土壤环境中抗生素抗性基因污染研究进展和热点分析

doi:10.19741/j.issn.1673-4831.2022.0793

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 近年来,土壤环境中抗生素抗性基因(ARGs)污染引起广泛关注。以Web of Science核心数据库和万方数据库文献资料为数据源进行文献计量学分析,从年发文量变化、不同国家贡献及研究主题演变(基于关键词)等方面对土壤环境中ARGs污染相关研究进行剖析,以此探讨国内外该领域的研究现状、热点和发展。结果表明,土壤中ARGs污染相关研究的发文数量快速增长。我国文献在发文数量、论文被引频次方面具有重要影响,表明我国在该领域有较强的国际学术影响力。关键词聚类分析表明该领域的研究方向主要集中在以下5个方面:(1)土壤中携带ARGs的微生物及其环境行为;(2)土壤环境中ARGs的来源和持久性;(3)土壤环境中ARGs的传播和消减方法;(4)土壤中共存物质对ARGs丰度和迁移行为的影响;(5)农业生产活动对土壤环境中ARGs污染的影响。同时,在介绍ARGs常用检测方法以及土壤环境中ARGs污染来源和分布的基础上,剖析影响ARGs在土壤中传播的多种因素,探讨土壤环境中ARGs的消减方法,并指出当前研究尚存的不足之处以及今后的研究方向。该文可为未来土壤环境中ARGs污染领域的研究和风险管控提供参考。

关键词: 土壤, 抗生素抗性基因, 水平基因转移, 文献计量, 研究进展, 消减方法

Abstract: In recent years, antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) in soil environments have attracted widespread attention. A bibliometric analysis was conducted using the Web of Science core database and Wanfang database as data sources to analyze the researches on ARGs contamination in soil environments from the aspects of annual publication volume, contributions from different countries, and the evolution of research topics (based on keywords). The aim was to explore the current status, hotspots, and development trends in this domain both domestically and internationally. The results show a rapid increase in the number of publications annually on ARGs contamination in soil. Chinese literature had a significant impact in terms of publication volume and citation frequency, indicating its strong international academic influence in this field. Keyword clustering analysis revealed that the current researches in this field have been mainly focused on the following areas: (1) microorganisms carrying ARGs in the soil environments; (2) source and persistence of ARGs in soil environments; (3) transmission and reduction methods of ARGs in soil environments; (4) the influence of coexisting substances in soil on the abundance and migration behavior of ARGs; (5) the impact of agricultural production activities on ARGs contamination in soil environments. Additionally, commonly used detection methods for ARGs were introduced, the sources and distribution of ARGs contamination in soil environments were also analyzed. Various factors influencing the spread of ARGs were analyzed, and methods for reducing ARGs in soil environments were discussed. Current shortcomings and future research directions in this field have been pointed out. This article can serve as a reference for future research and risk management in the field of ARGs contamination in soil environments.

Key words: soil, antibiotic resistance gene, horizontal gene transfer, bibliometric analysis, research progress, remediation method

中图分类号:

李泽楷, 韩淼, 秦超, 胡小婕, 高彦征. 土壤环境中抗生素抗性基因污染研究进展和热点分析[J]. 生态与农村环境学报, 2024, 40(1): 11-22.

LI Ze-kai, HAN Miao, QIN Chao, HU Xiao-jie, GAO Yan-zheng. Research Progress and Hot Spot Analysis on Antibiotic Resistance Gene Pollution in Soil Environment[J]. Journal of Ecology and Rural Environment, 2024, 40(1): 11-22.

