国土空间规划体系研究:理论认知与实践向度

doi:10.19741/j.issn.1673-4831.2022.0584

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 以高水平国土空间规划体系推进国土空间治理现代化,日益成为当前经济社会发展全面绿色转型的现实要求。综合运用文献研究、归纳演绎和理论分析法,系统梳理空间规划的思想缘起,对比国际上规划实践探索,揭示中国国土空间规划体系变迁历程,并明晰其基础理论与内涵,进而基于新制度主义理论探析国土空间规划体系改革的实践方向。结果表明,空间规划内涵呈现"管理手段-指导理论-宏观制度"演进态势,中国国土空间规划体系发展过程形成"初创期-发展期-转型期-重塑期"格局;生态基点、利益中点、协调节点是统筹规划内涵与演化机制的基础;编制模式初步形成"基本理论与实践基础-理论框架与规划目标-空间分类与分区管控-生态修复与重点建设-规划实施与监督-成果与技术要求"的逻辑进路。未来时期,应从法律法规、体制机制、技术平台、经济社会服务和监督管理等层面,为国土空间规划编制实施保障体系夯基筑台和立柱架梁。

关键词: 国土空间规划, 思想缘起, 理论认知, 实践向度, 新制度主义理论

Abstract: Promoting the modernization of territory land governance with a high-level spatial planning system has increasingly become a realistic requirement for the comprehensive green transformation of current economic and social development. This paper comprehensively uses the methods of literature research, induction and deduction, and theoretical analysis, systematically combs the ideological origin of spatial planning, compares the international planning practice and exploration, and reveals the evolution of China's spatial planning system. It clarifies the basic theory and connotation of spatial planning system, and then explores the practical direction of its reform based on the new institutionalism theory. The research shows that the connotation of spatial planning presents the evolution trend of "management means - guiding theory - macro system", and the development process of China's spatial planning system forms a pattern of "initial period - development period - transformation period - reconstruction period". Ecological base point, interest midpoint and coordination node are the basis of the connotation and evolution mechanism of the overall spatial planning system. The planning model has initially formed the logical route of "basic theory and practical basis - theoretical framework and planning objectives - spatial classification and zone control - ecological restoration and key construction - planning implementation and supervision - achievements and technical requirements". In the future, the security system of spatial planning should be strengthened in terms of laws and regulations, institutional mechanisms, technological platforms, economic and social services, supervision and management.

Key words: spatial planning, ideological origin, theoretical cognition, practical dimension, new institutionalism theory

中图分类号:

F301

牛善栋, 吕晓. 国土空间规划体系研究:理论认知与实践向度[J]. 生态与农村环境学报, 2023, 39(3): 294-305.

NIU Shan-dong, LÜ Xiao. Research on Spatial Planning System: Theoretical Cognition and Practical Dimension[J]. Journal of Ecology and Rural Environment, 2023, 39(3): 294-305.

