以设计精准修复方案为目标的土壤重金属形态分布研究

doi:10.11934/j.issn.1673-4831.2018.01.011

生态与农村环境学报 ›› 2018, Vol. 34 ›› Issue (1): 87-95.doi: 10.11934/j.issn.1673-4831.2018.01.011

• 污染控制与修复 • 上一篇

以设计精准修复方案为目标的土壤重金属形态分布研究

王佳佳¹, 李翔¹, 罗楠¹, 何跃², 刘永兵¹, 卢一富³, 苗向前³, 吕利光³

1. 轻工业环境保护研究所工业场地污染与修复北京市重点实验室, 北京 100089;
2. 环境保护部南京环境科学研究所, 江苏南京 210042;
3. 济源市环境科学研究所河南省土壤重金属污染监测与修复重点实验室, 河南济源 459001

收稿日期:2017-06-02 出版日期:2018-01-25 发布日期:2018-01-26
通讯作者: 何跃, 刘永兵 E-mail:heyue@nies.org;liuyongbing21@163.com
作者简介:王佳佳(1989-),女,山西晋中人,助理研究员,硕士,研究方向为土壤重金属修复。E-mail:wangjiajia0501@126.com
基金资助:
国家重金属污染防治专项（JGZJ-工-2015152-02）；北京市科学技术研究院财政专项（2016-A-30）；中央级公益性科研院所基本科研业务专项（2017年）；中科院盱眙凹土应用技术研发与产业化中心开放性课题资助项目（201506）

Distribution of Heavy Metals by Form for Precise Remediation of Polluted Farmland Soil

WANG Jia-jia¹, LI Xiang¹, LUO Nan¹, HE Yue², LIU Yong-bing¹, LU Yi-fu³, MIAO Xiang-qian³, LÜ Li-guang³

1. Beijing Key Laboratory of Industrial Contamination and Remediation, Environmental Protection Research Institute of Light Industry, Beijing 100089, China;
2. Nanjing Institute of Environmental Sciences, Ministry of Environmental Protection, Nanjing 210042, China;
3. Key Laboratory for Monitoring and Remediation of Heavy Metal Polluted Soils of Henan Province, Environmental Science Research Institute of Jiyuan City, Jiyuan 459001, China

Received:2017-06-02 Online:2018-01-25 Published:2018-01-26

摘要/Abstract

摘要：

农田土壤原位钝化/稳定化修复是通过向土壤中添加化学药剂以降低重金属活性、抑制土壤重金属向农作物迁移进而降低重金属风险的一种修复技术。针对河南省某重金属污染农田土壤，为制定精准的原位稳定化修复方案，采集32个表层土壤样品测定其Cd、Pb、As、Cu、Zn、Ni、Cr 7种元素全量，并利用BCR连续提取法测定弱酸提取态、可还原态、可氧化态和残渣态4种形态含量。结果表明：土壤Cd、Pb、As、Cu、Zn、Ni和Cr含量的平均值分别为1.90、144.91、7.33、32.24、91.40、28.80和19.76 mg·kg^-1，Cd和Pb含量分别超过HJ/T 332-2006《食用农产品产地环境质量评价标准》的3.17和1.81倍。BCR形态分析表明，弱酸提取态Cd含量占全量比例较高，平均值为24.06%；土壤80.35%的Pb以可还原态存在，其余5种元素主要以残渣态存在。基于不同元素的弱酸提取态含量与全量建立回归分析模型，结果显示各元素的弱酸提取态含量随全量呈线性变化且两者的正相关关系显著；根据Cd、Pb 2种元素全量与弱酸提取态含量的空间分布差异对研究区域进行分区，基于土壤全量Cd和弱酸提取态Cd含量的分区结果有一定差异，而基于弱酸提取态Cd与弱酸提取态Pb含量的分区结果大致相同，能够为设计精准的修复方案提供依据。最后，分别以重金属全量与有效态含量为出发点对研究区域重金属的污染程度与存在风险给予评价，Hakanson风险评价结果表明土壤Cd存在极强的潜在生态风险，风险评价编码法评价结果则显示Cd为中等风险，两者之间的差异提示土壤重金属修复需综合考虑不同评价方法的评价结果，这为重金属的修复评价奠定基础。

