生物完整性指数及其在水生态健康评价中的应用进展

doi:10.11934/j.issn.1673-4831.2016.04.001

摘要/Abstract

摘要：

生物完整性指数（index of biotic integrity, IBI）是用以度量区域生物集群维持物种组成、多样性、结构和功能稳态能力的量化指标，经过30多年的发展，已成为水生态健康定量评价的热门方法。IBI是将具有不同敏感性的多项度量指标复合而得的一个数值，其理论基础是生态学与数学，涉及生物学和环境科学等其他多门学科。IBI作为一种定量分析方法，其理论技术体系仍在不断发展演化，关键技术环节为参照位点选取、度量指标筛选以及指标赋权和复合，各环节的实现存在多种观点和方法。基于大量监测数据的预测模型研究是目前国际学界的研究热点，但我国学界尚未见IBI预测模型的研究报道。除了传统的F-IBI（鱼类IBI）、B-IBI（底栖动物IBI）、A-IBI（固着藻类IBI）、P-IBI（浮游生物IBI）和AP-IBI（水生植物IBI），已有学者提出M-IBI（微生物IBI），基于上述单类群IBI（s-IBI）的研究成果，多类群IBI（m-IBI）将成为今后重要的研究方向。IBI的应用目的可分为水生态健康定量评价、水生态对人类干扰响应的定量分析和预测水生态健康状况。认为IBI具有定量化、对象依赖性、学科交叉性、标准化趋势和系统误差性的特点，IBI在农村河道、灌区和农田生态健康评价领域是一种极具前景的方法。

关键词: 生物完整性指数, 水生态健康, 定量分析, 预测模型, 进展

Abstract:

Index of biotic integrity (IBI) is a quantitative one, often used to scale the abilities of aquatic biocoenoses to maintain species composition, diversity, structure and function stability. IBI has been gradually developing in the past 30 years and now into one of the most important indices to quantitatively assess aquatic ecological health. IBI is a numerical value, which is acquired by integrating a number of measuring indices different in sensitivity, and relies on ecology and mathematics as its theoretical foundation, and some other disciplines, too, like biology, environmental science, etc.. IBI being a quantitative analysis method, its theoretical and technical system keeps on developing and evolving and its key technical links lie in selecting reference sites, screening measuring indices, empowering and recombining the indices, for materialization of these links exists a variety of ideas and methods. Research on prediction models based on large volumes of monitoring data is a hot spot topic in the current international academia. However, little has been reported about the IBI prediction models in China. In addition to the traditional F-IBI (fish-based IBI), B-IBI (benthod-based IBI), A-IBI (sessile algae-based IBI), P-IBI (plankton-based IBI) and AP-IBI (aquatic plant-based IBI), some scholars have put forth M-IBI (microbe-based IBI). Based on the above-listed findings in the study on s-IBI (single group-based IBI), the study on m-IBI (multi-group-based IBI) will be an important target of future researches. The purposes of applying IBI can be described as quantitative analysis of water ecological health, quantitative analysis of responses of water ecology to human disturbances, and prediction of water ecological health. The authors hold that IBI can be characterized by quantitativeness, object dependence, interdisciplinarity, standardizing trend and systematic deviation, and that IBI is a promising method for ecological health assessment of rural rivers, irrigation districts and farmlands.

Key words: IBI, water ecological health, quantitative analysis, forecasting model, progress

中图分类号:

X826
S19

王为木, 蔡旺炜. 生物完整性指数及其在水生态健康评价中的应用进展[J]. 生态与农村环境学报, 2016, 32(4): 517-524.

WANG Wei-mu, CAI Wang-wei. Index of Biotic Integrity and Its Application to Aquatic Ecological Health Assessment[J]. Journal of Ecology and Rural Environment, 2016, 32(4): 517-524.