参考文献 54

[1]	庄少勤.新时代的空间规划逻辑[J].中国土地,2019(1):4-8.[ZHUANG Shao-qin.Spatial Planning Logic in the New Era[J].China Land,2019(1):4-8.]
[2]	吴志强.国土空间规划的五个哲学问题[J].城市规划学刊,2020(6):7-10.[WU Zhi-qiang.Five Philosophical Concerns of the Territorial Spatial Planning[J].Urban Planning Forum,2020(6):7-10.]
[3]	安树伟.落实国家空间规划体系的关键是利益协调[J].区域经济评论,2018(5):18-20.[AN Shu-wei.The Key to Implement the National Spatial Planning System Is the Coordination of Interests[J].Regional Economic Review,2018(5):18-20.]
[4]	王兴中,常芳,赵刚,等.新区域经营观的空间体系价值统一规划理念:我的区域规划社会公正观[J].人文地理,2016,31(2):1-5.[WANG Xing-zhong,CHANG Fang,ZHAO Gang,et al.Planning Concept of Spatial System Value-unification under the New Regional Management Views:My Thinking to Regional Planning Concept of Social Justice[J].Human Geography,2016,31(2):1-5.]
[5]	孙施文.国土空间规划的知识基础及其结构[J].城市规划学刊,2020(6):11-18.[SUN Shi-wen.The Types and Structure of Knowledge in Territorial Spatial Planning[J].Urban Planning Forum,2020(6):11-18.]
[6]	吴志强,张修宁,鲁斐栋,等.技术赋能空间规划:走向规律导向的范式[J].规划师,2021,37(19):5-10.[WU Zhi-qiang,ZHANG Xiu-ning,LU Fei-dong,et al.Emerging Technology and Planning:A New Paradigm Guided by Data-informed Laws[J].Planners,2021,37(19):5-10.]
[7]	张兵.国土空间规划的知与行[J].城市规划学刊,2022(1):10-17.[ZHANG Bing.Knowledge and Action:Reforming the Territorial Spatial Planning System in China[J].Urban Planning Forum,2022(1):10-17.]
[8]	孙施文,张勤,武廷海,等.空间规划基础理论大讨论[J].城市规划,2022,46(1):32-37,43.[SUN Shi-wen,ZHANG Qin,WU Ting-hai,et al.Debates on Basic Theories of Spatial Planning[J].City Planning Review,2022,46(1):32-37,43.]
[9]	邓兴栋,韩文超,霍子文.基于人地和谐的国土空间治理框架:以广州市为例[J].城市规划学刊,2022(2):47-53.[DENG Xing-dong,HAN Wen-chao,HUO Zi-wen.Framework of Territorial Space Governance Based on the Perspective of Humanearth Harmony:The Case of Guangzhou City[J].Urban Planning Forum,2022(2):47-53.]
[10]	潘海霞,赵民.国土空间规划体系构建历程、基本内涵及主要特点[J].城乡规划,2019(5):4-10.[PAN Hai-xia,ZHAO Min.On the Reform Course,Basic Contents and Main Features of Territory Planning System of China[J].Urban and Rural Planning,2019(5):4-10.]
[11]	靳利飞,孟旭光,刘天科.面向生态文明的国土空间规划关键问题研究[J].规划师,2021,37(19):65-71.[JIN Li-fei,MENG Xu-guang,LIU Tian-ke.Some Key Issues in Territory Spatial Planning Toward Ecological Civilization[J].Planners,2021,37(19):65-71.]
[12]	赵毅,郑俊,徐辰,等.县级国土空间总体规划编制关键问题[J].城市规划学刊,2022(2):54-61.[ZHAO Yi,ZHENG Jun,XU Chen,et al.Key Issues in the Making of County-level Territorial Spatial Master Plans[J].Urban Planning Forum,2022(2):54-61.]
[13]	熊健,范宇,张振广,等.区域协调与空间治理背景下的上海大都市圈空间协同规划编制创新探索[J].城市规划学刊,2022(2):76-82.[XIONG Jian,FAN Yu,ZHANG Zhen-guang,et al.Innovative Collaborative Spatial Planning in Shanghai Metropolitan Area under the Background of Regional Coordination and Spatial Governance[J].Urban Planning Forum,2022(2):76-82.]
[14]	李明月,周晓航,周艺霖.市县国土空间规划实施监测指标体系研究:基于生命周期理论的广东省实例分析[J/OL].城市规划,2022:1-11[2022-06-13].https://kns.cnki.net/kcms/detail/11.2378.TU.20220316.1049.002.html.[LI Ming-yue,ZHOU Xiao-hang,ZHOU Yi-lin.Research on the Monitoring Indicator System of Territorial Planning Implementation at City and County Level:A Case Study of Guangdong Province Based on the Life Cycle Theory[J/OL].City Planning Review,2022:1-11[2022-06-13].https://kns.cnki.net/kcms/detail/11.2378.TU.20220316.1049.002.html.]