关键词: 农田土壤, 原位稳定化, 重金属形态, 分区处理, 精准修复, 风险评价

Abstract:

In-situ immobilization/stabilization of heavy metals in farmland soil is a soil remediation technology through amending the soil with certain chemical agents to reduce activity of the pollutants, inhibit their transport from soil to crops and hence mitigate their risks to crops. A total of 32 soil samples were collected from heavy metal polluted croplands in Henan Province for analysis of Cd, Pb, As, Cu, Zn, Ni and Cr for their totals and various fractions, i. e., weak-acid extractable, reducible, oxidizable and residue, using the BCR sequential extraction method, and then a precise soil remediation program formed. Results show that the concentration of Cd, Pb, As, Cu, Zn, Ni and Cr in the soil was on average 1.90, 144.91, 7.33, 32.24, 91.40, 28.80 and 19.76 mg·kg^-1, respectively. Among them, Cd and Pb concentration in the soil was far beyond the criteria of the "Standard for Environmental Quality Evaluation Standards of Farmlands Producing Edible Agricultural Produce (HJ/T 332-2006)" reaching 3.17 and 1.81 times as high, respectively. The analysis using the BCR sequential extraction method shows that weak acid extractable Cd was relatively high in percentage of the total, reaching up to 24.06%; Pb existed in the soil mainly in reducible form, which accounted for 80.35% of the total in the soil, while the other 5 elements existed mainly in residual form. Regression analysis models were established based on contents of the weak acid extractables and their respective total of the heavy metal elements in the soil, indicating that the former varied with the latter exhibiting positive linear relationships between the two. According to the differences weak acid extractable Cd and Pb and their respective total in spatial distribution, the study area was partitioned. The partitioning by total Cd differed somewhat from that by weak acid extractable Cd, while the partitioning by weak acid extractable Cd was quite similar to that by weak acid extractable Pb, which may serve as a basis for formulation of a precise soil remediation program. In the end, levels and risks of the heavy metal pollution of the soil in view of the total and the content of available form of heavy metals, separately. Hakanson Potential Ecological Risk Assessment shows that Cd in the soil posed a strong potential ecological risk, but Cd in the soil was rated as moderate in risk according to the Risk Assessment Code (RAC). The difference between the two evaluations suggests that it is essential to take into account results of all various evaluation methods to program remediation of heavy metals polluted soils. This study may have laid down a foundation for evaluation and remediation of heavy metal polluted soils.

Key words: farmland soil, in-situ stabilization, fraction of heavy metal, partitioning of the study area, precise remediation, risk evaluation

中图分类号:

王佳佳, 李翔, 罗楠, 何跃, 刘永兵, 卢一富, 苗向前, 吕利光. 以设计精准修复方案为目标的土壤重金属形态分布研究[J]. 生态与农村环境学报, 2018, 34(1): 87-95.

WANG Jia-jia, LI Xiang, LUO Nan, HE Yue, LIU Yong-bing, LU Yi-fu, MIAO Xiang-qian, LÜ Li-guang. Distribution of Heavy Metals by Form for Precise Remediation of Polluted Farmland Soil[J]. Journal of Ecology and Rural Environment, 2018, 34(1): 87-95.

