3种水分管理条件下施用木炭和磷酸二铵对水稻Cd、As累积的影响

doi:10.19741/j.issn.1673-4831.2019.0960

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 通过测定土壤和水稻体内Cd、As含量及水稻产量，探究常规灌溉（W1）、全生育期淹水（W2）和湿润灌溉（W3）耕作条件下，施用木炭和磷酸二铵对水稻Cd、As累积的影响。结果表明，3种水分管理条件下施用木炭和磷酸二铵均显著提高土壤pH值，pH值随水稻生长呈先增加后下降趋势，最后趋于中性；土壤氧化还原电位随水分增加呈下降趋势，其值由高到低依次为W1 > W3 > W2水分管理条件，W2水分管理条件始终处于弱还原状态。同一水分管理条件下施用木炭和磷酸二铵，土壤有效态Cd以及水稻根、茎叶和籽粒Cd含量均随施用量的增加而减少。W1、W2和W3水分管理条件下，对照组水稻籽粒Cd含量分别为（0.23±0.02）、（0.19±0.03）和（0.22±0.04） mg·kg^-1，施用木炭和磷酸二铵后水稻籽粒Cd含量均小于0.2 mg·kg^-1；其中，W2水分管理条件下配施0.44 kg·m^-2木炭或15.00 g·m^-2磷酸二铵的降低效果较好。3种水分管理条件下施用木炭和磷酸二铵均使土壤有效态As含量增加；相比较而言，W2水分管理条件下各处理土壤有效态As含量最少，介于0.88~1.22 mg·kg^-1之间。W2水分管理条件下各处理水稻根、茎叶和籽粒As含量较低，且籽粒无机As含量均小于0.2 mg·kg^-1。3种水分管理条件下施用木炭和磷酸二铵均能促进水稻生长，提高水稻产量。水稻产量与土壤有效态Cd含量呈极显著负相关，与土壤有效态As含量无显著相关性。因此，在确保水稻籽粒无机As含量不超过0.2 mg·kg^-1条件下，实际生产中可采用W2水分管理配施0.44 kg·m^-2木炭或15.00 g·m^-2磷酸二铵的方法促进水稻增产，并有效降低水稻籽粒Cd累积。

关键词: 水稻, Cd, As, 水分管理, 木炭, 磷酸二铵

Abstract: According to the field experiment next to a lead-zinc mining area in Anhui Province, the available cadmium (Cd) and arsenic (As) in farmland as well as rice yields were evaluated as affected by charcoal and diammonium phosphate (DAP) treatments under conventional irrigation (W1), whole growth period flooding (W2), and wet irrigation (W3). Moreover, the pH values, oxidation-reduction potential (Eh), and Cd and As accumulation in rice tissues were also investigated in this study. The results demonstrate that the application of charcoal and DAP enhanced the pH values in soils under all the three conditions of water management. With the rice growth, the pH value in farmland increased firstly and then decreased to neutral. The Eh values of soils showed a declining tendency with the increase of moisture. The Eh values under the different water management conditions followed the sequence of W1 > W3 > W2. Furthermore, the Eh values at W2 condition showed a weak reductive state. At the same water management condition, the available Cd content in soil and Cd content in root, stem leaves and grains decreased as the application amount of charcoal and DAP increased, respectively. In control group, the Cd contents in rice grains under W1, W2, and W3 treatments were (0.23±0.02), (0.19±0.03), and (0.22±0.04) mg·kg^-1, respectively. After the charcoal and DAP application, Cd accumulation in rice grains was lower than 0.2 mg·kg^-1 for all treatments. It was found that the reduction in Cd accumulation had an optimum efficiency in application of 0.44 kg·m^-2 charcoal or 15.00 g·m^-2 DAP under W2 treatment. On the other hand, the available As content increased after the charcoal and DAP application. The available As content in soil showed the lowest concentration range (0.88-1.22 mg·kg^-1) in W2 treatments. In the W2 treatment group, it was observed that the available As content in soil and As accumulation were lower in rice roots, stem leaves and grains. Meanwhile, the inorganic As contents in rice grains were lower than 0.2 mg·kg^-1. Overall, application of charcoal and DAP improved rice growth and increased rice yield. The rice yields were negatively correlated with the available Cd content in soil, but no significant correlation with the available As content was observed. Therefore, the application of 0.44 kg·m^-2 charcoal or 15.00 g·m^-2 DAP coupled with W2 water treatment could be adopted to promote rice yields in the condition of ensuring that As content in rice grains below 0.2 mg·kg^-1, which simultaneously decreased the accumulation of Cd in rice grains.

