重金属铅的土壤环境基准研究进展

doi:10.19741/j.issn.1673-4831.2018.0662

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 环境基准是环境标准制修订的科学依据，同时也是进行环境质量评价、环境风险控制和应急事故管理以及建立整个环境管理体系的科学基础，是国家环境保护和环境管理的基石与根本。从保护人体健康、保护生态安全和保护农产品安全3个方面综合分析了国内外重金属铅土壤环境基准的研究现状和主要技术要点，进一步展望了我国重金属铅土壤环境基准未来发展过程中面临的关键问题，以期为我国重金属铅土壤环境基准研究提出建议。

关键词: 铅, 土壤环境基准, 人体健康, 生态安全, 农产品安全

Abstract: Environmental criteria are the scientific basis for the revision of environmental standards, quality assessment, risk control, emergency accident management and the whole management system. They are also the foundation for national environment protection and management. The research status and main technical points of environmental criteria on heavy metal lead in soil at home and abroad were comprehensively analyzed from three aspects, human health, ecological safety and agricultural products safety. Possible key issues in its future development in China are further prospected so as to provide reference for the study of relevant environmental criteria in China.

Key words: lead, soil-environmental criteria, human health, ecological safety, agricultural products safety

中图分类号:

葛峰, 云晶晶, 徐坷坷, 张明珠, 许琳玥, 李焱, 张爱国. 重金属铅的土壤环境基准研究进展[J]. 生态与农村环境学报, 2019, 35(9): 1103-1110.

GE Feng, YUN Jing-jing, XU Ke-ke, ZHANG Ming-zhu, XU Lin-yue, LI Yan, ZHANG Ai-guo. Progress of Research on Environmental Criteria for Lead in Soil[J]. Journal of Ecology and Rural Environment, 2019, 35(9): 1103-1110.

