生态与农村环境学报 ›› 2015, Vol. 31 ›› Issue (4): 608-616.doi: 10.11934/j.issn.1673-4831.2015.04.026

• 研究方法 • 上一篇    

基于污染物削减效果和成本的农业面源污染控制技术优选——以太湖地区为例

刘莉,胡正义   

  1. 中国科学院大学资源与环境学院/中丹学院
  • 收稿日期:2014-12-19 修回日期:2015-02-15 出版日期:2015-07-25 发布日期:2015-07-25
  • 通讯作者: 胡正义 E-mail:zhyhu@ucas.ac.cn
  • 作者简介:刘莉(1989-),女,甘肃陇南人,硕士生,主要从事面源污染控制技术研究。E—mail:liuli13@mails.ucas.ac.cn
  • 基金资助:

    中国科学院重点部署项目(KZZD-EW-10-04-2)

Selection of Optimal Agricultural Non-Point Source Pollution Prevention and Control Techniques Based on Effect and Cost of Their Pollution Reduction: A Case Study of the Taihu Region

LIU Li,HU Zheng-yi   

  1. College of Resources and Environment / Sino-Danish College,University of Chinese Academy of Sciences
  • Received:2014-12-19 Revised:2015-02-15 Online:2015-07-25 Published:2015-07-25

摘要:

农业面源面源污染控制既要考虑技术对污染物的削减效果,也要兼顾工程建设-运行成本。以我国近20 a来农业(种植业、畜禽养殖业、水产养殖业)面源污染控制具有代表性的73种技术为对象,根据指标(总氮、总磷、氨氮、COD削减率,建设成本,运行成本)完整性等因素初步选择了12种技术,采用层次-灰色关联度法选择兼顾污染物削减率和成本的最适技术。结果表明:种植业污染控制技术中以农田排水植物-微生物复合处理技术为最好,其次是生态拦截沟渠技术;畜禽养殖业面源污染控制技术中以养殖废水土地渗滤处理系统为最好,其次是人工湿地技术;水产养殖业污染控制技术中以组合填料序批式生物膜法为最好,其次是生物-生态复合处理技术。针对太湖地区实际情况,生态拦截沟渠技术更适合该地区农田排水污染控制,土地渗滤处理系统可用于太湖上游地区畜禽养殖业废水处理,组合填料序批式生物膜法可以用于水产养殖排水处理。所提出的层次-灰色关联度法可满足兼顾污染物削减和工程建设-运行成本的面源污染控制技术比选和决策需求。

关键词: 太湖地区, 农业面源污染, 污染物削减, 灰色关联度分析法, 层次分析法

Abstract:

In preventing and controlling agricultural non-point source pollution,it is essential to take into account both pollution reducing effect of a technique and engineering construction-operation costs of the technique. AHP (analytical hierarchy process) coupled with GRAP (grey correlation degree process)  was used to select the most suitable ones out of the73 typical technologies for preventing and controlling agricultural (planting,livestock and poultry breeding,aquaculture) non-point source pollution available in the past 20 years in China. A total of 12 were obtained preliminarily in the light of pollutants (TN,TP,NH3-N,COD) reducing effects and construction-operation costs. Results show that for controlling non-point source pollution from farming,the technology of plant-microbe complex for treating field drainage is the best and followed by the technology of ecological buffering ditches; for controlling non-point source pollution from livestock an poultry breeding,the technology of wastewater land filtering system is the best and followed by the technology of artificial wetlands; and for controlling non-point source pollution from aquaculture,the technology of complex filling sequencing batch biofilm reactor is the best and followed by the technology of complex biological-ecological treatment. In light of the actual situation of the Taihu region,the technology of ecological buffering ditches is very suitable for controlling agricultural nonpoint source pollution with field drainage,the technology of wastewater land filtering system is treating wastewater from livestock and poultry breeding in the upper stream of the Taihu Lake Region,and the technology of complex filling sequencing batch biofilm reactor is for treating waste water from aquaculture. The AHP-GRAP method used in the selection is good enough to meet the demand for consideration of both pollution reducing effects and construction-operation costs in comparing and selecting agricultural non-point source pollution control technologies.

Key words: Taihu Lake Region, agricultural non-point source pollution, reduction of pollutants, analytical hierarchy process, grey correlation degree process