Key words: rice, Cd, As, water management, charcoal, diammonium phosphate

中图分类号:

米雅竹, 朱广森, 张旭, 刘小红, 司友斌. 3种水分管理条件下施用木炭和磷酸二铵对水稻Cd、As累积的影响[J]. 生态与农村环境学报, 2020, 36(9): 1200-1209.

MI Ya-zhu, ZHU Guang-sen, ZHANG Xu, LIU Xiao-hong, SI You-bin. Accumulation of Cd and As in Rice (Oryza sativa) Under Different Water Management Coupled With Charcoal and Diammonium Phosphate Amendment[J]. Journal of Ecology and Rural Environment, 2020, 36(9): 1200-1209.

参考文献

[1] HUANG B,GUO Z H,TU W J,et al.Geochemistry and Ecological Risk of Metal(Loid)s in Overbank Sediments Near an Abandoned Lead/Zinc Mine in Central South China[J].Environmental Earth Sciences,2018,77(3):1-13.
[2] MI Y Z,ZHAN F D,LI B,et al.Distribution Characteristics of Cadmium and Lead in Particle Size Fractions of Farmland Soils in a Lead-zinc Mine Area in Southwest China[J].Environmental Systems Research,2018,7(1):1-10.
[3] 于焕云,崔江虎,乔江涛,等.稻田镉砷污染阻控原理与技术应用[J].农业环境科学学报,2018,37(7):1418-1426.[YU Huan-yun,CUI Jiang-hu,QIAO Jiang-tao,et al.Principle and Technique of Arsenic and Cadmium Pollution Control in Paddy Field[J].Journal of Agro-Environment Science,2018,37(7):1418-1426.]
[4] QIAO J T,LIU T X,WANG X Q,et al.Simultaneous Alleviation of Cadmium and Arsenic Accumulation in Rice by Applying Zero-valent Iron and Biochar to Contaminated Paddy Soils[J].Chemosphere,2018,195:260-271.
[5] WANG R Z,WEI S,JIA P H,et al.Biochar Significantly Alters Rhizobacterial Communities and Reduces Cd Concentration in Rice Grains Grown on Cd-contaminated Soils[J].Science of the Total Environment,2019,676:627-638.
[6] 崔红标,范玉超,周静,等.改良剂对土壤铜镉有效性和微生物群落结构的影响[J].中国环境科学,2016,36(1):197-205.[CUI Hong-biao,FAN Yu-chao,ZHOU Jing,et al.Availability of Soil Cu and Cd and Microbial Community Structure as Affected by Applications of Amendments[J].China Environmental Science,2016,36(1):197-205.]
[7] 陈芳,张康康,谷思诚,等.不同种类生物质炭及施用量对水稻生长及土壤养分的影响[J].华中农业大学学报,2019,38(5):57-63.[CHEN Fang,ZHANG Kang-kang,GU Si-cheng,et al.Effects of Kinds and Application Rates of Biochar on Rice Growth and Soil Nutrients[J].Journal of Huazhong Agricultural University,2019,38(5):57-63.]
[8] SIEBERS N,SIANGLIW M,TONGCUMPOU C.Cadmium Uptake and Subcellular Distribution in Rice Plants as Affected by Phosphorus:Soil and Hydroponic Experiments[J].Journal of Soil Science and Plant Nutrition,2013,13(4):833-844.
[9] 李桃,李军,韩颖,等.磷对水稻镉的亚细胞分布及化学形态的影响[J].农业环境科学学报,2017,36(9):1712-1718.[LI Tao,LI Jun,HAN Ying,et al.Effects of Phosphorus on Subcellular Distribution and Chemical Speciation of Cadmium in Rice[J].Journal of Agro-Environment Science,2017,36(9):1712-1718.]
[10] 吴迪,魏小娜,彭湃,等.钝化剂对酸性高镉土壤钝化效果及水稻镉吸收的影响[J].土壤通报,2019,50(2):482-488.[WU Di,WEI Xiao-na,PENG Pai,et al.Effects of Passivators on Acid and Cadmium Farmland Soils and Cadmium Absorption by Rice[J].Chinese Journal of Soil Science,2019,50(2):482-488.]