参考文献

[1] HJ/T 332-2006,食用农产品产地环境质量评价标准[S].[HJ/T 332-2006,Environmental Quality Evaluation Standards for Farmland of Edible Agricultural Products[S].]
[2] HJ/T 333-2006,温室蔬菜产地环境质量评价标准[S].[HJ/T 333-2006,Environmental Quality Evaluation Standards for Farmland of Greenhouse Vegetables Production[S].]
[3] DB11/T 656-2009,场地环境评价导则[S].[DB11/T 656-2009,Environmental Site Assessment Guideline[S].]
[4] DB11/T 811-2011,场地土壤环境风险评价筛选值[S].[DB 11/T 811-2011,Screeing Levels for Soil Environmental Risk Assessment of Sites[S].]
[5] DB33/T 892-2013,污染场地风险评估技术导则[S].[DB 33/T 892-2013,Guideline for Risk Assessment of Contaminated Sites[S].]
[6] DB44/T 1415-2014,土壤重金属风险评价筛选值珠江三角洲[S].[DB 44/T 1415-2014,Risk Screening Values for Soil Heavy Metal The Pearl River Delta Area[S].]
[7] DB50/T 723-2016,场地土壤环境风险评估筛选值[S].[DB 50/T 723-2016,Soil Screening Levels for Environmental Risk Assessment of Sites[S].]
[8] GB 36600-2018,土壤环境质量建设用地土壤污染风险管控标准(试行)[S].[GB 36600-2018,Soil Environmental Quality Risk Control Standard for Soil Contamination of Development Land[S].]
[9] GB 15618-2018,土壤环境质量农用地土壤污染风险管控标准(试行)[S].[GB 15618-2018,Soil Environmental Quality Risk Control Standard for Soil Contamination of Agricultural Land[S].]
[10] 冯承莲,赵晓丽,侯红,等.中国环境基准理论与方法学研究进展及主要科学问题[J].生态毒理学报,2015,10(1):2-17.[FENG Cheng-lian,ZHAO Xiao-li,HOU Hong,et al.Research Progress and Main Scientific Problems of Theory and Methodology of China's Environmental Quality Criteria[J].Asian Journal of Ecotoxicology,2015,10(1):2-17.]
[11] FOSTER P M D,AUTON T R.Application of Benchmark Dose Risk Assessment Methodology to Developmental Toxicity:An Industrial View[J].Toxicology Letters,1995,82/83:555-559.
[12] DOURSON M L,HERTZBERG R C,HARTUNG R,et al.Novel Methods for the Estimation of Acceptable Daily Intake[J].Toxicology and Industrial Health,1985,1(4):23-41.
[13] REISS R,GAYLOR D.Use of Benchmark Dose and Meta-Analysis to Determine the Most Sensitive Endpoint for Risk Assessment for Dimethoate[J].Regulatory Toxicology and Pharmacology,2005,43(1):55-65.
[14] 王桂芳,郭会越,邹建芳,等.铅的神经毒性及其生物标志物的研究进展[J].工业卫生与职业病,2012,38(4):252-255.
[15] 王舜钦,张金良.我国儿童血铅水平分析研究[J].环境与健康杂志,2004,21(6):355-360.[WANG Shun-qin,ZHANG Jin-liang.Blood Lead Levels of Children in China[J].Journal of Environment and Health,2004,21(6):355-360.]
[16] DEFRA and Environment Agency.Contaminants in Soil:Collation of Toxicological Data and Intake Values for Humans:Lead[R].Swindon,UK:The R & D Dissemination Centre,2002:9-10.
[17] 杨珂玲,张宏志,张志刚,等.铅暴露的环境健康风险评估模型的本土化研究[J].中国人口·资源与环境,2016,26(2):163-169.[YANG Ke-ling,ZHANG Hong-zhi,ZHANG Zhi-gang,et al.Localization Study of Environmental Health Risk Assessment Model for Lead Exposure[J].China Population,Resources and Environment,2016,26(2):163-169.]
[18] 李梅,王齐,陈建伟,等.环境铅暴露健康风险评价三种PBPK模型的比较[J].中国社会医学杂志,2013,30(1):60-62.[LI Mei,WANG Qi,ZHOU Jian-wei,et al.Comparison of Three PBPK Models Used in Environmental Health Risk Assessment for Lead[J].Chinese Journal of Social Medicine,2013,30(1):60-62.]
[19] ZENG F,ALI S,ZHANG H T,et al.The Influence of pH and Organic Matter Content in Paddy Soil on Heavy Metal Availability and Their Uptake by Rice Plants[J].Environmental Pollution,2011,159(1):84-91.
[20] RÖMKENS P F A M,BRUS D J,GUO H Y,et al.Impact of Model Uncertainty on Soil Quality Standards for Cadmium in Rice Paddy Fields[J].Science of the Total Environment,2011,409(17):3098-3105.
