畜禽养殖氨排放清单研究现状与实证

doi:10.11934/j.issn.1673-4831.2018.09.007

摘要/Abstract

摘要：

氨在雾霾形成中起着关键作用，从源头上控制氨排放，对提升空气环境质量尤为重要，而畜禽养殖作为人为源氨排放的重要来源备受关注。准确的畜禽养殖氨排放清单对于核算氨排放量、识别主要排放源进而制定有效的畜禽氨减排政策具有重要意义。通过梳理畜禽养殖氨排放清单的发展历程，总结欧盟、美国和中国畜禽养殖氨排放清单的运用情况，结合某生猪养殖场实测数据，对比分析中国指南和欧盟方法（EEA方法）。结果表明，畜禽氨排放清单归纳总结为整体系数法、阶段系数法；用EEA方法核算的栏舍、存储环节氨排放系数显著高于中国指南核算结果和实测结果，中国指南核算结果与实测结果大致接近，归因于中国指南对于关键参数如总氨态氮（TAN）进行了本土化取值，但氨挥发率等核心参数的本土化研究的缺乏仍然制约清单的准确性；清单参数结构与中国现有的畜禽基量统计数据匹配度不高。亟需进一步深入开展畜禽排泄物中TAN量、氨挥发率和非氨转化率等基础核心参数的实测研究，以便为中国养殖业氨排放清单本土化编制工作提供理论支撑。

关键词: 畜禽养殖, 氨排放, 排放清单, 排放因子

Abstract:

Ammonia plays a key role in the formation of haze, therefore, controlling ammonia emission from pollution sources is an effective measure to improve air quality, in which livestock is one of most important sources. Through investigating the development process of the ammonia emission inventory of livestock, the application of the ammonia emission inventory of livestock in the United States and China was summarized. At the same time, combined with the measured data of a pig farm, the Chinese guide and the European Union method (EEA method) were compared and analyzed. The results show that (1) there are two kinds of methods to develop the ammonia emission inventory, the total coefficient method and stage coefficient method, respectively; (2) the ammonia emission coefficients of livestock house and storage measured by the EEA method were significantly higher than the results of China's guide and the actual measured results, meanwhile, the results of China's guide were roughly close to the actual measured results. It was attributed to the localization of key parameters, such as total ammonium nitrogen (TAN), in China's guide, however, the accuracy of the inventory is still restricted by lacking of the research on the ratio of ammonia emission in different stages; (3) the structure of ammonia emission inventory parameters can not match with the base quantity of livestock in China. Therefore, it is urgent to further carry out the field measurement of basic parameters, such as the amount of TAN in the livestock excrement, ammonia volatilization rate, and non-ammonia conversion rate, so as to provide the theoretical support for the establishment of indigenization livestock ammonia emission inventory in China.

Key words: livestock, ammonia emission, emission inventory, emission factor

中图分类号:

X501
X51

王文林, 童仪, 杜薇, 高岩, 刘筱, 关雷, 曾杰亮, 范军旗, 吴琼, 李文静, 何斐, 刘波, 赵学涛. 畜禽养殖氨排放清单研究现状与实证[J]. 生态与农村环境学报, 2018, 34(9): 813-820.

WANG Wen-lin, TONG Yi, DU Wei, GAO Yan, LIU Xiao, GUAN Lei, ZENG Jie-liang, FAN Jun-qi, WU Qiong, LI Wen-jing, HE Fei, LIU Bo, ZHAO Xue-tao. Empirical Study on Ammonia Emission Inventory From Livestock[J]. Journal of Ecology and Rural Environment, 2018, 34(9): 813-820.

