基于最小累积阻力模型的生态安全格局构建研究进展

doi:10.19741/j.issn.1673-4831.2020.0850

摘要/Abstract

摘要： “山水林田湖草是生命共同体”理念强调生态系统修复的整体性。构建生态安全格局可以连接破碎生境，提高景观连通性，优化生态网络，进而维护区域生态安全。采用文献分析法，以"格局要素规划与设计-源地识别-阻力面设置与修正-廊道提取-格局优化与有效性评价-研究成果应用"为逻辑线，系统梳理基于最小累积阻力模型构建生态安全格局的各重要环节，整理和分析当前各环节研究要点和存在问题，提出未来研究方向的建议。结果表明：（1）生态源地识别应采取直接识别与间接识别相结合的方式，满足实践中管理监督的需求；（2）目前阻力面构建方式主要有基于土地覆被/土地类型打分赋值和基于生态系统服务赋值2种，分别存在主观性较强和适用性较差的缺陷，应完善相关指标体系，提高生态阻力面赋值科学性；（3）生态网络相较于生态保护红线更加强调景观连通性，可以通过生态廊道和生态节点优化生态保护红线布局；（4）最小累积阻力模型相较于其他方法具有适用性较强和兼容性较好的优势，但未来仍需加强多路径分析和生态节点的研究，更加注重研究对象空间尺度的差异性，提高模型的客观性和适用性。

关键词: 土地生态, 生态安全格局, 最小累积阻力模型, 生态廊道, 生态网络

Abstract: The existence of mountains-rivers-forests-farmlands-lakes-grasslands systems emphasises the need for ecosystem integrity and reflects the relationships among natural ecosystems. The construction of ecological security pattern can connect fragmented habitats, thereby improving the stability of the ecosystem and maintaining regional ecological security. Using the literature analysis method, the logical line of "planning and design of pattern elements-sources identification-resistance surface setting and modification-corridor extraction-pattern optimization and effectiveness evaluation-application of research results" was taken for combing out each important link in constructing ecological security pattern based on minimum cumulative resistance model, clearing and analyzing the current research points and existing problems of each link, so as to make suggestions and to point out the direction of future development. The results show that: (1) For the identification of ecological sources, a combination of direct and indirect identification should be adopted to meet the needs of management and supervision in practice. (2) At present, resistance surface construction methods mainly include scoring assignment based on land cover and ecosystem service assignment, which have the disadvantages of strong subjectivity and poor applicability. Relevant index systems should be improved to promote the scientific nature of the ecological resistance surface assignment; (3) Compared with the ecological red line, the ecological network emphasises the connectivity of the landscape. The layout of the ecological red line can be optimised through corridors and nodes. (4) Compared with other methods, the minimum cumulative resistance model has the advantages of applicability and compatibility. However, in the future, it is still necessary to strengthen the researches on multi-path analysis and ecological nodes, pay more attention to the difference of the spatial scale of the research object, and improve the objectivity and applicability of the model.

Key words: land ecology, ecological security pattern, minimum cumulative resistance model, ecological corridor, ecological network

中图分类号:

X826

杨凯, 曹银贵, 冯喆, 耿冰瑾, 冯漪, 王舒菲. 基于最小累积阻力模型的生态安全格局构建研究进展[J]. 生态与农村环境学报, 2021, 37(5): 555-565.

YANG Kai, CAO Yin-gui, FENG Zhe, GENG Bing-jin, FENG Yi, WANG Shu-fei. Research Progress of Ecological Security Pattern Construction Based on Minimum Cumulative Resistance Model[J]. Journal of Ecology and Rural Environment, 2021, 37(5): 555-565.