参考文献

[1] 刘永兵,贾斌,李翔,等.海南省南渡江新坡河塘底泥养分状况及重金属污染评价[J].农业工程学报,2013,29(3):213-224.[LIU Yong-bing,JIA Bin,LI Xiang,et al.Characteristic of Nutrients and Evaluation of Heavy Metal Contamination on Sediments Among Xinpo Pond,Nandu River in Hainan Province[J].Transactions of the Chinese Society of Agricultural Engineering,2013,29(3):213-224.]
[2] 李翔,刘永兵,宋云,等.石灰干化污泥对土壤重金属稳定化处理的效果[J].环境工程学报,2014,8(8):3461-3470.[LI Xiang,LIU Yong-bing,SONG Yun,et al.Effect of Lime-Stabilized Sludge on Stabilization of Heavy Metals in Soil[J].Chinese Journal of Environmental Engineering,2014,8(8):3461-3470.]
[3] 李翔,刘永兵,程言君,等.稳定化处理对底泥利用后土壤重金属形态及蔬菜重金属含量的影响[J].农业环境科学学报,2016,35(7):1278-1285.[LI Xiang,LIU Yong-bing,CHENG Yan-jun,et al.Effects of Stabilization on Soil Heavy Metal Fractions and Vegetable Heavy Metal Content Under Amendment With Dredged River Sediments[J].Journal of Agro-Environment Science,2016,35(7):1278-1285.]
[4] 郝汉舟,陈同斌,靳孟贵,等.重金属污染土壤稳定/固化修复技术研究进展[J].应用生态学报,2011,22(3):816-824.[HAO Han-zhou,CHEN Tong-bin,JIN Meng-gui,et al.Recent Advance in Solidification/Stabilization Technology for the Remediation of Heavy Metals-Contaminated Soil[J].Chinese Journal of Applied Ecology,2011,22(3):816-824.]
[5] 韩君,徐应明,温兆飞,等.重庆某废弃电镀工业园农田土壤重金属污染调查与生态风险评价[J].环境化学,2014,33(3):432-439.[HAN Jun,XU Ying-ming,WEN Zhao-fei,et al.Investigation and Ecological Risk Assessment of Heavy Metal Pollution in Agriculture Soil of an Abandoned Electroplating Industrial Park of Chongqing,China[J].Environmental Chemistry,2014,33(3):432-439.]
[6] 柳云龙,章立佳,韩晓非,等.上海城市样带土壤重金属空间变异特征及污染评价[J].环境科学,2012,33(2):599-605.[LIU Yun-long,ZHANG Li-jia,HAN Xiao-fei,et al.Spatial Variability and Evaluation of Soil Heavy Metal Contamination in the Urban-Transect of Shanghai[J].Environmental Science,2012,33(2):599-605.]
[7] 吴琼,赵同科,邹国元,等.北京东南郊农田土壤重金属含量与环境质量评价[J].中国土壤与肥料,2016(1):7-12.[WU Qiong,ZHAO Tong-ke,ZOU Guo-yuan,et al.Heavy Metals Contents and Environment Quality Evaluation of Farmland Soil in East-South Area of Beijing[J].Soil and Fertilizer Sciences in China,2016(1):7-12.]
[8] 刘亚纳,朱书法,魏学锋,等.河南洛阳市不同功能区土壤重金属污染特征及评价[J].环境科学,2016,37(6):2322-2328.[LIU Ya-na,ZHU Shu-fa,WEI Xue-feng,et al.Assessment and Pollution Characteristics of Heavy Metals in Soil of Different Functional Areas in Luoyang[J].Environmental Science,2016,37(6):2322-2328.]
[9] 刘衍君,张保华,刘子亭,等.基于ArcGIS的潍坊市土壤重金属污染现状与空间分布研究[J].水土保持通报,2016,36(6):150-154.[LIU Yan-jun,ZHANG Bao-hua,LIU Zi-ting,et al.A Study on Distribution of Soil Heavy Metal Pollution in Weifang City Based on Geography Information System[J].Bulletin of Soil and Water Conservation,2016,36(6):150-154.]
[10] 王佳佳,弓晓峰,向洪锐,等.城市内湖疏浚前重金属的沉积与污染特征研究[J].环境科学与技术,2015,38(10):161-167.[WANG Jia-jia,GONG Xiao-feng,XIANG Hong-rui,et al.Study of Heavy Metals Deposition and Pollution Characteristics in Urban Lake Before Dredging[J].Environmental Science and Technology,2015,38(10):161-167.]