[21] BRAND E,LIJZEN J,PEIJNENBURG W,et al.Possibilities of Implementation of Bioavailability Methods for Organic Contaminants in the Dutch Soil Quality Assessment Framework[J].Journal of Hazardous Materials,2013,261(13):833-839.
[22] U. S. EPA.Guidance Manual for the Integrated Exposure Uptake Biokinetic Model for Lead in Children[EB/OL].Publication Number 9285.7-15-1.EPA/540/R-93/081[2018-10-18].https://ntrl.ntis.gov/NTRL/dashboard/searchResults/titleDetail/PB93963510.xhtml.
[23] U. S. EPA.Estimation of Relative Bioavailability of Lead in Soil and Soil-Like Materials Using In Vivo and In Vitro Methods[EB/OL].OSWER 9285.7-77.[2018-10-18].https://nepis.epa.gov/Exe/ZyPURL.cgi?Dockey=P100FL1Q.txt.
[24] 张红振,骆永明,章海波,等.基于人体血铅指标的区域土壤环境铅基准值[J].环境科学,2009,30(10):3036-3042.[ZHANG Hong-zhen,LUO Yong-ming,ZHANG Hai-bo,et al.Development of Lead Benchmarks for Soil Based on Human Blood Lead Level in China[J].Environmental Science,2009,30(10):3036-3042.]
[25] 杨彦,李晓芳,王琼,等.基于人体健康模型(IEUBK、ALM)的温岭地区土壤环境铅基准值研究[J].环境科学学报,2014,34(7):1808-1817.[YANG Yan,LI Xiao-fang,WANG Qiong,et al.Lead Benchmarks for Soil Based on Human Health Model (IEUBK and ALM) in Wenling Region[J].Acta Scientiae Circumstantiae,2014,34(7):1808-1817.]
[26] 李灿,曾云,刘淑运,等.基于儿童和成人血铅模型的土壤环境铅基准值研究[J].环境与健康杂志,2017,34(9):789-793.[LI Can,ZENG Yun,LIU Shu-yun,et al.Lead Benchmarks for Soils Based on Blood Lead Model for Children and Adult in China[J].Journal of Environment and Health,2017,34(9):789-793.]
[27] 徐松.IEUBK模型结合流行病学调查的儿童环境铅暴露健康风险评估研究[D].武汉:华中科技大学,2011.[XU Song.Health Risk Assessment via IEUBK Model and Epidemiological Investigation for Environmental Lead Exposed Children[D].Wuhan:Huazhong University of Science and Technology,2011.]
[28] SUCCOP P,BORNSCHEIN R,BROWN K,et al.An Empirical Comparison of Lead Exposure Pathway Models[J].Environmental Health Perspectives,1998,106(Suppl. 6):1577-1583.
[29] 王金达,刘景双,于君宝,等.沈阳市城区土壤和灰尘中铅的分布特征[J].中国环境科学,2003,23(3):300-304.[WANG Jin-da,LIU Jing-shuang,YU Jun-bao,et al.The Distribution Character of Lead in Soil and Dust in Urban Region of Shenyang City[J].China Environmental Science,2003,23(3):300-304.]
[30] LANPHEAR B P,MATTE T D,ROGERS J,et al.The Contribution of Lead-Contaminated House Dust and Residential Soil to Children's Blood Lead Levels[J].Environmental Research,1998,79(1):51-68.
[31] 王国庆,骆永明,宋静,等.土壤环境质量指导值与标准研究:Ⅰ.国际动态及中国的修订考虑[J].土壤学报,2005,42(4):666-673.[WANG Guo-qing,LUO Yong-ming,SONG Jing,et al.Study on Soil Environmental Quality Guidelines and Standards:Ⅰ.International Trend and Suggestions for Amendment in China[J].Acta Pedologica Sinica,2005,42(4):666-673.]
[32] 郑丽萍,龙涛,冯艳红,等.基于生态风险的铅(Pb)土壤环境基准研究[J].生态与农村环境学报,2016,32(6):1030-1035.[ZHENG Li-ping,LONG Tao,FENG Yan-hong,et al.Environmental Quality Criteria for Lead in Soil Based on Ecological Risk[J].Journal of Ecology and Rural Environment,2016,32(6):1030-1035.]
[33] 颜增光,谷庆宝,周娟,等.构建土壤生态筛选基准的技术关键及方法学概述[J].生态毒理学报,2008,3(5):417-427.[YAN Zeng-guang,GU Qing-bao,ZHOU Juan,et al.A Synoptic Review of the Technical Tips and Methodologies for the Development of Ecological Soil Screening Benchmarks[J].Asian Journal of Ecotoxicology,2008,3(5):417-427.]
[34] BRAND E,LIJZEN J,PEIJNENBURG W,et al.Possibilities of Implementation of Bioavailability Methods for Organic Contaminants in the Dutch Soil Quality Assessment Framework[J].Journal of Hazardous Materials,2013,261:833-839.
[35] 王小庆,李菊梅,韦东普,等.土壤中铜生态阈值的影响因素及其预测模型[J].中国环境科学,2014,34(2):445-451.[WANG Xiao-qing,LI Ju-mei,WEI Dong-pu,et al.Major Soil Factors Affecting Ecological Threshold for Copper and the Predictable Models[J].China Environmental Science,2014,34(2):445-451.]