参考文献

[1] FENG L,LIAO W J.Legislation,Plans,and Policies for Prevention and Control of Air Pollution in China:Achievements,Challenges,and Improvements[J].Journal of Cleaner Production,2016,112(Part 2):1549-1558.
[2] HO K F,HO S S H,HUANG R J,et al.Chemical Composition and Bioreactivity of PM_2.5 During 2013 Haze Events in China[J].Atmospheric Environment,2016,126:162-170.
[3] YANG F,TAN J H,ZHAO Q Q,et al.Characteristics of PM_2.5 Speciation in Representative Megacities and Across China[J].Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics,2011,11(11):1025-1051.
[4] DEDOUSSI I C,BARRETT S R H.Air Pollution and Early Deaths in the United States:Part Ⅱ:Attribution of PM_2.5 Exposure to Emissions Species,Time,Location and Sector[J].Atmospheric Environment,2014,99:610-617.
[5] WEI L F,DUAN J C,TAN J H,et al.Gas-to-Particle Conversion of Atmospheric Ammonia and Sampling Artifacts of Ammonium in Spring of Beijing[J].Science China Earth Sciences,2014,58(3):345-355.
[6] 韦莲芳,段菁春,谭吉华,等.北京春季大气中氨的气粒相转化及颗粒态铵采样偏差研究[J].中国科学:地球科学,2015,45(2):216-226.
[7] CUI H Y,CHEN W H,DAI W,et al.Source Apportionment of PM_2.5 in Guangzhou Combining Observation Data Analysis and Chemical Transport Model Simulation[J].Atmospheric Environment,2015,116:262-271.
[8] WANG J D,WANG S X,VOORHEES A S,et al.Assessment of Short-Term PM_2.5-Related Mortality Due to Different Emission Sources in the Yangtze River Delta,China[J].Atmospheric Environment,2015,123(Part B):440-448.
[9] TURŠIC J,BERNER A,PODKRAJŠEK B,et al.Influence of Ammonia on Sulfate Formation Under Haze Conditions[J].Atmospheric Environment,2004,38(18):2789-2795.
[10] 王文林,刘波,韩睿明,等.农业源氨排放影响因素研究进展[J].生态与农村环境学报,2016,32(6):870-878.[WANG Wen-lin,LIU Bo,HAN Rui-ming,et al.Review of Researches on Factors Affecting Emission of Ammonia From Agriculture[J].Journal of Ecology and Rural Environment,2016,32(6):870-878.]
[11] GALLOWAY J N,DENTENER F J,CAPONE D G,et al.Nitrogen Cycles:Past,Present,and Future[J].Biogeochemistry,2004,70(2):153-226.
[12] KANNARI A,TONOOKA Y,BABA T,et al.Development of Multiple-Species 1 km×1 km Resolution Hourly Basis Emissions Inventory for Japan[J].Atmospheric Environment,2007,41(16):3428-3439.
[13] FAULKNER W B,SHAW B W.Review of Ammonia Emission Factors for United States Animal Agriculture[J].Atmospheric Environment,2008,42(27):6567-6574.
[14] 生态环境部.大气氨源排放清单编制技术指南[EB/OL].[2018-02-25].http://www.mep.gov.cn/gkml/hbb/bgg/201408/W020140828351293771578.pdf.
[15] PAIN B F,VAN DER WEERDEN T J,CHAMBERS B J,et al.A New Inventory for Ammonia Emissions From U. K. Agriculture[J].Atmospheric Environment,1998,32(3):309-313.
[16] EEA.EMEP/EEA Air Pollutant Emission Inventory Guidebook 2013[M].Denmark:European Environment Agency,2013.
[17] ROSS C A,SCHOLEFIELD D,JARVIS S C.A Model of Ammonia Volatilisation From a Dairy Farm:An Examination of Abatement Strategies[J].Nutrient Cycling in Agroecosystems,2002,64(3):273-281.
[18] GROENWOLD J G,OUDENDAG D,LUESINK H.Het Mest:En Ammoniakmodel[R].Den Haag:LEI,2002.
