对农户自愿性的影响较大；退耕还林政策中，自愿参与和非自愿参与的农户比例分别为84.4%和15.6%，农户对周围人和村干部的信任程度越高、有外出打工经历、政策了解程度越深以及补偿标准越高、政策预期评价越好，其参与生态补偿政策的自愿性越高，农户年龄和家庭劳动力数量越大则自愿性越低。公益林政策中，自愿和非自愿参与的农户比例分别为36.0%和64.0%，农户对周围人和对村干部的信任程度越高，政策了解程度越深，补偿标准越高，政策预期评价越好，其参与生态补偿政策的自愿性越高。可以通过有效政策宣传、用市场化手段引入社会资本以适当提高补偿标准、积极创造非农就业机会等手段，来促进退耕还林和公益林补偿政策目标更好地实现。

关键词: 生态补偿, 自愿性, 退耕还林, 公益林补偿

Abstract:

The voluntariness of households to take part in the eco-compensation programs will largely affect the outputs of these programs. The factors influencing the household voluntariness to take part in two eco-compensation programs, i. e. the Sloping Land Conversion Program (SLCP) and Public Benefit Forest Compensation Program (PBFC) were studied. The study is based on a 615-households interview with questionnaires in Pingbian and Xichou, Yunnan Province. The results of the study show that household motivation and program attractiveness are vital for household voluntariness. In the SLCP, 84. 4% of households voluntarily took part in the program while 15. 6% of households were not voluntary. The positive factors to influence household voluntariness in the SLCP are trust in neighbours and village leaders, experiences of off-farm jobs, compensation rate, expected policy outcome and understanding to the policy. Age and number of household labors are the negative factors. In the PBFC, 36% of households were voluntary to take part in the program while 64% of households were not voluntary. The positive factors to influence household voluntariness in the PBFC are trust in neighbours and village leaders, compensation rate, expected policy outcome, understanding to the policy. This study implies that SLCP and PBFC could be better implemented with preferable outcomes if policy advocacy is enhanced, compensation rate is raised appropriately, and non-farm job opportunities are created.

Key words: eco-compensation, voluntariness, Sloping Land Conversion Program, Public Benefit Forest Compensation Program

中图分类号:

F062.2

楚宗岭, 庞洁, 蒋振, 靳乐山. 贫困地区农户参与生态补偿自愿性影响因素分析:以退耕还林和公益林补偿为例[J]. 生态与农村环境学报, 2019, 35(6): 738-746.

CHU Zong-ling, PANG Jie, JIANG Zhen, JIN Le-shan. Factors Influencing Voluntariness of Farmers to Take Part in the Ecological Compensation Programs in Poor Regions: A Case Study of Sloping Land Conversion Program and Public Benefit Forest Compensation Program in Yunnan Province[J]. Journal of Ecology and Rural Environment, 2019, 35(6): 738-746.