[11] SHEN F,LIAO R M,ALI A,et al.Spatial Distribution and Risk Assessment of Heavy Metals in Soil Near a Pb/Zn Smelter in Feng County,China[J].Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety,2017,139:254-262.
[12] 赵倩,马琳,刘翼飞,等.北京东南郊典型地层重金属分布特征与潜在生态风险[J].环境科学,2016,37(5):1931-1937.[ZHAO Qian,MA Lin,LIU Yi-fei,et al.Distribution Characteristics and Potential Ecological Hazards Assessment of Soil Heavy Metals in Typical Soil Profiles in Southeast Suburb of Beijing[J].Environmental Science,2016,37(5):1931-1937.]
[13] 韩春梅,王林山,巩宗强,等.土壤中重金属形态分析及其环境学意义[J].生态学杂志,2005,25(12):1499-1502.[HAN Chun-mei,WANG Lin-shan,GONG Zong-qiang,et al.Chemical Forms of Soil Heavy Metals and Their Environmental Significance[J].Chinese Journal of Ecology,2005,24(12):1499-1502.]
[14] 周国华.土壤重金属生物有效性研究进展[J].物探与化探,2014,38(6):1097-1106.[ZHOU Guo-hua.Recent Progress in the Study of Heavy Metal Bioavailability in Soil[J].Geophysical & Geochemical Exploration,2014,38(6):1097-1106.]
[15] TESSIER A,CAMPBELL P G C,BISSON M.Sequential Extraction Procedure for the Speciation of Particulate Trace Metal[J].Analytical Chemistry,1979,51(7):844-851.
[16] RAURET G,LÓPEZ-SÁNCHEZ J F,SAHUQUILLO A,et al.Improvement of the BCR Three Step Sequential Extraction Procedure Prior to the Certification of New Sediment and Soil Reference Materials[J].Journal of Environmental Monitoring,1999,1(1):57-61.
[17] 陈璐,文方,程艳,等.铅锌尾矿中重金属形态分布与毒性浸出特征研究[J].干旱区资源与环境,2017,31(3):89-94.[CHEN Lu,WEN Fang,CHENG Yan,et al.Characteristics of Speciation Distribution and Toxicity Leaching of Heavy Metals in Pb-Zn Tailings[J].Journal of Arid Land Resources and Environment,2017,31(3):89-94.]
[18] HJ/T 166-2004,土壤环境监测技术规范[S].[HJ/T 166-2004,Technical Specification for Soil Environmental Monitoring[S].]
[19] GB/T 22105.2-2008,土壤质量总汞、总砷、总铅的测定原子荧光法第2部分:土壤中总砷的测定[S].[GB/T 22105.2-2008,Soil Quality:Analysis of Total Mercury,Arsenic and Lead Contents:Atomic Fluorescence Spectrometry:Part 2:Analysis of Total Arsenic Contents in Soils[S].]
[20] HJ/T 332-2006,食用农产品产地环境质量评价标准[S].[HJ/T 332-2006,Environmental Quality Evaluation Standards for Farmland of Edible Agricultural Products[S].]
[21] 周广柱,杨锋杰,程建光,等.土壤环境质量综合评价方法探讨[J].山东科技大学学报(自然科学版),2005,24(4):113-115.[ZHOU Guang-zhu,YANG Feng-jie,CHENG Jian-guang,et al.Research on Synthetic Assessment Method for Soil Environmental Quality[J].Journal of Shandong University of Science and Technology (Natural Science),2005,24(4):113-115.]
[22] HAKANSON L.An Ecological Risk Index for Aquatic Pollution Control:A Sedimentological Approach[J].Water Research,1980,14(8):975-1001.
