不同水生植物的除氮效率及对生物脱氮过程的调节作用

doi:10.11934/j.issn.1673-4831.2017.02.011

摘要/Abstract

摘要：

选取漂浮植物凤眼莲（Eichhornia crassipes）和大薸（Pistia stratiotes）、浮叶植物乌菱（Trapa bicornis）和沉水植物轮叶黑藻（Hydrilla verticillata）4种不同类型水生植物为供试植物，构建富营养化水体净化系统，在植物生长初期（6-7月）、快速生长期（7-8月）和缓慢生长期（9月）研究其吸收富集氮的能力、去除水体中氮的效率及对水体生物脱氮过程的影响。结果表明，4种水生植物去除水体氨氮、硝态氮、总氮的效率有所差异，凤眼莲、大薸在3个生长阶段对上覆水中各种形态氮的去除效率均较高，对氮的富集能力也较强，轮叶黑藻去除水体中氮的效率最低。快速生长期各类植物净化水体氮的速率最快，其次是生长初期。4种植物体内富集氮能力从大到小依次为凤眼莲、大薸、乌菱和轮叶黑藻，种植沉水植物的水体生物脱氮气体N₂和N₂O的释放通量以及气体释放总量明显高于其他类型水生植物。

关键词: 水生植物, 富营养化, 氮, 生物脱氮

Abstract:

Eutrophication of water bodies has become a worldwide problem in recent years. So far, little has been reported on differences between types of aquatic plants in nitrogen (N) removal efficiency and function of controlling bio-denitrification processes, and variation of the function with growth stage of the plants. This will put us at a disadvantage when it comes to choose appropriate plant species and to further improve efficiency of the phytoremediation technology. With regard to this situation, an experiment was carried out to have four different types of aquatic plants (Eichhornia crassipes, Pistia stratiotes, Trapa bicornis, Hydrilla verticillata) to construct separately four microcosms for treating eutrophied water in an attempt to explore their N enrichment capacities, N removal efficiencies and functions of controlling bio-denitrification processes at different plant growth stages, i. e. initial growth period (June to July), rapid growth period (July to August) and slow growth period (September). Results show that the four types of aquatic plants differed significantly in NH₄⁺-N, NO₃^--N and TN removal efficiency. The two types of floating plants, E. crassipes and P. stratiotes, were the highest in N removal efficiency and N enrichment capacity at all the growth stages with TN removal rate reaching (99.67±0.27)% at the initial growth stage, (96.26±0.88)% at the rapid growth stage and (63.86±3.77)% at the slow growth stage, while the type of submerged plant, H. verticillata, was the lowest in N removal efficiency. Among the three growth stages, the rapid growth stage witnessed the highest N removal efficiency for all the types of plants, and was followed by the initial growth stage. In terms of N enrichment capability, the four types of aquatic plants displayed an order of E. crassipes > P. stratiotes > Trapa bicornis > Hydrilla verticillata. However, the type of submerged plants released significantly more N₂ and N₂O through bio-denitrification than all the others and so was its total gas release. The present study reveals that the aquatic plants differ in efficiency, pathway and mechanisms of N removal in eutrophied water with type and growth stage of the plants. It is, therefore, expected that all the findings in this experiment could provide some useful information on how to choose appropriate aquatic plants and improve efficiency of the phytoremediation technology in treating eutrophied water.

Key words: aquatic plant, eutrophication, nitrogen, biological nitrogen removal

中图分类号:

张芳, 易能, 邸攀攀, 王岩, 张振华, 唐婉莹, 严少华, 高岩. 不同水生植物的除氮效率及对生物脱氮过程的调节作用[J]. 生态与农村环境学报, 2017, 33(2): 174-180.

ZHANG Fang, YI Neng, DI Pan-pan, WANG Yan, ZHANG Zhen-hua, TANG Wan-ying, YAN Shao-hua, GAO Yan. Nitrogen Removal Efficiency and Control of Bio-Denitrification Process of Aquatic Plants[J]. Journal of Ecology and Rural Environment, 2017, 33(2): 174-180.