[19] HUTCHINGS N J,SOMMER S G,ANDERSEN J M,et al.A Detailed Ammonia Emission Inventory for Denmark[J].Atmospheric Environment,2001,35(11):1959-1968.
[20] VAN EVERT F K,TEN BERGE H F M,VAN DER MEER H G,et al.FARMMIN:Modeling Crop-Livestock Nutrient Flows[C].Netherlands:Plant Research International,2003.
[21] WEBB J,MISSELBROOK T H.A Mass-Flow Model of Ammonia Emissions From UK Livestock Production[J].Atmospheric Environment,2004,38(14):2163-2176.
[22] DÄMMGEN U,LÜTTICH M,DÖHLER H,et al.GAS-EM:A Procedure to Calculate Gaseous Emissions From Agriculture[J].Landbauforschung Volkenrode,2002,52(1):19-42.
[23] SOMMER S G,HUTCHINGS N J.Ammonia Emission From Field Applied Manure and Its Reduction:Invited Paper[J].European Journal of Agronomy,2001,15(1):1-15.
[24] USEPA.National Emission Inventory:Ammonia Emissions From Animal Husbandry Operations Draft Report[R].Washington DC,USEPA,2004.
[25] GOEBES M D,STRADER R,DAVIDSON C.An Ammonia Emission Inventory for Fertilizer Application in the United States[J].Atmospheric Environment,2003,37(18):2539-2550.
[26] 王文兴,卢筱凤,庞燕波,等.中国氨的排放强度地理分布[J].环境科学学报,1997,17(1):2-7.[WANG Wen-xing,LU Xiao-feng,PANG Yan-bo,et al.Geographical Distribution of NH₃ Emission Intensities in China[J].Actaentiae Circumstantiae,1997,17(1):2-7.]
[27] 王振刚,宋振东.湖北省人为源氨排放的历史分布[J].环境科学与技术,2005,28(1):70-71.
[28] 房效凤,沈根祥,徐昶,等.上海市农业源氨排放清单及分布特征[J].浙江农业学报,2015,27(12):2177-2185.[FANG Xiao-feng,SHEN Gen-xiang,XU Chang,et al.Agricultural Ammonia Emission Inventory and Its Distribution Characteristics in Shanghai[J].Acta Agriculturae Zhejiangensis,2015,27(12):2177-2185.]
[29] 余飞翔,晁娜,吴建,等.浙江省2013年农业源氨排放清单研究[J].环境污染与防治,2016,38(10):41-46.[YU Fei-xiang,CHAO Na,WU Jian,et al.Research on Agricultural Ammonia Emission Inventory of Zhejiang Province in 2013[J].Environmental Pollution & Control,2016,38(10):41-46.]
[30] 张灿,翟崇治,周志恩,等.重庆市主城区农业源氨排放研究[J].中国环境监测,2014,30(3):90-96.[ZHANG Can,ZHAI Chong-zhi,ZHOU Zhi-en,et al.Research on Ammonia Emission From Agricultural Sources in Chongqing Urban City[J].Environmental Monitoring in China,2014,30(3):90-96.]
[31] 张双,王阿婧,张增杰,等.北京市人为源氨排放清单的初步建立[J].安全与环境学报,2016,16(2):242-245.[ZHANG Shuang,WANG A-jing,ZHANG Zeng-jie,et al.On Creating an Anthropogenic Ammonia Emission Inventory in Capital Beijing[J].Journal of Safety and Environment,2016,16(2):242-245.]
[32] 王阿婧,张双,瞿艳芝,等.氨排放清单编制的初步研究[J].湖北农业科学,2016,55(2):345-348.[WANG A-jing,ZHANG Shuang,QU Yan-zhi,et al.A Preliminary Study on Compiling the Ammonia Emission Inventory[J].Hubei Agricultural Sciences,2016,55(2):345-348.]
[33] 杨志鹏.基于物质流方法的中国畜牧业氨排放估算及区域比较研究[D].北京:北京大学,2008.[YANG Zhi-peng.Estimation of Ammonia Emission From Livestock in China Based on Mass-Flow Method and Regional Comparison[D].Beijing:Peking University,2008.]
[34] 刘东,马林,王方浩,等.中国猪粪尿N产生量及其分布的研究[J].农业环境科学学报,2007,26(4):1591-1595.[LIU Dong,MA lin,WANG Fang-hao,et al.Amount and Distribution of N Excretion From Pig Manure in China[J].Journal of Agro-Environment Science,2007,26(4):1591-1595.]