参考文献

[1] 周志洪,吴清柱,王秀娟,等.环境中抗生素污染现状及检测技术[J].分析仪器,2016(6):1-8.[ZHOU Zhi-hong,WU Qing-zhu,WANG Xiu-juan,et al.A Review on Present Situation and Detection Technology of Antibiotics Pollution in Environment［J].Analytical Instrumentation,2016(6):1-8.］
[2] MARTINEZ J L.Environmental Pollution by Antibiotics and by Antibiotic Resistance Determinants[J].Environmental Pollution,2009,157(11):2893-2902.
[3] 王丽梅,罗义,毛大庆,等.抗生素抗性基因在环境中的传播扩散及抗性研究方法[J].应用生态学报,2010,21(4):1063-1069.[WANG Li-mei,LUO Yi,MAO Da-qing,et al.Transport of Antibiotic Resistance Genes in Environment and Detection Methods of Antibiotic Resistance［J].Chinese Journal of Applied Ecology,2010,21(4):1063-1069.］
[4] ZHU Y G,JOHNSON T A,SU J Q,et al.Diverse and Abundant Antibiotic Resistance Genes in Chinese Swine Farms[J].Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America,2013,110(9):3435-3440.
[5] BROWN M G,MITCHELL E H,BALKWILL D L.Tet 42,a Novel Tetracycline Resistance Determinant Isolated from Deep Terrestrial Subsurface Bacteria[J].Antimicrobial Agents and Chemotherapy,2008,52(12):4518-4521.
[6] SUN J T,JIN L,HE T T,et al.Antibiotic Resistance Genes (ARGs) in Agricultural Soils from the Yangtze River Delta,China[J].Science of the Total Environment,2020,740:140001.
[7] KNAPP C W,DOLFING J,EHLERT P A I,et al.Evidence of Increasing Antibiotic Resistance Gene Abundances in Archived Soils since 1940[J].Environmental Science & Technology,2010,44(2):580-587.
[8] 黄福义,周曙仡聃,王佳妮,等.不同作物农田土壤抗生素抗性基因多样性[J].环境科学,2021,42(6):2975-2980.[HUANG Fu-yi,ZHOU Shu-yi-dan,WANG Jia-ni,et al.Profiling of Antibiotic Resistance Genes in Different Croplands［J].Environmental Science,2021,42(6):2975-2980.］
[9] AARESTRUP F M,AGERSO Y,GERNER-SMIDT P,et al.Comparison of Antimicrobial Resistance Phenotypes and Resistance Genes in Enterococcus faecalis and Enterococcus faecium from Humans in the Community,Broilers,and Pigs in Denmark[J].Diagnostic Microbiology and Infectious Disease,2000,37(2):127-137.
[10] BIEMER J J.Antimicrobial Susceptibility Testing by the Kirby-Bauer Disc Diffusion Method[J].Annals of Clinical Laboratory Science,1973,3(2):135-140.
[11] CALL D R.Challenges and Opportunities for Pathogen Detection Using DNA Microarrays[J].Critical Reviews in Microbiology,2005,31(2):91-99.
[12] 刘燕,路璐.贡嘎山不同海拔土壤中抗生素抗性基因的多样性特征[J].西昌学院学报(自然科学版),2021,35(2):1-7.[LIU Yan,LU Lu.Diversity of Antibiotic Resistance Genes in Soils along Elevations of the Gongga Mountain［J].Journal of Xichang University (Natural Science Edition),2021,35(2):1-7.］
[13] SONOLA V S,KATAKWEBA A S,MISINZO G,et al.Occurrence of Multi-drug-resistant Escherichia coli in Chickens,Humans,Rodents and Household Soil in Karatu,Northern Tanzania[J].Antibiotics (Basel,Switzerland),2021,10(9):1137.
[14] MUNIR M,XAGORARAKI I.Levels of Antibiotic Resistance Genes in Manure,Biosolids,and Fertilized Soil[J].Journal of Environmental Quality,2011,40(1):248-255.
[15] BASTOS M C,DOS SANTOS D R,AUBERTHEAU É,et al.Antibiotics and Microbial Resistance in Brazilian Soils under Manure Application[J].Land Degradation & Development,2018,29(8):2472-2484.