[15]	段学军,王传胜,李恒鹏,等.村镇建设资源环境承载力测算的基本逻辑与框架[J].生态与农村环境学报,2021,37(7):817-826.[DUAN Xue-jun,WANG Chuan-sheng,LI Heng-peng,et al.Basic Logic and Framework of the Calculation of Resources and Environment Carrying Capacity of Rural and Township Development[J].Journal of Ecology and Rural Environment,2021,37(7):817-826.]
[16]	彭棋,周佳,邵姝遥,等.巢湖湖滨带村庄格局优化方法研究[J].生态与农村环境学报,2022,38(3):300-307.[PENG Qi,ZHOU Jia,SHAO Shu-yao,et al.Method on the Optimization Pattern of Villages in Chaohu Lakeside Zone[J].Journal of Ecology and Rural Environment,2022,38(3):300-307.]
[17]	张彤华,赵永革,于海涛,等.国土空间规划先行性地方立法的意义及对国家层面立法的作用[J].城市规划学刊,2022(2):41-46.[ZHANG Tong-hua,ZHAO Yong-ge,YU Hai-tao,et al.Significance of Advance Local Legislation on Territorial Spatial Planning and Its Implications on National Legislation[J].Urban Planning Forum,2022(2):41-46.]
[18]	沈娉,梁景宇.空间规划应对气候变化的调适策略:台湾"国土计划"的经验与启示[J].国际城市规划,2022,37(2):120-128.[SHEN Ping,LIANG Jing-yu.Climate Change Adaptation Strategies in Spatial Planning:Experience and Lessons of Taiwan's "Spatial Planning"[J].Urban Planning International,2022,37(2):120-128.]
[19]	孙施文,吴唯佳,彭震伟,等.新时代规划教育趋势与未来[J].城市规划,2022,46(1):38-43.[SUN Shi-wen,WU Wei-jia,PENG Zhen-wei,et al.Trend and Future of Planning Education in the New Era[J].City Planning Review,2022,46(1):38-43.]
[20]	丁志刚,石楠,周岚,等.空间治理转型及行业变革[J].城市规划,2022,46(2):12-19,24.[DING Zhi-gang,SHI Nan,ZHOU Lan,et al.Spatial Governance Transformation and Planning Reform[J].City Planning Review,2022,46(2):12-19,24.]
[21]	刘慧,樊杰,王传胜.欧盟空间规划研究进展及启示[J].地理研究,2008,27(6):1381-1389.[LIU Hui,FAN Jie,WANG Chuan-sheng.Progress in the Study of European Spatial Planning and the Inspiration to China[J].Geographical Research,2008,27(6):1381-1389.]
[22]	罗超,王国恩,孙靓雯.中外空间规划发展与改革研究综述[J].国际城市规划,2018,33(5):117-125.[LUO Chao,WANG Guo-en,SUN Liang-wen.Research Review of Spatial Planning Development and Reform in China and Abroad[J].Urban Planning International,2018,33(5):117-125.]
[23]	蔡玉梅,何挺,张建平.法国空间规划体系演变与启示[J].中国土地,2017(7):32-34.[CAI Yu-mei,HE Ting,ZHANG Jian-ping.Evolution and Enlightenment of French Spatial Planning System[J].China Land,2017(7):32-34.]
[24]	周姝天,翟国方,施益军.英国空间规划经验及其对我国的启示[J].国际城市规划,2017,32(4):82-89.[ZHOU Shu-tian,ZHAI Guo-fang,SHI Yi-jun.Spatial Planning Experience in England and Its Implications to China[J].Urban Planning International,2017,32(4):82-89.]
[25]	李志林,包存宽,沈百鑫.德国空间规划体系战略环评的联动机制及对中国的启示[J].国际城市规划,2018,33(5):132-137.[LI Zhi-lin,BAO Cun-kuan,SHEN Bai-xin.Application of Tiering Assessment in German Spatial Planning and Its Enlightenment on Chinese SEA System[J].Urban Planning International,2018,33(5):132-137.]
[26]	谭纵波,高浩歌.日本国土利用规划概观[J].国际城市规划,2018,33(6):1-12.[TAN Zong-bo,GAO Hao-ge.An Overview on Japan's National Land Use Planning[J].Urban Planning International,2018,33(6):1-12.]