参考文献

[1] 王根绪,程国栋,钱鞠.生态安全评价研究中的若干问题[J].应用生态学报,2003,14(9):1551-1556.
[2] 沈韫芬,蔡庆华.淡水生态系统中的复杂性问题[J].中国科学院研究生院学报,2003,20(2):131-138.
[3] KARR J R.Assessment of Biotic Integrity Using Fish Communities[J].Fisheries,1981,6(6):21-27.
[4] 王备新,杨莲芳,刘正文.生物完整性指数与水生态系统健康评价[J].生态学杂志,2006,25(6):707-710.
[5] KARR J R,CHU E W.Sustaining Living Rivers[J].Hydrobiologia,2000,422:1-14.
[6] 戈峰.现代生态学[M].北京:科学出版社,2008:304-305.
[7] RAPPORT D J,GAUDET C,KARR J R,et al.Evaluating Landscape Heath:Integrating Societal Goals and Biophysical Process[J].Journal of Environmental Management,1998,53(1):1-15.
[8] FORE L S,KARR J R,WISSEMAN R W.Assessing Invertebrate Responses to Human Activities:Evaluating Alternative Approaches[J].Journal of the North American Benthological Society,1996,15(2):212-231.
[9] 廖静秋,黄艺.应用生物完整性指数评价水生态系统健康的研究进展[J].应用生态学报,2013,24(1):295-302.
[10] PILIÈRE A,SCHIPPER A M,BREURE A M,et al.Comparing Responses of Freshwater Fish and Invertebrate Community Integrity Along Multiple Environmental Gradients[J].Ecological Indicators,2014,43:215-226.
[11] SILOW E A,IN-HYE O.Aquatic Ecosystem Assessment Using Exergy[J].Ecological Indicators,2004,4(3):189-198.
[12] KESMINAS V,VIRBICKAS T.Application of an Adapted Index of Biotic Integrity to Rivers of Lithuania[J].Hydrobiologia,2000,422:257-270.
[13] STODDARD J L,LARSEN D P,HAWKINS C P,et al.Setting Expectations for the Ecological Condition of Streams:The Concept of Reference Condition[J].Ecological Applications,2006,16(4):1267-1276.
[14] PONT D,HUGUENY B,BEIER U,et al.Assessing River Biotic Condition at a Continental Scale:A European Approach Using Functional Metrics and Fish Assemblage[J].Journal of Applied Ecology,2006,43(1):70-80.
[15] 渠晓东,刘志刚,张远.标准化方法筛选参照点构建大型底栖动物生物完整性指数[J].生态学报,2012,32(15):4661-4672.
[16] 郑丙辉,张远,李英博.辽河流域河流栖息地评价指标与评价方法研究[J].环境科学学报,2007,27(6):928-936.
[17] BÖHMER J,RAWER-JOST C,ZENKER A.Multimetric Assessment of Data Provided by Water Managers From Germany:Assessment of Several Different Types of Stressors With Macrozoobenthos Communities[J].Hydrobiologia,2004,516(1/2/3):215-228.
[18] 朱迪,常剑波.长江中游浅水湖泊生物完整性时空变化[J].生态学报,2004,24(12):2761-2767.
[19] WU Nai-cheng,CAI Qing-hua,FOHRER N.Development and Evaluation of a Diatom-based Index of Biotic Integrity (D-IBI) for Rivers Impacted by Run-of-river Dams[J].Ecological Indicators,2012,18:108-117.
[20] 王备新,杨莲芳,胡本进,等.应用底栖动物完整性指数B-IBI评价溪流健康[J].生态学报,2005,25(6):1481-1490.
[21] BORJA A,DAUER D M.Assessing the Environmental Quality Status in Estuarine and Coastal Systems:Comparing Methodologies Indices[J].Ecological Indicators,2008,8(4):331-337.
[22] SCHOOLMASTER D R,GRACE J B,WILLIAM-SCHWEIGER E,et al.A General Theory of Multimetric Indices and Their Properties[J].Methods in Ecology and Evolution,2012,3(4):773-781.
[23] 张颖,胡金,万云,等.基于底栖动物完整性指数B-IBI的淮河流域水系生态健康评价[J].生态与农村环境学报,2014,30(3):300-305.
[24] BARBOUR M T,GERRITSEN J,SNYDER B D,et al.Rapid Bioassessment Protocols for Use in Streams and Wadeable Rivers:Periphyton,Benthic Macroinvertebrates and Fish[R].2nd ed.EPA 841-B-99-002.Washington DC,USA:U. S. Environmental Protection Agency,Office of Water,1999.
[25] 李强,杨莲芳,吴璟,等.底栖动物完整性指数评价西苕溪溪流健康[J].环境科学,2007,28(9):2141-2147.
[26] BEDOYA D,NOVOTNY V,MANOLAKOS E S.Instream and Offstream Environmental Conditions and Stream Biotic Integrity Importance of Scale and Site Similarities for Learning and Prediction[J].Ecology Modelling,2009,220(19):2393-2406.
