矿物对轻度重金属污染水稻田土壤镉的钝化效果

doi:10.19741/j.issn.1673-4831.2021.0148

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 针对日益严重的土壤镉（Cd）污染情况，综合国内外重金属污染土壤修复方法，改良剂原位修复技术是运用最为广泛的方法之一。分别以海泡石（BM2）、蒙脱石（BM3）、凹凸棒石（BM4）、沸石（BM5）、羟基磷灰石（BM6）和生石灰（BM7）不同种类矿物作为修复材料，并将其与生物炭（BM1）和对照（BM0）进行对比，在浙江省某一轻度Cd污染地区的农田土壤中进行2年4季的田间钝化修复试验。结果表明，生物炭、海泡石、凹凸棒石、羟基磷灰石和生石灰都能略微增加水稻产量，但统计上并没有显著性差异。所有钝化处理都能降低土壤有效Cd含量和水稻籽粒Cd含量。各处理降低籽粒Cd含量的效果由大到小依次为生物炭、生石灰、沸石、蒙脱石、羟基磷灰石、凹凸棒石、海泡石和对照。其中，经生石灰处理后土壤有效Cd含量和水稻籽粒Cd含量分别为0.214和0.169 mg·kg^-1，与BM0相比分别降低25.17%和41.26%。此外，与对照相比，生石灰处理可交换态Cd在全Cd中的质量占比降低10个百分点，但铁锰氧化物结合态和有机态Cd含量增加，其他矿物处理Cd形态变化趋势相同，说明矿物修复Cd污染土壤主要通过将可交换态Cd转化为铁锰氧化物结合态Cd和有机态Cd，而碳酸盐结合态Cd和残渣态Cd几乎不参与该过程的转化。

关键词: Cd, 矿物修复, 水稻土, Tessier连续提取法

Abstract: In view of the increasingly serious soil cadmium (Cd) pollution, the improper in-situ remediation technology is one of the most widely used methods based on the domestic and foreign heavy metal remediation methods. In this study, different minerals, i. e., sepiolite (BM2), montmorillonite (BM3), attapulgite (BM4), zeolite (BM5), hydroxyapatite (BM6) and quicklime (BM7), and biochar (BM1) were used as restoration materials compared with control (BM0). A two-year remediation experiment was carried out on low Cd contaminated farmland soil in Zhejiang Province. The results show that biochar, sepiolite, attapulgite, hydroxyapatite, and quicklime slightly enhanced rice yield but with no statistically significant difference. All the passivation treatments reduced soil available Cd and rice grain Cd contents. The reduction of grain Cd contents was in an order of biochar > quicklime > zeolite > montmorillonite > hydroxyapatite > attapulgite > sepiolite > control. Besides, the soil available Cd and grain Cd after quicklime addition were 0.214 and 0.169 mg·kg^-1, respectively, which were decreased by 25.17% and 41.26%, respectively compared with BM0. In addition, the proportion of exchangeable Cd to the total Cd reduced by 10 percentage point after quicklime treatment addition, but the contents of Fe-Mn oxide binding and organic Cd increased. The trends of changes of Cd forms in the other mineral treatments were the same, indicating that the minerals remediate Cd-contaminated soil mainly by the conversion of exchangeable Cd into Fe-Mn oxide binding and organic Cd. Carbonate binding and residue Cd almost did not participate in the process of transformation.

Key words: Cd, mineral remediation, paddy soil, Tessier sequential extraction

中图分类号:

吕俊飞, 巩龙达, 蔡梅, 张耿苗, 张奇春. 矿物对轻度重金属污染水稻田土壤镉的钝化效果[J]. 生态与农村环境学报, 2022, 38(3): 391-398.

Lü Jun-fei, GONG Long-da, CAI Mei, ZHANG Geng-miao, ZHANG Qi-chun. Study on the Passivation Effect of Minerals on Cd in Farmland Soil with Light Heavy Metal Pollution[J]. Journal of Ecology and Rural Environment, 2022, 38(3): 391-398.