[23] SOLTANI N,KESHAVARZI B,MOORE F,et al.Ecological and Human Health Hazards of Heavy Metals and Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons (PAHs) in Road Dust of Isfahan Metropolis,Iran[J].Science of the Total Environment,2015,505:712-723.
[24] 范明毅,杨皓,黄先飞,等.典型山区燃煤型电厂周边土壤重金属形态特征及污染评价[J].中国环境科学,2016,36(8):2425-2436.[FAN Ming-yi,YANG Hao,HUANG Xian-fei,et al.Chemical Forms and Risk Assessment of Heavy Metals in Soils Around a Typical Coal-Fired Power Plant Located in the Mountainous Area[J].China Environmental Science,2016,36(8):2425-2436.]
[25] 李如忠,姜艳敏,潘成荣,等.典型有色金属矿山城市小河流沉积物重金属形态分布及风险评估[J].环境科学,2013,34(3):1067-1075.[LI Ru-zhong,JIANG Yan-min,PAN Cheng-rong,et al.Fraction Distribution and Risk Assessment of Heavy Metals in Stream Sediments From a Typical Nonferrous Metals Mining City[J].Environmental Science,2013,34(3):1067-1075.]
[26] 雷国建,陈志良,刘千钧,等.广州郊区土壤重金属污染程度及潜在生态危害评价[J].中国环境科学,2013,33(增刊1):49-53.[LEI Guo-jian,CHEN Zhi-liang,LIU Qian-jun,et al.The Assessments of Polluted Degree and Potential Ecological Hazards of Heavy Metals in Suburban Soil of Guangzhou City[J].China Environmental Science,2013,33(Suppl.1):49-53.]
[27] GB 15618-1995,土壤环境质量标准[S].[GB 15618-1995,Environmental Quality Standard for Soils[S].]
[28] 邵丰收,周皓韵.河南省主要元素的土壤环境背景值[J].河南农业,1998(10):29.[SHAO Feng-shou,ZHOU Hao-yun.The Main Elements of the Soil Environmental Background Value in Henan Province[J].Henan Agriculture,1998(10):29.]
[29] 张金莲,丁疆峰,卢桂宁,等.广东清远电子垃圾拆解区农田土壤重金属污染评价[J].环境科学,2015,36(7):2633-2640.[ZHANG Jin-lian,DING Jiang-feng,LU Gui-ning,et al.Heavy Metal Contamination in Farmland Soils at an E-Waste Disassembling Site in Qingyuan,Guangdong,South China[J].Environmental Science,2015,36(7):2633-2640.]
[30] 李瑛,张桂银,李洪军,等.根际土壤中Cd、Pb形态转化及其植物效应[J].生态环境,2004,13(3):316-319.[LI Ying,ZHANG Gui-yin,LI Hong-jun,et al.Speciation Transformation of Cd,Pb in Rhizosphere and Their Effects on Plant[J].Ecology and Environment,2004,13(3):316-319.]
[31] MERTENS J,VERVAEKE P,SCHRIJVER A D,et al.Metal Uptake by Young Trees From Dredged Brackish Sediment:Limitations and Possibilities for Phytoextraction and Phytostabilisation[J].Science of the Total Environment,2004,326(1/2/3):209-215.
[32] 李姗姗,曹广超,石平超,等.青岛城区土壤重金属元素空间分布及其现状评价[J].生态与农村环境学报,2015,31(1):112-117.[LI Shan-shan,CAO Guang-chao,SHI Ping-chao,et al.Status Quo and Evaluation of the Spatial Distribution of Heavy Metals in Urban Soil of Qingdao City[J].Journal of Ecology and Rural Environment,2015,31(1):112-117.]
[33] 姜俊彦,黄星,李秀珍,等.潮滩湿地土壤有机碳储量及其与土壤理化因子的关系:以崇明东滩为例[J].生态与农村环境学报,2015,31(4):540-547.[JIANG Jun-yan,HUANG Xing,LI Xiu-zhen,et al.Soil Organic Carbon Storage in Tidal Wetland and Its Relationships With Soil Physico-Chemical Factors:A Case Study of Dongtan of Chongming,Shanghai[J].Journal of Ecology and Rural Environment,2015,31(4):540-547.]