参考文献

[1] HECKY R E,KIHAM P.Nutrient Limitation of Phytoplankton in Freshwater and Marine Environments:A Review of Recent Evidence on the Effects of Enrichment[J].Limnology and Oceanography,1988,33(4):796-822.
[2] NIXON S W.Coastal Marine Eutrophication:A Definition,Social Causes,and Future Concerns[J].Ophelia,1995,41(1):199-219.
[3] SCHINDLER D W,HECKY R E,FINDLAY D L,et al.Eutrophication of Lakes Cannot be Controlled by Reducing Nitrogen Input:Results of a 37-Year Whole-Ecosystem Experiment[J].Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences,2008,105(32):11254-11258.
[4] 张艺,许文年,方艳芬,等.三峡库湾香溪河生态环境研究进展[J].三峡大学学报(自然科学版),2007,29(1):20-24.[ZHANG Yi,XU Wen-nian,FANG Yan-fen,et al.Advance in Research on Ecological Environment of Xiangxi River of Three Gorges Reservoir Area[J].Journal of China Three Gorges University(Natural Sciences),2007,29(1):20-24.]
[5] 刘盼,宋超,朱华,等.3种水生植物对富营养化水体的净化作用研究[J].水生态学杂志,2011,32(2):69-74.[LIU Pan,SONG Chao,ZHU Hua,et al.Studies on Eutrophicated Water Quality Improvement by Three Kinds of Hydrophytes[J].Journal of Hydroecology,2011,32(2):69-74.]
[6] 李安峰,潘涛,杨冲,等.水体富营养化治理与控制技术综述[J].安徽农业科学,2012,40(16):9041-9044,9062.[LI An-feng,PAN Tao,YANG Chong,et al.Review of the Treatment and Control Techniques of Water Eutrophication[J].Journal of Anhui Agricultural Sciences,2012,40(16):9041-9044,9062.]
[7] 魏晓慧,冯佳,谢树莲,等.六种水生植物对汾河太原段污水的修复研究[J].给水排水,2012(增刊1):102-105.[WEI Xiao-hui,FENG Jia,XIE Shu-lian,et al.Study on Restoration in Taiyuan Segment of Fenhe River by Six Aquatic Plants[J].Journal of Water Supply and Drainage,2012(Suppl.1):102-105.]
[8] 高丁梅,杨涓,虎春宇,等.宁夏4种水生植物对富营养化水体净化效果的研究[J].农业科学研究,2012,33(2):63-65.[GAO Ding-mei,YANG Juan,HU Chun-yu,et al.Study on the Effect of Purification of Four Aquatic Macrophytes to the Eutrophic Water in Ningxia[J].Journal of Agricultural Sciences,2012,33(2):63-65.]
[9] FRASER L H,CARTY S M,STEER D.A Test of Four Plant Species to Reduce Total Nitrogen and Total Phosphorus From Soil Leachate in Subsurface Wetland Microcosms[J].Bioresource Technology,2004,94(2):185-192.
[10] 高岩,易能,张志勇,等.凤眼莲对富营养化水体硝化、反硝化脱氮释放N₂O的影响[J].环境科学学报,2012,32(2):349-359.[GAO Yan,YI Neng,ZHANG Zhi-yong,et al.Effect of Water Hyacinth on N₂O Emission Through Nitrification and Denitrification Reactions in Eutrophic Water[J].Acta Scientiae Circumstantiae,2012,32(2):349-359.]
[11] 王娟,王圣瑞,金相灿,等.沉水植物黑藻对沉积物氨氮吸附/释放特征的影响[J].生态环境,2007,16(2):336-341.[WANG Juan,WANG Sheng-rui,JIN Xiang-can,et al.Effect of Submerged Aquatic Plant Hydrilla verticilla on the Sorption/Release Characteristic of Ammonia Nitrogen on Sediment[J].Ecology and Environment,2007,16(2):336-341.]
[12] 马涛,易能,张振华,等.凤眼莲根系分泌氧和有机碳规律及其对水体氮转化影响的研究[J].农业环境科学学报,2014,33(10):2003-2013.[MA Tao,YI Neng,ZHANG Zhen-hua,et al.Oxygen and Organic Carbon Releases From Roots of and Eichhonia crassipes and Their Influence on Transformation of Nitrogen in Water[J].Journal of Agro-Environmental Science,2014,33(10):2003-2013.]
[13] 马涛,张振华,易能.等.凤眼莲及底泥对富营养化水体反硝化脱氮特征的影响研究[J].农业环境科学学报,2013,32(12):2451-2459.[MA Tao,ZHANG Zhen-hua,YI Neng,et al.Nitrogen Removal Via Denitrification From Eutrophic Water as Influenced by Eichhonia crassipes and Sediment[J].Journal of Agro-Environmental Science,2013,32(12):2451-2459.]