[11] 薛培英,刘文菊,段桂兰,等.外源磷对苗期小麦和水稻根际砷形态及其生物有效性的影响[J].生态学报,2009,29(4):2027-2034.[XUE Pei-ying,LIU Wen-ju,DUAN Gui-lan,et al.Effects of Exogenous Phosphorus on Arsenic Fractions in the Rhizosphere and Their Bioavailability to Rice and Wheat Seedlings[J].Acta Ecologica Sinica,2009,29(4):2027-2034.]
[12] HOSSAIN M B,JAHIRUDDIN M,LOEPPERT R H,et al.The Effects of Iron Plaque and Phosphorus on Yield and Arsenic Accumulation in Rice[J].Plant and Soil,2009,317(1/2):167-176.
[13] 刘昭兵,纪雄辉,彭华,等.水分管理模式对水稻吸收累积镉的影响及其作用机理[J].应用生态学报,2010,21(4):908-914.[LIU Zhao-bing,JI Xiong-hui,PENG Hua,et al.Effects and Action Mechanisms of Different Water Management Modes on Rice Cd Absorption and Accumulation[J].Chinese Journal of Applied Ecology,2010,21(4):908-914.]
[14] 李海龙,李香真,聂三安,等.水分管理对Cd-Pb-Zn污染土壤有效态及水稻根际细菌群落的影响[J].农业环境科学学报,2018,37(7):1456-1467.[LI Hai-long,LI Xiang-zhen,NIE San-an,et al.Effects of Two Flooding Methods on Bio-available Cd-Pb-Zn Contents of Contaminated Paddy Soil and Bacteria Community in Rice Rhizosphere[J].Journal of Agro-Environment Science,2018,37(7):1456-1467.]
[15] 刘昭兵,纪雄辉,官迪,等.镉胁迫条件下淹水时间对水稻吸收累积镉的影响[J].生态与农村环境学报,2017,33(12):1125-1131.[LIU Zhao-bing,JI Xiong-hui,GUAN Di,et al.Effects of Timing and Duration of Waterlogging on Cd Absorption and Accumulation by Rice Under Cadmium Stress[J].Journal of Ecology and Rural Environment,2017,33(12):1125-1131.]
[16] HU P J,HUANG J X,OUYANG Y,et al.Water Management Affects Arsenic and Cadmium Accumulation in Different Rice Cultivars[J].Environmental Geochemistry and Health,2013,35(6):767-778.
[17] 李园星露,叶长城,刘玉玲,等.生物炭耦合水分管理对稻田土壤As-Cd生物有效性及稻米累积的影响[J].农业环境科学学报,2018,37(4):696-704.[LI Yuanxinglu,YE Chang-cheng,LIU Yu-ling,et al.Bioavailability of Arsenic and Cadmium,and Their Cumulative Control in Rice Grown on Arsenic-cadmium-contaminated Paddy Soils[J].Journal of Agro-Environment Science,2018,37(4):696-704.]
[18] 田桃,曾敏,周航,等.水分管理模式与土壤Eh值对水稻Cd迁移与累积的影响[J].环境科学,2017,38(1):343-351.[TIAN Tao,ZENG Min,ZHOU Hang,et al.Effects of Different Water Managements and Soil Eh on Migration and Accumulation of Cd in Rice[J].Environmental Science,2017,38(1):343-351.]
[19] 吴愉萍,王明湖,席杰君,等.不同农业废弃物生物炭及施用量对土壤pH值和保水保氮能力的影响[J].中国土壤与肥料,2019(1):87-92.[WU Yu-ping,WANG Ming-hu,XI Jie-jun,et al.The Effects of Different Agricultural Waste Biochars and Application Rates on Soil pH,Water Holding Capacity and N Adsorption[J].Soil and Fertilizer Sciences in China,2019(1):87-92.]
[20] 赵钰,董黎明,张艳萍,等.北京道路尘土与土壤植物中重金属形态分析与评价[J].环境科学与技术,2013,36(9):169-174.[ZHAO Yu,DONG Li-ming,ZHANG Yan-ping,et al.Speciation Analysis and Pollution Assessment of Heavy Metals in Road Dust,Soils and Plants in Beijing[J].Environmental Science & Technology,2013,36(9):169-174.]