[27]	刘海猛,方创琳,李咏红.城镇化与生态环境"耦合魔方"的基本概念及框架[J].地理学报,2019,74(8):1489-1507.[LIU Hai-meng,FANG Chuang-lin,LI Yong-hong.The Coupled Human and Natural Cube:A Conceptual Framework for Analyzing Urbanization and Eco-environment Interactions[J].Acta Geographica Sinica,2019,74(8):1489-1507.]
[28]	蔡玉梅,高延利,张丽佳.荷兰空间规划体系的演变及启示[J].中国土地,2017(8):33-35.[CAI Yu-mei,GAO Yan-li,ZHANG Li-jia.Evolution and Enlightenment of Dutch Spatial Planning System[J].China Land,2017(8):33-35.]
[29]	张京祥,林怀策,陈浩.中国空间规划体系40年的变迁与改革[J].经济地理,2018,38(7):1-6.[ZHANG Jing-xiang,LIN Huai-ce,CHEN Hao.40-year Changes and Reforms of China's Spatial Planning System[J].Economic Geography,2018,38(7):1-6.]
[30]	胡序威.中国区域规划的演变与展望[J].地理学报,2006,61(6):585-592.[HU Xu-wei.Evolution and Prospect of China's Regional Planning[J].Acta Geographica Sinica,2006,61(6):585-592.]
[31]	刘卫东,陆大道.新时期我国区域空间规划的方法论探讨:以"西部开发重点区域规划前期研究"为例[J].地理学报,2005,60(6):894-902.[LIU Wei-dong,LU Da-dao.Methodological Basis for Making Regional Spatial Planning in China in the New Era:A Preliminary Study Based on Planning of Key Economic Regions in Developing Western China[J].Acta Geographica Sinica,2005,60(6):894-902.]
[32]	林坚,陈诗弘,许超诣,等.空间规划的博弈分析[J].城市规划学刊,2015(1):10-14.[LIN Jian,CHEN Shi-hong,XU Chao-yi,et al.Game Analysis of Spatial Planning[J].Urban Planning Forum,2015(1):10-14.]
[33]	周依敏,刘敏.关于我国区域规划编制趋势特点的思考[J].经济体制改革,2014(2):45-48.[ZHOU Yi-min,LIU Min.Thoughts on the Characteristics of Regional Planning Trend in China[J].Reform of Economic System,2014(2):45-48.]
[34]	樊杰,郭锐."十四五"时期国土空间治理的科学基础与战略举措[J].城市规划学刊,2021(3):15-20.[FAN Jie,GUO Rui.Scientific Foundations and Strategies of National Territorial Spatial Governance during the 14th Five-year-plan Period in China[J].Urban Planning Forum,2021(3):15-20.]
[35]	王向东,刘卫东.中国空间规划体系:现状、问题与重构[J].经济地理,2012,32(5):7-15,29.[WANG Xiang-dong,LIU Wei-dong.Spatial Planning System in China:Status,Problems and Reconstruction[J].Economic Geography,2012,32(5):7-15,29.]
[36]	严金明,陈昊,夏方舟."多规合一"与空间规划:认知、导向与路径[J].中国土地科学,2017,31(1):21-27,87.[YAN Jin-ming,CHEN Hao,XIA Fang-zhou.Cognition,Direction and Path of Future Spatial Planning Based on the Background of Multiple Planning Integration[J].China Land Sciences,2017,31(1):21-27,87.]
[37]	林坚,文爱平,林坚:重构中国特色空间规划体系[J].北京规划建设,2018(4):184-187.[LIN Jian,WEN Ai-ping,LIN Jian:Reconstructing China's Characteristic Space Planning System[J].Beijing Planning Review,2018(4):184-187.]
[38]	郝庆.对机构改革背景下空间规划体系构建的思考[J].地理研究,2018,37(10):1938-1946.[HAO Qing.The Construction of Spatial Planning System under the Background of Institutional Reform[J].Geographical Research,2018,37(10):1938-1946.]
[39]	梁琦.构建空间规划体系应处理好四个问题[J].区域经济评论,2018(5):21-22.[LIANG Qi.Four Problems Should Be Dealt with in Constructing Spatial Planning System[J].Regional Economic Review,2018(5):21-22.]
[40]	江东,林刚,付晶莹."三生空间"统筹的科学基础与优化途径探析[J].自然资源学报,2021,36(5):1085-1101.[JIANG Dong,LIN Gang,FU Jing-ying.Discussion on Scientific Foundation and Approach for the Overall Optimization of "Production-living-ecological" Space[J].Journal of Natural Resources,2021,36(5):1085-1101.]