[35] 刘东.中国猪和奶牛粪尿氨(NH₃)挥发的评价研究[D].保定:河北农业大学,2007.[LIU Dong.Evaluation of NH₃ Emission From Pig and Dairy Cow Manure in China[D].Baoding:Hebei Agricultural University,2007.]
[36] 刘东,王方浩,马林,等.中国猪粪尿NH₃排放因子的估算[J].农业工程学报,2008,24(4):218-224.[LIU Dong,WANG Fang-hao,MA Lin,et al.Estimation of NH₃ Emission Factor for Pig Manure in China[J].Transactions of the CSAE,2008,24(4):218-224.]
[37] 陈园.上海市典型规模化猪场氨排放特征研究[D].上海:华东理工大学,2017.[CHEN Yuan.Study on Characteristics of Ammonia Emission From Typical Large Scale Pig Farm in Shanghai[D].Shanghai:East China University of Science and Technology,2017.]
[38] 代小蓉.集约化猪场NH₃的排放系数研究[D].杭州:浙江大学,2010.[DAI Xiao-rong.Study on Ammonia Emission Factors in Concentrated Pig Farm[D].Hangzhou:Zhejiang University,2010.]
[39] SALAZAR F,MARTÍNEZ-LAGOS J,ALFARO M,et al.Ammonia Emissions From Urea Application to Permanent Pasture on a Volcanic Soil[J].Atmospheric Environment,2012,61:395-399.
[40] 耿红,高芳,陈霖,等.畜禽源氨气排放因子估算方法研究[J].环境科学学报,2017,37(8):3077-3084.[GENG Hong,GAO Fang,CHEN Lin,et al.Estimation of Ammonia Emission Factors for Livestock and Poultry Breeding[J].Acta Scientiae Circumstantiae,2017,37(8):3077-3084.]
[41] ANDERSON N,STRADER R,DAVIDSON C.Airborne Reduced Nitrogen:Ammonia Emissions From Agriculture and Other Sources[J].Environment International,2003,29(2/3):277-286.
[42] BEUSEN A H W,BOUWMAN A F,HEUBERGER P S C,et al.Bottom-Up Uncertainty Estimates of Global Ammonia Emissions From Global Agricultural Production Systems[J].Atmospheric Environment,2008,42(24):6067-6077.
[43] TAKAI H,PEDERSEN S,JOHNSEN J O,et al.Concentrations and Emissions of Ammonia in Livestock Buildings in Northern Europe[J].Journal of Agricultural Engineering Research,1998,70(1):59-77.
[44] ANDERSON N,STRADER R,DAVIDSON C.Airborne Reduced Nitrogen:Ammonia Emissions From Agriculture and Other Sources[J].Environment International,2003,29(2/3):277-286.
[45] MANNEBECK H,OLDENBURG J.Comparison of the Effects of Different Systems on Ammonia Emission[C]//NIELSEN V C,VOORBURG J H,HERMITEP L.Odour and Ammonia Emissions From Livestock Farming.London:Elseviers Applied Science,1990:42-49.
[46] WEBB J,MENZI H,PAIN B F,et al.Managing Ammonia Emissions From Livestock Production in Europe[J].Environmental Pollution,2005,135(3):399-406.
[47] SARAZ J A O,TINôCO I F F T,GATES T R,et al.Evaluation of Different Methods for Determining Ammonia Emissions in Poultry Buildings and Their Applicability to Open Facilities[J].Dyna,2013,80(178):51-60.
[48] AROGO J,WESTERMAN P W.Proposed Method for Determining Ammonia Emission Factors From Confined Swine Feeding Operations[C].Chicago,USA:ASAE Annual Meeting,2002.
[49] 朱志平,董红敏,尚斌,等.育肥猪舍氨气浓度测定与排放通量的估算[J].农业环境科学学报,2006,25(4):1076-1080.[ZHU Zhi-ping,DONG Hong-min,SHANG Bin,et al.Measurement of Ammonia Concentration and Estimation on Emission Flux of Finishing Pig in Pig House[J].Journal of Agro-Environment Science,2006,25(4):1076-1080.]