[16] KNAPP C W,CALLAN A C,AITKEN B,et al.Relationship between Antibiotic Resistance Genes and Metals in Residential Soil Samples from Western Australia[J].Environmental Science and Pollution Research,2017,24(3):2484-2494.
[17] 王彩霞.南北极地区抗生素抗性基因的分布特征和来源解析[D].上海:上海海洋大学,2020.[WANG Cai-xia.Occurrence and Source of Antibiotic Resistance Genes in Arctic and Antarctic［D].Shanghai:Shanghai Ocean University,2020.］
[18] VAN GOETHEM M W,PIERNEEF R,BEZUIDT O K I,et al.A Reservoir of 'Historical’ Antibiotic Resistance Genes in Remote Pristine Antarctic Soils[J].Microbiome,2018,6(1):40.
[19] ZHANG S H,YANG G L,HOU S G,et al.Distribution of ARGs and MGEs among Glacial Soil,Permafrost,and Sediment Using Metagenomic Analysis[J].Environmental Pollution,2018,234:339-346.
[20] ZHAO X,WANG J H,ZHU L S,et al.Environmental Analysis of Typical Antibiotic-resistant Bacteria and ARGs in Farmland Soil Chronically Fertilized with Chicken Manure[J].Science of the Total Environment,2017,593/594:10-17.
[21] SCHMITT H,STOOB K,HAMSCHER G,et al.Tetracyclines and Tetracycline Resistance in Agricultural Soils:Microcosm and Field Studies[J].Microbial Ecology,2006,51(3):267-276.
[22] 赵翰斌,陈鑫,武广哲,等.畜禽养殖场污水处理系统中诺氟沙星抗性菌的筛选及其抗性基因分析[J].生态与农村环境学报,2020,36(2):250-256.[ZHAO Han-bin,CHEN Xin,WU Guang-zhe,et al.Isolation of Norfloxacin Resistant Bacteria and Analysis of Its Antibiotic Resistance Genes from the Wastewater Treatment System of a Livestock Farm［J].Journal of Ecology and Rural Environment,2020,36(2):250-256.］
[23] BOUGNOM B P,THIELE-BRUHN S,RICCI V,et al.Raw Wastewater Irrigation for Urban Agriculture in Three African Cities Increases the Abundance of Transferable Antibiotic Resistance Genes in Soil,Including Those Encoding Extended Spectrum β-lactamases (ESBLs)[J].The Science of the Total Environment,2020,698:134201.
[24] RAHUBE T O,MARTI R,SCOTT A,et al.Persistence of Antibiotic Resistance and Plasmid-associated Genes in Soil Following Application of Sewage Sludge and Abundance on Vegetables at Harvest[J].Canadian Journal of Microbiology,2016,62(7):600-607.
[25] 卢文强,孙昊宇,王雅娟,等.抗生素的胁迫与抗生素抗性基因产生与传播关系的研究[J].生态毒理学报,2020,15(4):129-138.[LU Wen-qiang,SUN Hao-yu,WANG Ya-juan,et al.The Relationship of Antibiotic Stress with Emergence and Dissemination of Antibiotic Resistance Genes［J].Asian Journal of Ecotoxicology,2020,15(4):129-138.］
[26] BEARSON B L,BRUNELLE B W.Fluoroquinolone Induction of Phage-mediated Gene Transfer in Multidrug-resistant Salmonella[J].International Journal of Antimicrobial Agents,2015,46(2):201-204.
[27] ANDERSSON D I,HUGHES D.Microbiological Effects of Sublethal Levels of Antibiotics[J].Nature Reviews Microbiology,2014,12(7):465-478.
[28] 杨统一,李静,唐国腾,等.外源Zn对土壤抗生素抗性基因及细菌群落的诱导作用[J].生态与农村环境学报,2022,38(2):236-243.[YANG Tong-yi,LI Jing,TANG Guo-teng,et al.Induction of Antibiotic Resistance Genes and Bacterial Community in Soil by Exogenous Zn［J].Journal of Ecology and Rural Environment,2022,38(2):236-243.］
[29] 戎玲玲,王复标,吴礼贵,等.细菌对抗生素与重金属的联合抗性机制研究进展[J].环境污染与防治,2021,43(8):1062-1068,1076.[RONG Ling-ling,WANG Fu-biao,WU Li-gui,et al.Research Advances on the Co-contaminated Resistance Mechanism of Antibiotics and Heavy Metals in Bacteria［J].Environmental Pollution & Control,2021,43(8):1062-1068,1076.］