[41]	郝庆,封志明,邓玲.基于人文-经济地理学视角的空间规划理论体系[J].经济地理,2018,38(8):5-10.[HAO Qing,FENG Zhi-ming,DENG Ling.Spatial Planning Theory System from the Perspective of Human-economic Geography[J].Economic Geography,2018,38(8):5-10.]
[42]	郝庆,彭建,魏冶,等."国土空间"内涵辨析与国土空间规划编制建议[J].自然资源学报,2021,36(9):2219-2247.[HAO Qing,PENG Jian,WEI Ye,et al.The Connotation of Territory and the Suggestions of Drawing up Spatial Planning in the New Era[J].Journal of Natural Resources,2021,36(9):2219-2247.]
[43]	董祚继.从机构改革看国土空间治理能力的提升[J].中国土地,2018(11):4-9.[DONG Zuo-ji.On the Improvement of Land and Space Governance Capacity from the Perspective of Institutional Reform[J].China Land,2018(11):4-9.]
[44]	田双清,陈磊,姜海.从土地用途管制到国土空间用途管制:演进历程、轨迹特征与政策启示[J].经济体制改革,2020(4):12-18.[TIAN Shuang-qing,CHEN Lei,JIANG Hai.From Land Use Regulation to Territorial Space Use Regulation:Evolution Process,Trajectory Characteristics and Policy Enlightenment[J].Reform of Economic System,2020(4):12-18.]
[45]	袁奇峰,谭诗敏,李刚,等.空间规划:为何?何为?何去?[J].规划师,2018(7):11-17,25.[YUAN Qi-feng,TAN Shi-min,LI Gang,et al.Objectives,Functions,and Orientation of Spatial Planning[J].Planners,2018(7):11-17,25.]
[46]	罗超,王国恩,孙靓雯.我国城市空间增长现状剖析及制度反思[J].城市规划学刊,2015(6):46-55.[LUO Chao,WANG Guo-en,SUN Liang-wen.An Analysis of China's Urban Spatial Growth and Reflections on Institutions[J].Urban Planning Forum,2015(6):46-55.]
[47]	邓羽.城市空间扩展的自组织特征与规划管控效应评估:以北京市为例[J].地理研究,2016,35(2):353-362.[DENG Yu.Self-organization Characteristics of Urban Extension and the Planning Effect Evaluation:A Case Study of Beijing[J].Geographical Research,2016,35(2):353-362.]
[48]	余玲,刘家明,李涛,等.中国城市公共游憩空间研究进展[J].地理学报,2018,73(10):1923-1941.[YU Ling,LIU Jia-ming,LI Tao,et al.Research Progress of Urban Public Recreational Space in China[J].Acta Geographica Sinica,2018,73(10):1923-1941.]
[49]	徐晶,朱志兵,余亦奇.空间规划用地分类体系初探[J].中国土地,2018(7):22-24.[XU Jing,ZHU Zhi-bing,YU Yi-qi.Preliminary Study on Classification System of Planning Land[J].China Land,2018(7):22-24.]
[50]	汪芳,王舜奕,PROMINSKI Martin.城镇化与地方性中的水资源:可持续视角的水环境保护利用与水空间规划设计[J].地理研究,2018,37(12):2576-2584.[WANG Fang,WANG Shun-yi,MARTIN P.Water-related Urbanization and Locality:Protection and Utilization of Water Environment as Well as Planning and Design of Water Space in a Sustainable Perspective[J].Geographical Research,2018,37(12):2576-2584.]
[51]	杨保军.城市总体规划改革的回顾和展望[J].中国土地,2018(10):9-13.[YANG Bao-jun.Retrospect and Prospect of Urban Master Plan Reform[J].China Land,2018(10):9-13.]
[52]	黄征学.完善空间治理体系的几点思考[J].中国土地,2018(11):10-12.[HUANG Zheng-xue.Some Thoughts on Perfecting the Spatial Governance System[J].China Land,2018(11):10-12.]
[53]	孙安军.空间规划改革的思考[J].城市规划学刊,2018(1):10-17.[SUN An-jun.Thinking on Spatial Planning Reform[J].Urban Planning Forum,2018(1):10-17.]
[54]	于丹丹,童文君,刘威,等.基于"自然未来框架"的中国生物多样性保护目标情景研究初探[J].生态与农村环境学报,2021,37(10):1234-1241.[YU Dan-dan,TONG Wen-jun,LIU Wei,et al.A Preliminary Study on Scenarios for Biodiversity Targets in China Based on the "Nature Futures Framework"[J].Journal of Ecology and Rural Environment,2021,37(10):1234-1241.]