[27] BLOCKSOM K A,KURTENBACH J P,KLEMM D J,et al.Development and Evaluation of the Lake Macroinvertebrate Integrity Index(LMII) for New Jersey Lakes and Reservoirs[J].Environmental Monitoring and Assessment,2002,77(3):311-333.
[28] 李祚泳.环境质量综合指数的余分指数合成法[J].中国环境科学,1997,17(6):554-556.
[29] IBARRA A A,GEVREY M,PARK Y S,et al.Modelling the Factors that Influence Fish Guilds Composition Using a Back-propagation Network:Assessment of Metrics for Indices of Biotic Integrity[J].Ecological Modelling,2003,160(3):281-290.
[30] BECK M W,WILSON B N,VONDRACEK B,et al.Application of Neural Networks to Quantify Utility of Indices of Biotic Integrity for Biological Monitoring[J].Ecological Indicators,2014,45:195-208.
[31] 刘明典,陈大庆,段辛斌,等.应用鱼类生物完整性指数评价长江中上游健康状况[J].长江科学院院报,2010,27(2):1-6.
[32] 朱迪,陈锋,杨志,等.基于鱼类生物完整性指数的水源地评价[J].水生态学杂志,2012,33(2):1-5.
[33] 沈强,俞建军,陈晖,等.浮游生物完整性指数在浙江水源地水质评价中的应用[J].水生态学杂志,2012,33(2):26-31.
[34] 李国忱.辽宁省清河流域生物完整性指数的研究[D].沈阳:辽宁大学,2012.
[35] 高欣,张远,丁森,等.西辽河大型底栖动物生物完整性评价及同环境因子关系的探讨[C]//中国环境科学学会.光大环保优秀论文集.北京:中国环境科学出版社,2014:43-53.
[36] ROTH N E,ALLAN J D,ERICKSON D L.Landscape Influences on Stream Biotic Integrity Assessed at Multiple Spatial Scales[J].Landscape Ecology,1996,11(3):141-156.
[37] LAUNOIS L,VESLOT J,IRZ P,et al.Development of Fish-based Index (FBI) of Biotic Integrity for French Lakes Using the Hindcasting Approach[J].Ecological Indicators,2011,11(6):1572-1583.
[38] HERING D,JOHNSON R K,KRAMM S,et al.Assessment of European Streams With Diatoms,Macrophytes,Macroinvertebrates and Fish:A Comparative Metric-based Analysis of Organism Response to Stress[J].Freshwater Biology,2006,51(9):1757-1785.
[39] WU Nai-cheng,SCHMALZ B,FOHRER N.Development and Testing of Phytoplankton Index of Biotic Integrity (P-IBI) for a German Lowland River[J].Ecology Indicators,2012,13(1):158-167.
[40] ANGERMEIER P L,DAVIDEANU G.Using Fish Communities to Assess Streams in Romania:Initial Development of an Index of Biotic Integrity[J].Hydrobiologia,2004,511(1/2/3):65-78.
[41] RAPPORT D J,GAUDET C,KARR J R,et al.Evaluating Landscape Heath:Integrating Societal Goals and Biophysical Process[J].Journal of Environmental Management,1998,53(1):1-15.
[42] RAFFERTY S D,LYBROOK J,KACZMAREK K M,et al.Assessing Changes in the Presque Isle Bay Watershed Fish Community Using a Modified Index of Biotic Integrity:Before and After the Elimination of Combined Sewer Overflows[J].Environmental Monitoring and Assessment,2013,185(12):10459-10471.
[43] BOOTH D B,KARR J R,SCHAUMAN S,et al.Reviving Urban Streams:Land Use,Hydrology,Biology,and Human Behavior[J].Journal of the American Water Resources Association,2004,40(5):1351-1364.
[44] 朱迪,杨志.鱼类生物完整性指标在河流健康管理中的应用[J].人民长江,2013,44(15):65-68.
[45] 吴璟,杨莲芳,姜小三,等.浙江西苕溪土地利用变化对溪流大型底栖无脊椎动物完整性的影响[J].生态学报,2008,28(3):1183-1191.
[46] GLENNON M J,PORTER W F.Effects of Land Use Management on Biotic Integrity:An Investigation of Bird Communities[J].Biological Conservation,2005,126(4):499-511.
[47] MELO S,STENERT C,DALZOCHIO M S,et al.Development of a Multimetric Index Based on Aquatic Macroinvertebrate Communities to Assess Water Quality of Rice Fields in Southern Brazil[J].Hydrobiologia,2015,742(1):1-14.
[48] 胡俊,沈强,陈明秀,等.生态监测指标选择的探讨[J].中国环境监测,2014,30(4):166-170.
[49] KARR J R,YODER C O.Biological Assessment and Criteria Improve Total Maximum Daily Load Decision Making[J].Journal of Environmental Engineering,2004,130(6):594-604.