以设计精准修复方案为目标的土壤重金属形态分布研究

Distribution of Heavy Metals by Form for Precise Remediation of Polluted Farmland Soil

PDF

可视化

摘要/Abstract

引用本文

使用本文

参考文献

相关文章 15

编辑推荐

Metrics

本文评价

[1]	马舒欣, 乔永民, 唐梦瑶, 杨洪允. 广州市主要湖泊沉积物重金属污染与生态风险评价[J]. 生态与农村环境学报, 2019, 35(5): 600-607.
[2]	张亚捷, 牛海山. 农田土壤氧化亚氮产生机制和相关模型研究进展[J]. 生态与农村环境学报, 2019, 35(5): 554-562.
[3]	谭丽超, 程燕, 朱昱璇, 卜元卿. 油菜蚜虫防治用药对蜜蜂的急性毒性与风险评价[J]. 生态与农村环境学报, 2019, 35(4): 500-505.
[4]	张又文, 韩建华, 涂棋, 杨永安, 徐艳, 师荣光. 天津市郊农田土壤重金属积累特征及评价[J]. 生态与农村环境学报, 2019, 35(11): 1445-1452.
[5]	徐蕾, 肖昕, 马玉, 韩筱璇. 徐州农田土壤重金属空间分布及来源分析[J]. 生态与农村环境学报, 2019, 35(11): 1453-1459.
[6]	符云聪, 朱晓龙, 袁毳, 解晓露, 杨国航, 李鹏祥, 刘晨, 刘代欢. 含硫材料对中碱性农田土壤镉的钝化效果[J]. 生态与农村环境学报, 2019, 35(10): 1353-1360.
[7]	赵涵, 赵军, 徐晓晔, 吴绍华, 朱青. 快速城市化地区土壤多环芳烃的空间分布及来源:以深圳市为例[J]. 生态与农村环境学报, 2019, 35(1): 38-45.
[8]	陈垚, 甘春娟, 张彩, 袁绍春, 朱子奇. 城市雨水塘生态风险评价方法[J]. 生态与农村环境学报, 2018, 34(12): 1064-1073.
[9]	吕良禾, 张鸿龄, 陈宗聪, 孙家君, 孙丽娜, 王晓旭. 表面活性剂强化油菜-微生物联合修复滴滴涕污染农田土壤研究[J]. 生态与农村环境学报, 2017, 33(8): 755-761.
[10]	刘世梁, 侯笑云, 张月秋, 尹艺洁, 王军. 基于生态系统服务的土地整治生态风险评价与管控建议[J]. 生态与农村环境学报, 2017, 33(3): 193-200.
[11]	冯艳红, 郑丽萍, 应蓉蓉, 张亚, 林玉锁, 王国庆. 黔西北炼锌矿区土壤重金属形态分析及风险评价[J]. 生态与农村环境学报, 2017, 33(2): 142-149.
[12]	邱孟龙, 王琦, 刘黎明, 刚毅. 优化赋权模糊综合评价法对耕地土壤重金属污染的风险评价[J]. 生态与农村环境学报, 2017, 33(11): 1049-1056.
[13]	徐怀洲, 宋宁慧, 张圣虎, 汪贞, 吉贵祥, 刘济宁, 石利利. 骆马湖邻苯二甲酸酯分布特征及健康风险评价[J]. 生态与农村环境学报, 2017, 33(10): 928-934.
[14]	李少华, 王学全, 兰岚, 高琪, 杨占武. 青海湖流域主要河口区沉积物中重金属元素生态风险评价[J]. 生态与农村环境学报, 2016, 32(6): 940-945.
[15]	李娟英, 石文瑄, 崔昱, 李润奇. 滴水湖水体及沉积物中重金属和多环芳烃的污染分析与评价[J]. 生态与农村环境学报, 2016, 32(1): 96-101.