参考文献

[1] 白中科,周伟,王金满,等.试论国土空间整体保护、系统修复与综合治理[J].中国土地科学,2019,33(2):1-11.[BAI Zhong-ke,ZHOU Wei,WANG Jin-man,et al.Overall Protection,Systematic Restoration and Comprehensive Management of Land Space［J].China Land Science,2019,33(2):1-11.］
[2] 俞孔坚.生态安全格局与国土空间开发格局优化[J].景观设计学,2016,4(5):6-9.[YU Kong-jian.Ecological Security Pattern and Spatial Development Pattern Optimization of National Territory［J].Landscape Architecture Frontiers,2016,4(5):6-9.］
[3] 陈美球,洪土林.国土空间生态修复内涵剖析[J].中国土地,2020(6):23-25.
[4] 王回茴,李汉廷,谢苗苗,等.资源型城市工矿用地系统修复的生态安全格局构建[J].自然资源学报,2020,35(1):162-173.[WANG Hui-hui,LI Han-ting,XIE Miao-miao,et al.Construction of Ecological Security Pattern for Systematic Restoration of Industrial and Mining Land in Resource-based Cities［J].Journal of Natural Resources,2020,35(1):162-173.］
[5] 陈昕,彭建,刘焱序,等.基于"重要性-敏感性-连通性"框架的云浮市生态安全格局构建[J].地理研究,2017,36(3):471-484.[CHEN Xin,PENG Jian,LIU Yan-xu,et al.Constructing Ecological Security Patterns in Yunfu City Based on the Framework of Importance-sensitivity-connectivity［J].Geographical Research,2017,36(3):471-484.］
[6] 俞孔坚.生物保护的景观生态安全格局[J].生态学报,1999,19(1):8-15.[YU Kong-jian.Landscape Ecological Security Patterns in Biological Conservation［J].Acta Ecologica Sinica,1999,19(1):8-15.］
[7] 叶鑫,邹长新,刘国华,等.生态安全格局研究的主要内容与进展[J].生态学报,2018,38(10):3382-3392.[YE Xin,ZOU Chang-xin,LIU Guo-hua,et al.Main Research Contents and Advances in the Ecological Security Pattern［J].Acta Ecologica Sinica,2018,38(10):3382-3392.］
[8] 谭华清.国土空间总体规划中生态保护格局构建的思考:以南京市为例[EB/OL].[2020-01-07].https://www.guoturen.com/guihua-69.html.
[9] 彭建,赵会娟,刘焱序,等.区域生态安全格局构建研究进展与展望[J].地理研究,2017,36(3):407-419.[PENG Jian,ZHAO Hui-juan,LIU Yan-xu,et al.Research Progress and Prospect on Regional Ecological Security Pattern Construction［J].Geographical Research,2017,36(3):407-419.］
[10] 王媛,周长威.黔中城市群景观生态安全格局构建[J].生态与农村环境学报,2019,35(9):1111-1117.[WANG Yuan,ZHOU Chang-wei.Landscape Ecological Security Pattern in Central Guizhou Urban Agglomeration［J].Journal of Ecology and Rural Environment,2019,35(9):1111-1117.］
[11] 陈德权,兰泽英,李玮麒.基于最小累积阻力模型的广东省陆域生态安全格局构建[J].生态与农村环境学报,2019,35(7):826-835.[CHEN De-quan,LAN Ze-ying,LI Wei-qi.Construction of Land Ecological Security in Guangdong Province from the Perspective of Ecological Demand［J].Journal of Ecology and Rural Environment,2019,35(7):826-835.］
[12] 黄木易,岳文泽,冯少茹,等.基于MCR模型的大别山核心区生态安全格局异质性及优化[J].自然资源学报,2019,34(4):771-784.[HUANG Mu-yi,YUE Wen-ze,FENG Shao-ru,et al.Analysis of Spatial Heterogeneity of Ecological Security Based on MCR Model and Ecological Pattern Optimization in the Yuexi County of the Dabie Mountain Area［J].Journal of Natural Resources,2019,34(4):771-784.］