参考文献

[1] 魏树和,周启星.重金属污染土壤植物修复基本原理及强化措施探讨[J].生态学杂志,2004,23(1):65-72.[WEI Shu-he,ZHOU Qi-xing.Discussion on Basic Principles and Strengthening Measures for Phytoremediation of Soils Contaminated by Heavy Metals[J].Chinese Journal of Ecology,2004,23(1):65-72.]
[2] 邵孝侯,邢光熹,侯文华.连续提取法区分土壤重金属元素形态的研究及其应用[J].土壤学进展,1994,22(3):40-46.
[3] 张宝强.矿物材料修复重金属污染的研究进展[J].中国资源综合利用,2019,37(7):100-102.[ZHANG Bao-qiang.Research Progress on the Remediation of Heavy Metal Pollution by Mineral Materials[J].China Resources Comprehensive Utilization,2019,37(7):100-102.]
[4] 张亚男.石灰类钝化剂对土壤镉修复机理及油麦菜吸收镉的影响[D].沈阳:沈阳农业大学,2017:12-13.[ZHANG Ya-nan.Effect of Remediation Mechanism of Lime-type Passivator on Soil Cadmium and Cadmium Uptake by Leccuces[D].Shenyang:Shenyang Agricultural University,2017:12-13.]
[5] 王浣荷.轻中度镉污染农田土壤的修复及利用研究[D].杭州:浙江大学,2020:38-55.[WANG Huan-he.Remediation and Utilization of Slightly-moderately Cadmium Contaminated Farmland Soil[D].Hangzhou:Zhejiang University,2020:38-55.]
[6] LUO N L,WEN J J,LI Z W,et al.Passivating Effect of Dewatered Sludge and Biochar on As-contaminated Soil[J].Water,Air,& Soil Pollution,2019,231(1):1-10.
[7] 鲍士旦,江荣风,杨超光,等.土壤农化分析[M].北京:中国农业出版社,2000:30-57,375.[BAO Shi-dan,JIANG Rong-feng,YANG Chao-guang,et al.Soil Agrochemical Analysis[M].Beijing:China Agricultural Press,2000:30-57,375.]
[8] 蔡梅.混合改良剂对土壤Cd污染的钝化修复研究[D].杭州:浙江大学,2019:10-11.[CAI Mei.Study on Remediation of Cd Contaminated Soils by Mixed Amendments[D].Hangzhou:Zhejiang University,2019:10-11.]
[9] 王国庆,邓绍坡,冯艳红,等.国内外重金属土壤环境标准值比较:镉[J].生态与农村环境学报,2015,31(6):808-821.[WANG Guo-qing,DENG Shao-po,FENG Yan-hong,et al.Comparative Study on Soil Environmental Standards for Heavy Metals in China and Other Countries:Cadmium[J].Journal of Ecology and Rural Environment,2015,31(6):808-821.]
[10] REN X W,TANG J C,LIU X M,et al.Effects of Microplastics on Greenhouse Gas Emissions and the Microbial Community in Fertilized Soil[J].Environmental Pollution,2020,256:113347.1-113347.11.
[11] DELPIANO C A,PRIETO I,LOAYZA A P,et al.Different Responses of Leaf and Root Traits to Changes in Soil Nutrient Availability Do Not Converge into a Community-level Plant Economics Spectrum[J].Plant and Soil,2020,450(1/2):463-478.
[12] KEKULANDARA D S,SIRISENA D N,BANDARANAYAKE P C G,et al.Variation in Grain Yield,and Nitrogen,Phosphorus and Potassium Nutrition of Irrigated Rice Cultivars Grown at Fertile and Low-fertile Soils[J].Plant and Soil,2019,434(1/2):107-123.
[13] LAGRIFFOUL A,MOCQUOT B,MENCH M,et al.Cadmium Toxicity Effects on Growth,Mineral and Chlorophyll Contents,and Activities of Stress Related Enzymes in Young Maize Plants (Zea mays L.)[J].Plant and Soil,1998,200(2):241-250.
[14] ZENG F R,ALI S,ZHANG H T,et al.The Influence of pH and Organic Matter Content in Paddy Soil on Heavy Metal Availability and Their Uptake by Rice Plants[J].Environmental Pollution,2011,159(1):84-91.
[15] VAN ZWIETEN L,KIMBER S,MORRIS S,et al.Effects of Biochar from Slow Pyrolysis of Papermill Waste on Agronomic Performance and Soil Fertility[J].Plant and Soil,2010,327(1/2):235-246.