[30] HU H W,WANG J T,LI J,et al.Long-term Nickel Contamination Increases the Occurrence of Antibiotic Resistance Genes in Agricultural Soils[J].Environmental Science & Technology,2017,51(2):790-800.
[31] 孙东昌,王兵,竺利红.胁迫诱导抗性基因转移导致细菌耐药的分子机制研究进展[J].微生物学报,2013,53(7):641-647.[SUN Dong-chang,WANG Bing,ZHU Li-hong.Advances in Molecular Mechanisms of Bacterial Resistance Caused by Stress-induced Transfer of Resistance Genes:A Review［J].Acta Microbiologica Sinica,2013,53(7):641-647.］
[32] THOMAS C M,NIELSEN K M.Mechanisms of,and Barriers to,Horizontal Gene Transfer between Bacteria[J].Nature Reviews Microbiology,2005,3(9):711-721.
[33] SUN M M,YE M,WU J,et al.Impact of Bioaccessible Pyrene on the Abundance of Antibiotic Resistance Genes during Sphingobium Sp.- and Sophorolipid-enhanced Bioremediation in Soil[J].Journal of Hazardous Materials,2015,300:121-128.
[34] PRUDHOMME M,ATTAIECH L,SANCHEZ G,et al.Antibiotic Stress Induces Genetic Transformability in the Human Pathogen Streptococcus pneumoniae[J].Science,2006,313(5783):89-92.
[35] LI M M,RAY P,TEETS C,et al.Increasing Temperature and pH Can Facilitate Reductions of Cephapirin and Antibiotic Resistance Genes in Dairy Manure Slurries[J].Journal of Dairy Science,2020,103(3):2877-2882.
[36] WANG Y J,KOU S M,JIANG Q Y,et al.Factors Affecting Transfer of Degradative Plasmids between Bacteria in Soils[J].Applied Soil Ecology,2014,84:254-261.
[37] TIAN Z,ZHANG Y,YU B,et al.Changes of Resistome,Mobilome and Potential Hosts of Antibiotic Resistance Genes during the Transformation of Anaerobic Digestion from Mesophilic to Thermophilic[J].Water Research,2016,98:261-269.
[38] QIAN X,SUN W,GU J,et al.Reducing Antibiotic Resistance Genes,Integrons,and Pathogens in Dairy Manure by Continuous Thermophilic Composting[J].Bioresource Technology,2016,220:425-432.
[39] WANG L,ZHENG J L,HUANG X.Co-composting Materials Can Further Affect the Attenuation of Antibiotic Resistome in Soil Application[J].Waste Management,2021,135:329-337.
[40] CUI E P,CUI B J,FAN X Y,et al.Ryegrass (Lolium multiflorum L.) and Indian Mustard (Brassica juncea L.) Intercropping Can Improve the Phytoremediation of Antibiotics and Antibiotic Resistance Genes but Not Heavy Metals[J].Science of the Total Environment,2021,784:147093.
[41] CHAO H Z,ZHENG X X,XIA R,et al.Incubation Trial Indicated the Earthworm Intestinal Bacteria as Promising Biodigestor for Mitigating Tetracycline Resistance Risk in Anthropogenic Disturbed Forest Soil[J].Science of the Total Environment,2021,798:149337.
[42] SHI Y K,LIN H,MA J W,et al.Degradation of Tetracycline Antibiotics by Arthrobacter nicotianae OTC-16[J].Journal of Hazardous Materials,2021,403:123996.
[43] WANG Y,WANG X J,LI Y,et al.Effects of Struvite-loaded Zeolite Amendment on the Fate of Copper,Tetracycline and Antibiotic Resistance Genes in Microplastic-contaminated Soil[J].Chemical Engineering Journal,2022,430:130478.
[44] XU M,WANG F,SHENG H J,et al.Does Anaerobic Condition Play a More Positive Role in Dissipation of Antibiotic Resistance Genes in Soil?[J].Science of the Total Environment,2021,757:143737.