[13] 李政,丁忆,王亚林,等.基于最小累积阻力模型的山地石漠化地区生态安全格局构建:以重庆市南川区为例[J].生态与农村环境学报,2020,36(8):1046-1054.[LI Zheng,DING Yi,WANG Ya-lin,et al.Construction of Ecological Security Pattern in Mountain Rocky Desertification Area Based on MCR Model:A Case Study of Nanchuan,Chongqing［J].Journal of Ecology and Rural Environment,2020,36(8):1046-1054.］
[14] LIU X Y,WEI M,ZENG J.Simulating Urban Growth Scenarios Based on Ecological Security Pattern:A Case Study in Quanzhou,China[J].International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health,2020,17(19):7282.
[15] 倪庆琳,丁忠义,侯湖平,等.基于电路理论的生态格局识别与保护研究:以宁武县为例[J].干旱区资源与环境,2019,33(5):67-73.[NI Qing-lin,DING Zhong-yi,HOU Hu-ping,et al.Ecological Pattern Recognition and Protection Based on Circuit Theory［J].Journal of Arid Land Resources and Environment,2019,33(5):67-73.］
[16] PENG J,YANG Y,LIU Y X,et al.Linking Ecosystem Services and Circuit Theory to Identify Ecological Security Patterns[J].Science of the Total Environment,2018,644:781-790.
[17] WANG C X,YU C Y,CHEN T Q,et al.Can the Establishment of Ecological Security Patterns Improve Ecological Protection?an Example of Nanchang,China[J].Science of the Total Environment,2020,740:140051.
[18] HUANG J M,HU Y C,ZHENG F Y.Research on Recognition and Protection of Ecological Security Patterns Based on Circuit Theory:A Case Study of Jinan City[J].Environmental Science and Pollution Research,2020,27(11):12414-12427.
[19] 孔繁花,尹海伟.济南城市绿地生态网络构建[J].生态学报,2008,28(4):1711-1719.[KONG Fan-hua,YIN Hai-wei.Developing Green Space Ecological Networks in Jinan City［J].Acta Ecologica Sinica,2008,28(4):1711-1719.］
[20] 杜腾飞,齐伟,朱西存,等.基于生态安全格局的山地丘陵区自然资源空间精准识别与管制方法[J].自然资源学报,2020,35(5):1190-1200.[DU Teng-fei,QI Wei,ZHU Xi-cun,et al.Precise Identification and Control Method of Natural Resources Space Based on Ecological Security Pattern in Mountainous Hilly Area［J].Journal of Natural Resources,2020,35(5):1190-1200.］
[21] 曲艺,陆明.生态网络规划研究进展与发展趋势[J].城市发展研究,2016,23(8):29-36.[QU Yi,LU Ming.Research Progress and Development Trend of Ecological Network Planning［J].Urban Development Studies,2016,23(8):29-36.］
[22] CHATZIMENTOR A,APOSTOLOPOULOU E,MAZARIS A D.A Review of Green Infrastructure Research in Europe:Challenges and Opportunities[J].Landscape and Urban Planning,2020,198:103775.
[23] 陈星,周成虎.生态安全:国内外研究综述[J].地理科学进展,2005,24(6):8-20.[CHEN Xing,ZHOU Cheng-hu.Review of the Studies on Ecological Security［J].Progress in Geography,2005,24(6):8-20.］
[24] 王晓玉,陈甜倩,冯喆,等.基于地类边界分析的江苏省生态安全格局构建[J].生态学报,2020,40(10):3375-3384.[WANG Xiao-yu,CHEN Tian-qian,FENG Zhe,et al.Construction of Ecological Security Pattern Based on Boundary Analysis:A Case Study on Jiangsu Province［J].Acta Ecologica Sinica,2020,40(10):3375-3384.］