[36] 李波,马义兵,史奕.植物毒性评价终点的生物配体模型比较研究[J].环境科学与技术,2016,39(10):20-25,98.[LI Bo,MA Yi-bing,SHI Yi.The Comparisons of Biotic Ligand Model Based on Different Heavy Metals and Plant Toxicity Endpoints[J].Environmental Science & Technology,2016,39(10):20-25,98.]
[37] 陈苏,孙丽娜,晁雷,等.基于土壤酶活性变化的铅污染土壤修复基准[J].生态环境学报,2010,19(7):1659-1662.[CHEN Su,SUN Li-na,CHAO Lei,et al.Probabilistic Remediation Criterions of Contaminated Soil for Lead Derived From Soil Enzyme Activities[J].Ecology and Environmental Sciences,2010,19(7):1659-1662.]
[38] 王晓南,陈丽红,王婉华,等.保定潮土铅的生态毒性及其土壤环境质量基准推导[J].环境化学,2016,35(6):1219-1227.[WANG Xiao-nan,CHEN Li-hong,WANG Wan-hua,et al.Ecotoxicological Effect and Soil Environmental Quality Criteria of Lead in the Fluvo-Aquic Soil of Baoding[J].Environmental Chemistry,2016,35(6):1219-1227.]
[39] MCLAUGHLIN M,LOFTS S,WARNE M,et al.Derivation of Ecologically-Based Soil Standards for Trace Elements[M]//Soil Quality Standards for Trace Elements.[s. l.]:CRC Press,2010:7-80.DOI:10.1201/b10293-3.
[40] SMOLDERS E,OORTS K,SPRANG P V,et al.Toxicity of Trace Metals in Soil as Affected by Soil Type and Aging After Contamination:Using Calibrated Bioavailability Models to Set Ecological Soil Standards[J].Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry,2009,28(8):1633-1642.
[41] MA Y B,LOMBI E,NOLAN A L,et al.Long-Term Aging of Copper Added to Soils[J].Environmental Science & Technology,2006,40(20):6310-6317.
[42] 梁尧,李刚,仇建飞,等.土壤重金属污染对农产品质量安全的影响及其防治措施[J].农产品质量与安全,2013(3):9-14.
[43] 王新,吴燕玉.不同作物对重金属复合污染物吸收特性的研究[J].农业环境保护,1998(5):193-196.
[44] BRUS D J,DE GRYIJTER J J,RÖMKENS P F A M.Probabilistic Quality Standards for Heavy Metals in Soil Derived From Quality Standards in Crops[J].Geoderma,2005,128(3/4):301-311.
[45] BRUS D J,JANSEN M J.Uncertainty and Sensitivity Analysis of Spatial Predictions of Heavy Metals in Wheat[J].Journal of Environment Quality,2004,33(3):882-890.
[46] 张红振,骆永明,章海波,等.土壤环境质量指导值与标准研究:Ⅴ.镉在土壤-作物系统中的富集规律与农产品质量安全[J].土壤学报,2010,47(4):628-638.[ZHANG Hong-zhen,LUO Yong-ming,ZHANG Hai-bo,et al.Study on Soil Environmental Quality Guidelines and Standards:V.Modeling of Cadmium Uptake in Soil-Crop Systems for Human Food Safety in China[J].Acta Pedologica Sinica,2010,47(4):628-638.]
[47] BRUS D J,LI Z B,SONG J,et al.Predictions of Spatially Averaged Cadmium Contents in Rice Grains in the Fuyang Valley,P. R. China[J].Journal of Environment Quality,2009,38(3):1126-1136.
[48] 陈同斌,宋波,郑袁明,等.北京市菜地土壤和蔬菜铅含量及其健康风险评估[J].中国农业科学,2006,39(8):1589-1597.[CHEN Tong-bin,SONG Bo,ZHENG Yuan-ming,et al.A Survey of Lead Concentrations in Vegetables and Soils in Beijing and Their Health Risks[J].Scientia Agricultura Sinica,2006,39(8):1589-1597.]
[49] SCHLEKAT C E,VAV GENDEREN E,DE SCHAMPHELAERE K A C,et al.Cross-Species Extrapolation of Chronic Nickel Biotic Ligand Models[J].Science of the Total Environment,2010,408(24):6148-6157.
[50] MA Y B,LOMBI E,MCLAUGHLIN M J,et al.Aging of Nickel Added to Soils as Predicted by Soil pH and Time[J].Chemosphere,2013,92(8):962-968.
[51] 宋静,骆永明,夏家淇.我国农用地土壤环境基准与标准制定研究[J].环境保护科学,2016,42(4):29-35.[SONG Jing,LUO Yong-ming,XIA Jia-qi.Study of the Development of Environmental Criteria and Standards for Agricultural Lands in China[J].Environmental Protection Science,2016,42(4):29-35.]
[52] 王小庆.中国农业土壤中铜和镍的生态阈值研究[D].北京:中国矿业大学,2012.[WANG Xiao-qing.Ecological Thresholds for Copper and Nickel in Chinese Agricultural Soils[D].Beijing:China University of Mining and Technology,2012.]