参考文献

[1] 国家发展和改革委员会, 财政部, 自然资源部, 等. 建立市场化、多元化生态保护补偿机制行动计划(发改西部
[2018] 1960号)[EB/OL].[2019-01-11]. http://www.gov.cn/xinwen/2019-01/11/content_5357007.htm.
[2] WUNDER S.Payments for Environmental Services and the Poor:Concepts and Preliminary Evidence[J]. Environment and Development Economics, 2008, 13(3):279-297.
[3] WUNDER S. Payments for Environmental Services:Some Nuts and Bolts[M].[s.l.]:Center for International Forestry Research (CIFOR), 2005:2-3. DOI:10.17528/cifor/001760.
[4] WUNDER S. Are Direct Payments for Environmental Services Spelling Doom for Sustainable Forest Management in the Tropics?[J].Ecology and Society, 2006, 11(2):23.
[5] WⅡNSCHER T, ENGEL S, WUNDER S. Payments for Environmental Services in Costa Rica:Increasing Efficiency Through Spatial Differentiation[J].Quarterly Journal of International Agriculture, 2006, 45(4):319-337.
[6] VAN NOORDWIJK M, LEIMONA B, EMERTON L, et al.Criteria and Indicators for Environmental Service Compensation and Reward Mechanisms:Realistic, Voluntary, Conditional and Pro-Poor ICRAF Working Paper No. 37[R] [. s.l.]:World Agroforestry CentreI (CRAF), 2007. DOI:10.5716/wp14964.pdf.
[7] TACCONI L.Redefining Payments for Environmental Services[J]. Ecological Economics, 2012, 73:29-36.
[8] 葛颜祥, 梁丽娟, 王蓓蓓, 等.黄河流域居民生态补偿意愿及支付水平分析:以山东省为例[J]. 中国农村经济, 2009(10):77-85.
[9] 郑海霞, 张陆彪, 涂勤.金华江流域生态服务补偿支付意愿及其影响因素分析[J]. 资源科学, 2010, 32(4):761-767.[ZHENG Hai-xia, ZHANG Lu-biao, TU Qin.Analysis of the People's Willingness to Pay for Environmental Services Compensation and Its Influence Factors in the Jinhua River Basin[J].Resources Science, 2010, 32(4):761-767.]
[10] 李晓平, 谢先雄, 赵敏娟.资本禀赋对农户耕地面源污染治理受偿意愿的影响分析[J]. 中国人口·资源与环境, 2018, 28(7):93-101[. LI Xiao-ping, XIE Xian-xiong, ZHAO Min-juan. Analysis About the Influence of Capital on the Willingness to Accept for Controlling the Nonpoint Pollution of Cultivated Land[J]. China Population, Resources and Environment, 2018, 28(7):93-101.]
[11] 李超显, 彭福清, 陈鹤.流域生态补偿支付意愿的影响因素分析:以湘江流域长沙段为例[J]. 经济地理, 2012, 32(4):130-135[. LI Chao-xian, PENG Fu-qing, CHEN He.Analysis of the Influencing Factors for Willingness to Pay of Payment for Ecosystem Services of River Basin:A Case of Changsha Reach of Xiang Jiang River Basin[J]. Economic Geography, 2012, 32(4):130-135.]
[12] 杜丽永, 蔡志坚, 杨加猛, 等.运用Spike模型分析CVM中零响应对价值评估的影响:以南京市居民对长江流域生态补偿的支付意愿为例[J]. 自然资源学报, 2013, 28(6):1007-1018.[DU Li-yong, CAI Zhi-jian, YANG Jia-meng, et al.Using Spike Model to Evaluate the Effect of Zero Responseon Welfare Measurement:Evidence From the Willingness to Pay for the Ecological Compensation of the Yangtze River Basin in Nanjing Section[J]. Journal of Natural Resources, 2013, 28(6):1007-1018.]
[13] 赵雪雁, 路慧玲, 刘霜, 等.甘南黄河水源补给区生态补偿农户参与意愿分析[J]. 中国人口·资源与环境, 2012, 22(4):96-101.[ZHAO Xue-yan, LU Hui-ling, LIU Shuang, et al.Analysis on Farmers' Willingness to Participate in Ecological Compensation:A Case of the Yellow River Water Supply Area of Gannan[J].China Population, Resources and Environment, 2012, 22(4):96-101.]
[14] 苏芳, 尚海洋, 聂华林.农户参与生态补偿行为意愿影响因素分析[J]. 中国人口·资源与环境, 2011, 21(4):119-125[. SU Fang, SHANG Hai yang, NIE Hua lin. Analysis of Influencing Factors to Farming Households' Willingness to Participate in Ecological Compensation[J].China Population, Resources and Environment, 2011, 21(4):119-125.]
[15] 张佰林, 杨庆媛, 苏康传, 等.基于生计视角的异质性农户转户退耕决策研究[J]. 地理科学进展, 2013, 32(2):170-180.[ZHANG Bai-lin, YANG Qing-yuan, SU Kang-chuan, et al.Heterogeneous Households' Decision on Household Registration Transferand Farmland Relinquishment:From Livelihood Perspective[J]. Progress in Geography, 2013, 32(2):170-180.]
[16] 李海燕, 蔡银莺.生计多样性对农户参与农田生态补偿政策响应状态的影响:以上海闵行区、苏州张家港市发达地区为例[J]. 自然资源学报, 2014, 29(10):1696-1708.[LI Hai-yan, CAI Yin ying. Livelihood Diversity and Farmer Participate in Farmland Ecological Compensation Policy Response:The Case Study of Minhang District, Shanghai and Zhangjiagang District, Suzhou[J]. Journal of Natural Resources, 2014, 29(10):1696-1708.]
[17] 徐建英, 孔明, 刘新新, 等.生计资本对农户再参与退耕还林意愿的影响:以卧龙自然保护区为例[J]. 生态学报, 2017, 37(18):6205-6215[. XU Jian-ying, KONG Ming, LIU Xin-xin, et al.The Effect of Livelihood Capital on the Willingness of Farmers to Re Enroll in the Grain for Green Program:A Case Study in Wolong Nature Reserve[J].Acta Ecologica Sinica, 2017, 37(18):6205-6215.]