[25] 史芳宁,刘世梁,安毅,等.基于生态网络的山水林田湖草生物多样性保护研究:以广西左右江为例[J].生态学报,2019,39(23):8930-8938.[SHI Fang-ning,LIU Shi-liang,AN Yi,et al.Biodiversity Conservation of Mountains-rivers-forests-farmlands-lakes-grasslands Using an Ecological Network:A Case Study on the Zuoyoujiang River Basin in Guangxi Province,China［J].Acta Ecologica Sinica,2019,39(23):8930-8938.］
[26] 彭建,郭小楠,胡熠娜,等.基于地质灾害敏感性的山地生态安全格局构建:以云南省玉溪市为例[J].应用生态学报,2017,28(2):627-635.[PENG Jian,GUO Xiao-nan,HU Yi-na,et al.Constructing Ecological Security Patterns in Mountain Areas Based on Geological Disaster Sensitivity:A Case Study in Yuxi City,Yunnan Province,China［J].Chinese Journal of Applied Ecology,2017,28(2):627-635.］
[27] 毛诚瑞,代力民,齐麟,等.基于生态系统服务的流域生态安全格局构建:以辽宁省辽河流域为例[J].生态学报,2020,40(18):6486-6494.[MAO Cheng-rui,DAI Li-min,QI Lin,et al.Constructing Ecological Security Pattern Based on Ecosystem Services:A Case Study in Liaohe River Basin,Liaoning Province,China［J].Acta Ecologica Sinica,2020,40(18):6486-6494.］
[28] 谢高地,张彩霞,张雷明,等.基于单位面积价值当量因子的生态系统服务价值化方法改进[J].自然资源学报,2015,30(8):1243-1254.[XIE Gao-di,ZHANG Cai-xia,ZHANG Lei-ming,et al.Improvement of the Evaluation Method for Ecosystem Service Value Based on Per Unit Area［J].Journal of Natural Resources,2015,30(8):1243-1254.］
[29] ZHANG B,LI W H,XIE G D.Ecosystem Services Research in China:Progress and Perspective[J].Ecological Economics,2010,69(7):1389-1395.
[30] YU Zhong-yuan,BI Hua.The Key Problems and Future Direction of Ecosystem Services Research[J].Energy Procedia,2011,5:64-68.
[31] YU Zhong-yuan,BI Hua.Status Quo of Research on Ecosystem Services Value in China and Suggestions to Future Research[J].Energy Procedia,2011,5:1044-1048.
[32] SHI Y,WANG R S,HUANG J L,et al.An Analysis of the Spatial and Temporal Changes in Chinese Terrestrial Ecosystem Service Functions[J].Chinese Science Bulletin,2012,57(17):2120-2131.
[33] 雷捷,闫晓云.基于景观生态学的城市绿地系统规划布局评价:以包头市城区为例[J].内蒙古农业大学学报(自然科学版),2007,28(4):248-253.[LEI Jie,YAN Xiao-yun.The Appraisal of Urban Green Space Sysytem Planning Based on the Principles of Landscape Ecology:A Case Study of Baotou City［J].Journal of Inner Mongolia Agricultural University (Natural Science Edition),2007,28(4):248-253.］
[34] FORMAN R T T,GODRON M.Landscpae Ecology[M].New York,USA:Wiley,1986:121-155.
[35] 朱强,俞孔坚,李迪华.景观规划中的生态廊道宽度[J].生态学报,2005,25(9):2406-2412.[ZHU Qiang,YU Kong-jian,LI Di-hua.The Width of Ecological Corridor in Landscape Planning［J].Acta Ecologica Sinica,2005,25(9):2406-2412.］
[36] FU Y J,SHI X Y,HE J,et al.Identification and Optimization Strategy of County Ecological Security Pattern:A Case Study in the Loess Plateau,China[J].Ecological Indicators,2020,112:106030.