[14] GAO Y,LIU X H,YI N,et al.Estimation of N₂ and N₂O Ebullition From Eutrophic Water Using an Improved Bubble Trap Device[J].Ecological Engineering,2013,57:403-412.
[15] 刘新红,严少华,张志勇,等.一种水体底泥释放气体的收集装置.中国专利,201220549038.0[P].2012-12-25.[LIU Xin-hong,YAN Shao-hua,ZHANG Zhi-yong,et al.A Device Trapping Ebullition From Sediment.China Patent,201220549038.0[P].2012-12-25.]
[16] 高岩,刘新红,马涛,等.水体释放气体的研究:收集装置描述及收集气体成分研究[C]//第五届全国农业环境科学学术研讨会论文集.天津:中国农业生态环境保护协会,2013:578-586.[GAO Yan,LIU Xin-hong,MA Tao,et al.A Device Trapping Ebullition From Water Body:Device Description and Gas Composition Studies[C]//The Proceedings the 5th National Conference of Agro-environment Science,Tianjin:Chinese Society of Agro-Ecolo gical Environment Protection,2013:578-586.]
[17] 张迎颖,吴富勤,张志勇,等.凤眼莲有性繁殖与种子结构及其活力研究[J].南京农业大学学报,2012,35(1):135-138.[ZHANG Ying-ying,WU Fu-qin,ZHANG Zhi-yong,et al.Research on Sexual Reproduction,Seed Structure and its Vigor of Eichhornia crassipes[J].Journal of Nanjing Agricultural University,2012,35(1):135-138.]
[18] 常会庆,李娜,徐晓峰.三种水生植物对不同形态氮素吸收动力学研究[J].生态环境,2008,17(2):511-514.[CHANG Hui-qing,LI Na,XU Xiao-feng.NH₄⁺ and NO₃^- Uptake Kinetics of Three Aquatic Macrophytes[J].Ecology and Environment,2008,17(2):511-514.]
[19] SHIRALIPOUR A,GARRARD L A,HALLER W T.Nitrogen Source,Biomass Production,and Phosphorus Uptake in Water Hyacinth[J].Journal of Aquatic Plant Managent,1981,19:40-43.
[20] TUCKER C S.The Effect of Ionic Form and Level of Nitrogen on the Growth and Composition of Eichhornia crassipes (Mart.) Solms[J].Hydrobiologia,1981,83(3):517-522.
[21] REDDY K R,AGAMI M,TUKER J C.Influence of Nitrogen Supply Rates on Growth and Nutrient Storage by Water Hyacinth (Eichhornia crassipes) Plants[J].Aquatic Botany,1989,36(1):33-43.
[22] FOX L J,STRUIK P C,APPLETON B L,et al.Nitrogen Phytoremediation by Water Hyacinth (Eichhornia Crassipes (Mart.) Solms)[J].Water,Air,and Soil Pollution,2008,194(1):199-207.
[23] TRIPATHI B D,SRIVASTAVA J,MISRA K.Nitrogen and Phosphorus Removal-Capacity of Four Chosen Aquatic Macrophytes in Tropical Freshwater Ponds[J].Environmental Conservation,1991,18(2):143-147.
[24] SHARMA B M,OSHODI O O.Effect of Nutrients on the Biomass of Water Hyacinth (Eichhornia Crassipes (Mart) Solms)[J].Polskie Archiwum Hydrobiolog,1992,38:401.
[25] ZKOV Z,PALÁT M,KOCKOVÁ E,et al.Is It Realistic to Use Water Hyacinth for Wastewater Treatment and Nutrient Removal in Central Europe?[J].Water Science and Technology,1994,30(8):303-311.
[26] 舒柳.5种水生植物对净化生活污水的效果研究[J].广东农业科学,2013,40(6):161-163.[SHU Liu.Research of Different Aquatic Plants on Purify the Domestic Sewage[J].Guangdong Agricultural Sciences,2013,40(6):161-163.]
[27] CORNWELL D A,ZOLTRK JR J,PATRINELY C D,et al.Nutrient Removal by Water Hyacinths[J].Journal Water Environment Federation,1977,49(1):57-65.
[28] ROGERS H H,DAVIS D E.Nutrient Removal by Waterhyacinth[J].Weed Science,1972,20(5):423-428.
[29] WOLVERTON B C,MCDONALD R C.Water Hyacinths for Upgrading Sewage Lagoons to Meet Advanced Wastewater Treatment Standards:Part Ⅱ[M].Bay Saint Louis,USA:NASA Technical Memorandum,1976:1-24.
[30] GUTIÉRREZ E,HUERTO R,SALDAÑA P,et al.Strategies for Waterhyacinth (Eichhornia crassipes) Control in Mexico[M]//CAFFREY J M,BARRETT P R F,MURPHY K J.Management and Ecology of Freshwater Plants.Berlin,Germany:Springer,1996:181-185.