[16] 张磊,宋凤斌.土壤吸附重金属的影响因素研究现状及展望[J].土壤通报,2005,36(4):628-631.[ZHANG Lei,SONG Feng-bin.Adsorption of Heavy Metals by Soils and Its Affecting Factors[J].Chinese Journal of Soil Science,2005,36(4):628-631.]
[17] ALAM M S,GORMAN-LEWIS D,CHEN N,et al.Thermodynamic Analysis of Nickel(Ⅱ) and Zinc(Ⅱ) Adsorption to Biochar[J].Environmental Science & Technology,2018,52(11):6246-6255.
[18] ZHANG K,MAO J F,CHEN B L.Reconsideration of Heterostructures of Biochars:Morphology,Particle Size,Elemental Composition,Reactivity and Toxicity[J].Environmental Pollution,2019,254:113017.
[19] 刘艺芸.水肥耦合对海泡石钝化修复镉污染土壤的影响行为与机制[D].北京:中国农业科学院,2019:3-7.[LIU Yi-yun.Effects and Mechanism of Water Management and Organic Manure Coupling on Remediation of Cadmium Contaminated Soil by Sepiolite[D].Beijing:Chinese Academy of Agricultural Sciences,2019:3-7.]
[20] HUANG S W,CHIANG P N,LIU J C,et al.Chromate Reduction on Humic Acid Derived from a Peat Soil-exploration of the Activated Sites on HAs for Chromate Removal[J].Chemosphere,2012,87(6):587-594.
[21] 刘牛.蒙脱石的有机修饰及其对四环素的吸附[D].武汉:华中农业大学,2012:6-16.[LIU Niu.The Adsorption of Tetracycline Interactions with Organic Modified Montmorillonites[D].Wuhan:Huazhong Agricultural University,2012:6-16.]
[22] 敖翔,刘红,汪茜,等.4A分子筛-凹凸棒土颗粒对水中Cd(Ⅱ)的吸附[J].水处理技术,2017,43(9):62-66.[AO Xiang,LIU Hong,WANG Qian,et al.Adsorption of Cd(Ⅱ) in Aqueous Solution by Granular 4A Molecular Sieve/Attapulgite[J].Technology of Water Treatment,2017,43(9):62-66.]
[23] SHI W Y,SHAO H B,LI H,et al.Progress in the Remediation of Hazardous Heavy Metal-polluted Soils by Natural Zeolite[J].Journal of Hazardous Materials,2009,170(1):1-6.
[24] 王立群,罗磊,马义兵,等.不同钝化剂和培养时间对Cd污染土壤中可交换态Cd的影响[J].农业环境科学学报,2009,28(6):1098-1105.[WANG Li-qun,LUO Lei,MA Yi-bing,et al.Effects of Different Amendments and Incubation Times on Exchangeable Cadmium in Contaminated Soils[J].Journal of Agro-environment Science,2009,28(6):1098-1105.]
[25] GRAY C W,DUNHAM S J,DENNIS P G,et al.Field Evaluation of in Situ Remediation of a Heavy Metal Contaminated Soil Using Lime and Red-mud[J].Environmental Pollution,2006,142(3):530-539.
[26] 崔晓玉,陈雄鹰,徐伟,等.不同生石灰施用量对酸性土壤与稻米镉含量的影响[J].现代农业科技,2018(6):19-20.[CUI Xiao-yu,CHEN Xiong-ying,XU Wei,et al.Effect of Quick Lime on Acid Soil and Cadmium Content of Rice[J].Modern Agricultural Science and Technology,2018(6):19-20.]
[27] 刘大锷,郭明选,高汉清,等.施用生石灰对镉污染酸性土壤中水稻镉积累的影响[J].湖南农业科学,2016(12):24-26.[LIU Da-e,GUO Ming-xuan,GAO Han-qing,et al.Effects of Lime Application on Cadmium Accumulation of Rice in Acidic Cd-contaminated Paddy Soils[J].Hunan Agricultural Sciences,2016(12):24-26.]
[28] XIAN X.Effect of Chemical Forms of Cadmium,Zinc,and Lead in Polluted Soils on Their Uptake by Cabbage Plants[J].Plant and Soil,1989,113(2):257-264.
[29] 廖敏,黄昌勇,谢正苗.pH对镉在土水系统中的迁移和形态的影响[J].环境科学学报,1999,19(1):81-86.[LIAO Min,HUANG Chang-yong,XIE Zheng-miao.Effect of pH on Transport and Transformation of Cadmium in Soil-water System[J].Acta Scientiae Circumstantiae,1999,19(1):81-86.]