[37] PENG J,ZHAO H J,LIU Y X.Urban Ecological Corridors Construction:A Review[J].Acta Ecologica Sinica,2017,37(1):23-30.
[38] 滕明君,周志翔,王鹏程,等.基于结构设计与管理的绿色廊道功能类型及其规划设计重点[J].生态学报,2010,30(6):1604-1614.[TENG Ming-jun,ZHOU Zhi-xiang,WANG Peng-cheng,et al.The Function Types of Green Corridor and the Key Issues in Its Planning Based Upon Structure Design and Management［J].Acta Ecologica Sinica,2010,30(6):1604-1614.］
[39] FALCY M R,ESTADES C F.Effectiveness of Corridors Relative to Enlargement of Habitat Patches[J].Conservation Biology,2007,21(5):1341-1346.
[40] PARDINI R,DE SOUZA S M,BRAGA-NETO R,et al.The Role of Forest Structure,Fragment Size and Corridors in Maintaining Small Mammal Abundance and Diversity in an Atlantic Forest Landscape[J].Biological Conservation,2005,124(2):253-266.
[41] SINCLAIR K E,HESS G R,MOORMAN C E,et al.Mammalian Nest Predators Respond to Greenway Width,Landscape Context and Habitat Structure[J].Landscape and Urban Planning,2005,71(2/3/4):277-293.
[42] 褚琳,张欣然,王天巍,等.基于CA-Markov和InVEST模型的城市景观格局与生境质量时空演变及预测[J].应用生态学报,2018,29(12):4106-4118.[CHU Lin,ZHANG Xin-ran,WANG Tian-wei,et al.Spatial-temporal Evolution and Prediction of Urban Landscape Pattern and Habitat Quality Based on CA-Markov and InVEST Model［J].Chinese Journal of Applied Ecology,2018,29(12):4106-4118.］
[43] 彭建,李慧蕾,刘焱序,等.雄安新区生态安全格局识别与优化策略[J].地理学报,2018,73(4):701-710.[PENG Jian,LI Hui-lei,LIU Yan-xu,et al.Identification and Optimization of Ecological Security Pattern in Xiong'an New Area［J].Acta Geographica Sinica,2018,73(4):701-710.］
[44] 吴健生,张理卿,彭建,等.深圳市景观生态安全格局源地综合识别[J].生态学报,2013,33(13):4125-4133.[WU Jian-sheng,ZHANG Li-qing,PENG Jian,et al.The Integrated Recognition of the Source Area of the Urban Ecological Security Pattern in Shenzhen［J].Acta Ecologica Sinica,2013,33(13):4125-4133.］
[45] 刘壮壮,吴未,刘文锋,等.基于"源地-廊道"生态安全格局构建逻辑范式的建设用地减量化研究[J].生态学报,2020,40(22):8230-8238.[LIU Zhuang-zhuang,WU Wei,LIU Wen-feng,et al.Study on Construction Land Reduction Based on "Source-corridor" Ecological Security Pattern Paradigm［J].Acta Ecologica Sinica,2020,40(22):8230-8238.］
[46] 杨彦昆,王勇,程先,等.基于连通度指数的生态安全格局构建:以三峡库区重庆段为例[J].生态学报,2020,40(15):5124-5136.[YANG Yan-kun,WANG Yong,CHENG Xian,et al.Establishment of an Ecological Security Pattern Based on Connectivity Index:A Case Study of the Three Gorges Reservoir Area in Chongqing［J].Acta Ecologica Sinica,2020,40(15):5124-5136.］
[47] 汤峰,王力,张蓬涛,等.基于生态保护红线和生态网络的县域生态安全格局构建[J].农业工程学报,2020,36(9):263-272.[TANG Feng,WANG Li,ZHANG Peng-tao,et al.Construction of County-level Ecological Security Pattern Based on Ecological Protection Red Line and Network in China［J].Transactions of the Chinese Society of Agricultural Engineering,2020,36(9):263-272.］