[31] MADSEN J D.Growth and Biomass Allocation Patterns During Water hyacinth Mat Development[J].Journal of Aquatic Plant Management,1993,31:134-137.
[32] 闫芊.沉水植物黑藻在水生生态系统修复中的应用研究[J].环境与发展,2013(8):94-96.[YAN Qian.Study on Application of Submerged Plant Hydrilla verticillata in Aquatic Ecosystem Restoration[J].Environment and Development,2013(8):94-96.]
[33] 徐寸发,张志勇,秦红杰,等.不同生活型水生植物改善滇池草海水体的效果[J].江苏农业科学,2015,43(6):307-311.[XU Cun-fa,ZHANG Zhi-yong,QIN Hong-jie,et al.The Purification Effects Among Three Different Living Kinds of Aquatic Plants in Water Body of Lake Dianchi Caohai[J].Jiangsu Agricultural Sciences,2015,43(6):307-311.]
[34] 秦伯强.湖泊生态恢复的基本原理与实现[J].生态学报,2007,27(11):4848-4858.[QIN Bo-qiang.Principles and Approach for Lake Ecological Restoration[J].Acta Ecologica Snica,2007,27(11):4848-4858.]
[35] MCJANET C L,KEDDY P A,PICK F R.Nitrogen and Phosphorus Tissue Concentration in 41 Wetland Plants:A Comparison Across Habitats and Functional Groups[J].Functional Ecology,1995,9(2):231-238.
[36] TANNER C C.Plants for Constructed Wetland Treatment Systems:A Comparison of the Growth and Nutrient Uptake of Eight Emergent Species[J].Ecological Engineering,1996,7(1):59-83.
[37] HEADLEY T R.Removal of Nutrients and Plant Pathogens From Plants Nursery Runoff Using Horizontal Subsurface Flow Constructed Wetlands[D].Lismore,Australia:Southem Cross University,2004.
[38] 邹国林,王全金,朱平,等.低温下沉水植物塘对农村污染水体的净化作用[J].武汉工程大学学报,2012,34(3):38-41.[ZOU Guo-lin,WANG Quan-jing,ZHU Ping,et al.Purification Function of Submerged Plant Pond in Rural Polluted Water at Low Temperature[J].Journal of Wuhan Institute of Technology,2012,34(3):38-41.]
[39] 李聪聪,吴振东,周青,等.植物-微生物共代谢系统在湖泊修复中的作用[J].上海环境科学,2012(6):240-244,248.[LI Cong-cong,WU Zhen-dong,ZHOU Qing,et al.Effects of the Plant-and-Microorganism Co-Metabolic System on Lake Remediation[J].Shanghai Environmental Science,2012(6):240-244,248.]
[40] REDDY K R,PATRICK W H,LINDAU C W.Nitrification-Denitrification at the Plant Root-Sediment Interface in Wetlands[J].Limnology Oceanography,1989,34(6):1004-1013.
[41] SCHULZ M,KOZERSKI H P,PLUNTKE T,et al.The Influence of Macrophytes on Sedimentation and Nutrient Retention in the Lower River Spree(Germany)[J].Water Research,2003,37(3):569-578.
[42] CARPENTER S R,LODGER D M.Effects of Submersed Macrophytes on Ecosystem Process[J].Aquatic Botany,1986,26(3/4):341-370.
[43] MUKHERJEE R,NANDI B.Improvement of in Vitro Digestibility Through Biological Treatment of Water Hyacinth Biomass by Two Pleurotus Species[J].International Biodeterioration & Biodegradation,2004,53(1):7-12.
[44] ADEOYE G O,SRIDHAR M K C,IPINMOROTI R R.Potassium Recovery From Farm Wastes for Crop Growth[J].Communications in Soil Science and Plant Analysis,2001,32(15/16):2347-2358.
[45] PATVEEN S,FEROZA B,HOSSAIN M,et al.Production of Biogas From Cow Dung by Adding Water Hyacinth and Mud[J].Bangladesh Journal of Scientific and Industrial Research,1998,33(3):369-372.
[46] MATSUMURA Y.Evaluation of Supercritical Water Gasification and Biomethanation for Wet Biomass Utilization in Japan[J].Energy Conversion and Management,2002,43(9):1301-1310.