[18] 张方圆, 赵雪雁, 田亚彪, 等.社会资本对农户生态补偿参与意愿的影响:以甘肃省张掖市、甘南藏族自治州、临夏回族自治州为例[J].资源科学, 2013, 35(9):1821-1827[. ZHANG Fangyuan, ZHAO Xue yan, TIAN Ya biao, et al. Social Capital and Farmer Willingness to Participate in Ecological Compensation for Three Sites in Gansu[J].Resources Science, 2013, 35(9):1821-1827.]
[19] 郭文献, 付意成, 张龙飞. 流域生态补偿社会资本模拟[J]. 中国人口·资源与环境, 2014, 24(7):18-22[. GUO Wen-xian, FU Yi-cheng, ZHANG Long-fei.Social Capital Simulation of Watershed Eco-Compensation[J].China Population, Resources and Environment, 2014, 24(7):18-22.]
[20] 张朝辉.新一轮退耕还林工程农户风险感知的影响因素分析:基于新疆阿克苏地区的调研数据[J].资源科学, 2018, 40(7):1387-1396[. ZHANG Zhao-hui.Factors Affecting Risk Perception of Farmers in the New Round Returning Farmland to Forest Project in the Aksu Region[J]. Resources Science, 2018, 40(7):1387-1396.]
[21] 杨庆媛, 曾黎, 廖俊儒, 等.休耕制度试点阶段经济补偿的绩效评估:以云南省样本户为例[J].经济地理, 2018, 38(12):143-152.[YANG Qing yuan, ZENG Li, LIAO Jun ru, et al. Performance Evaluation of Compensation in the Pilot Phase of Fallow System:Study on Fallow Samples From Yunnan Province[J]. Economic Geography, 2018, 38(12):143-152.]
[22] MUDACA J D, TSUCHIYA T, YAMADA M, et al.Household Participation in Payments for Ecosystem Services:A Case Study From Mozambique[J]. Forest Policy and Economics, 2015, 55:21-27.
[23] 刘玉卿, 张华兵.基于条件估值法(CVM) 的湿地周边农户受偿意愿及影响因素研究:以江苏盐城珍禽自然保护区为例[J]. 生态与农村环境学报, 2018, 34(11):982-987[. LIU Yu-qing, ZHANG Hua-bing.Discussion on Farmers' Willingness to Accept Compensation for Ecological Services and Its Influential Factors Based on CVM Method:A Case Study in Yancheng Rare Bird Nature Reserve[J]. Journal of Ecology and Rural Environment, 2018, 34(11):982-987.]
[24] JOHANSSON STENMAN O L O F, MAHMUD·MIN H A J, MARTINSSON P E T E R.Trust and Religion:Experimental Evidence From Rural Bangladesh[J]. Economica, 2009, 76(303):462-485.
[25] 阮荣平, 王兵. 差序格局下的宗教信仰和信任基于中国十城市的经验数据[J]. 社会, 2011, 31(4):195-217[. RUAN Rongping, WANG Bing.Religious Faith and Trust in the Differentiated Model of Association:The Empirical Evidence From 10 Cities in China[J]. Chinese Journal of Sociology, 2011, 31(4):195-217.]
[26] 王一超, 郝海广, 张惠远, 等.自然保护区农户参与生态补偿的意愿及其影响因素[J]. 生态与农村环境学报, 2016, 32(6):895-900[. WANG Yi-chao, HAO Hai-guang, ZHANG Hui-yuan, et al. Willingness of Farm Households in National Nature Reserves to Participate in Ecological Compensation and Its Affecting Factors[J].Journal of Ecology and Rural Environment, 2016, 32(6):895-900.]
[27] PAGIOLA S, RIOS A R, ARCENAS A.Can the Poor Participate in Payments for Environmental Services?Lessons From the Silvopastoral Project in Nicaragua[J]. Environment and Development Economics, 2007, 13(3):299-325.
[28] 姜波, 姚顺波, 王怡菲.农户参与公益林建设意愿影响因素的实证分析:基于广西、湖南、河南3省调查问卷[J].林业经济, 2011, 33(3):59-64[. JIANG Bo, YAO Shun-bo, WANG Yi-fei. Empirical Analysis of Factors Influencing on Households' Willingness of Participating in the Construction of PBW:Based on Field Survey in Guangxi, Hunan and Henan[J].Forestry Economics, 2011, 33(3):59-64.]
[29] 史恒通, 睢党臣, 吴海霞, 等.社会资本对农户参与流域生态治理行为的影响:以黑河流域为例[J].中国农村经济, 2018(1):34-45.
[30] 谭秋成. 关于生态补偿标准和机制[J]. 中国人口·资源与环境, 2009, 19(6):1-6[. TAN Qiu-cheng.Eco-Compensation Standard and Mechanism[J].China Population, Resources and Environment, 2009, 19(6):1-6.]
[31] 刘燕, 董耀.后退耕时代农户退耕还林意愿影响因素[J].经济地理, 2014, 34(2):131-138[. LIU Yan, DONG Yao.Factors Influencing Farmers Willingness to Participate in Grain for Green Project in the Post-Program Era[J].Economic Geography, 2014, 34(2):131-138.]
[32] 靳乐山.中国生态保护补偿机制政策框架的新扩展:《建立市场化、多元化生态保护补偿机制行动计划》的解读[J].环境保护, 2019, 47(2):28-30[. JIN Le-shan.Emerging Policy Framework on China's Market-Based and Diverse Ecological Compensation Mechanism[J]. Environmental Protection, 2019, 47(2):28-30.]
[33] 靳乐山.中国生态补偿:全领域探索与进展[M].北京:经济科学出版社, 2016:17-18[. JIN Le-shan.Advances of China EcoCompensation:Policies and Practices in All Sectors[M].Beijing:Economic Science Press, 2016:17-18.]
[34] 靳乐山, 吴乐. 我国生态补偿的成就、挑战与转型[J]. 环境保护, 2018, 46(24):7-13.[JIN Le-shan, WU Le.Achievements, Challenges and Transformation of China's Ecological Compensation[J].Environmental Protection, 2018, 46(24):7-13.]