[48] 杜悦悦,胡熠娜,杨旸,等.基于生态重要性和敏感性的西南山地生态安全格局构建:以云南省大理白族自治州为例[J].生态学报,2017,37(24):8241-8253.[DU Yue-yue,HU Yi-na,YANG Yang,et al.Building Ecological Security Patterns in Southwestern Mountainous Areas Based on Ecological Importance and Ecological Sensitivity:A Case Study of Dali Bai Autonomous Prefecture,Yunnan Province［J].Acta Ecologica Sinica,2017,37(24):8241-8253.］
[49] 李恒凯,刘玉婷,李芹,等.基于MCR模型的南方稀土矿区生态安全格局分析[J].地理科学,2020,40(6):989-998.[LI Heng-kai,LIU Yu-ting,LI Qin,et al.Analysis of Ecological Security Pattern of Southern Rare Earth Mining Area Based on MCR Model［J].Scientia Geographica Sinica,2020,40(6):989-998.］
[50] 刘杰,叶晶,杨婉,等.基于GIS的滇池流域景观格局优化[J].自然资源学报,2012,27(5):801-808.[LIU Jie,YE Jing,YANG Wan,et al.A GIS-Based Landscape Pattern Optimization Approach for Lake Dianchi Watershed［J].Journal of Natural Resources,2012,27(5):801-808.］
[51] 叶玉瑶,苏泳娴,张虹鸥,等.生态阻力面模型构建及其在城市扩展模拟中的应用[J].地理学报,2014,69(4):485-496.[YE Yu-yao,SU Yong-xian,ZHANG Hong-ou,et al.Ecological Resistance Surface Model and Its Application in Urban Expansion Simulations［J].Acta Geographica Sinica,2014,69(4):485-496.］
[52] 傅伯杰,陈利顶,马克明.景观生态学原理及应用[M].2版.北京:科学出版社,2011:1-396.
[53] KONG F H,YIN H W,NAKAGOSHI N,et al.Urban Green Space Network Development for Biodiversity Conservation:Identification Based on Graph Theory and Gravity Modeling[J].Landscape and Urban Planning,2010,95(1/2):16-27.
[54] 梁艳艳,赵银娣.基于景观分析的西安市生态网络构建与优化[J].应用生态学报,2020,31(11):3767-3776.[LIANG Yan-yan,ZHAO Yin-di.Construction and Optimization of Ecological Network in Xi'an Based on Landscape Analysis［J].Chinese Journal of Applied Ecology,2020,31(11):3767-3776.］
[55] 俞孔坚,王思思,李迪华,等.北京市生态安全格局及城市增长预景[J].生态学报,2009,29(3):1189-1204.[YU Kong-jian,WANG Si-si,LI Di-hua,et al.The Function of Ecological Security Patterns as an Urban Growth Framework in Beijing［J].Acta Ecologica Sinica,2009,29(3):1189-1204.］
[56] 贾艳红,赵军,南忠仁,等.基于熵权法的草原生态安全评价:以甘肃牧区为例[J].生态学杂志,2006,25(8):1003-1008.[JIA Yan-hong,ZHAO Jun,NAN Zhong-ren,et al.Ecological Safety Assessment of Grassland Based on Entropy-right Method:A Case Study of Gansu Pastoral Area［J].Chinese Journal of Ecology,2006,25(8):1003-1008.］
[57] 王海鹰,秦奋,张新长,等.基于蚁群优化算法的城市生态用地空间规划模型[J].地理科学,2017,37(3):426-436.[WANG Hai-ying,QIN Fen,ZHANG Xin-chang,et al.The Spatial Planning Model of Urban Ecological Land Based on Ant Colony Optimization Algorithm［J].Scientia Geographica Sinica,2017,37(3):426-436.］
[58] DONG J Q,PENG J,LIU Y X,et al.Integrating Spatial Continuous Wavelet Transform and Kernel Density Estimation to Identify Ecological Corridors in Megacities[J].Landscape and Urban Planning,2020,199:103815.