[21] 冉洪珍,郭朝晖,肖细元,等.改良剂连续施用对农田水稻Cd吸收的影响[J].中国环境科学,2019,39(3):1117-1123.[RAN Hong-zhen,GUO Zhao-hui,XIAO Xi-yuan,et al.Effects of Continuous Application of Soil Amendments on Cadmium Availability in Paddy Soil and Uptake by Rice[J].China Environmental Science,2019,39(3):1117-1123.]
[22] 唐爱玲.土壤中有效态砷钒铬的两种提取方法比较[J].环境监控与预警,2019,11(1):21-25,31.[TANG Ai-ling.Comparative Study of Two Methods on Extraction of As,V and Cr in Soil[J].Environmental Monitoring and Forewarning,2019,11(1):21-25,31.]
[23] 马金晶,罗雯,张龙旺,等.微波消解-电感耦合等离子体质谱法测定人面果树中的重金属元素[J].分析试验室,2012,31(7):32-35.[MA Jin-jing,LUO Wen,ZHANG Long-wang,et al.Determination of Heavy Metal Elements in Garcinia Xanthochymus by ICP-MS Using Microwave Digestion for Sample Preparation[J].Chinese Journal of Analysis Laboratory,2012,31(7):32-35.]
[24] WANG Y,LIU X H,SI Y B,et al.Release and Transformation of Arsenic From As-bearing Iron Minerals by Fe-reducing Bacteria[J].Chemical Engineering Journal,2016,295:29-38.
[25] 钟松雄,尹光彩,陈志良,等.Eh、pH和铁对水稻土砷释放的影响机制[J].环境科学,2017,38(6):2530-2537.[ZHONG Song-xiong,YIN Guang-cai,CHEN Zhi-liang,et al.Influencing Mechanism of Eh,pH and Iron on the Release of Arsenic in Paddy Soil[J].Environmental Science,2017,38(6):2530-2537.]
[26] RAMZANI P M A,KHALID M,ANJUM S,et al.Cost-effective Enhanced Iron Bioavailability in Rice Grain Grown on Calcareous Soil by Sulfur Mediation and Its Effect on Heavy Metals Mineralization[J].Environmental Science and Pollution Research,2017,24(2):1219-1228.
[27] SHAH A L,NAHER U A,HASAN Z,et al.Arsenic Management in Contaminated Irrigation Water for Rice Cultivation[J].Pertanika Journal of Tropical Agricultural Science,2016,39(2):155-166.
[28] PARSONS C T,COUTURE R M,OMOREGIE E O,et al.The Impact of Oscillating Redox Conditions:Arsenic Immobilisation in Contaminated Calcareous Floodplain Soils[J].Environmental Pollution,2013,178:254-263.
[29] KOLB S E,FERMANICH K J,DORNBUSH M E.Effect of Charcoal Quantity on Microbial Biomass and Activity in Temperate Soils[J].Soil Science Society of America Journal,2009,73(4):1173-1181.
[30] CAO X D,WAHBI A,MA L,et al.Immobilization of Zn,Cu,and Pb in Contaminated Soils Using Phosphate Rock and Phosphoric Acid[J].Journal of Hazardous Materials,2009,164(2/3):555-564.
[31] BEESLEY L,MARMIROLI M,PAGANO L,et al.Biochar Addition to an Arsenic Contaminated Soil Increases Arsenic Concentrations in the Pore Water but Reduces Uptake to Tomato Plants (Solanum lycopersicum L.)[J].Science of the Total Environment,2013,454/455:598-603.
[32] 辜娇峰,周航,吴玉俊,等.复合改良剂对稻田Cd、As活性与累积的协同调控[J].中国环境科学,2016,36(1):206-214.[GU Jiao-feng,ZHOU Hang,WU Yu-jun,et al.Synergistic Control of Combined Amendment on Bioavailability and Accumulation of Cd and as in Rice Paddy Soil[J].China Environmental Science,2016,36(1):206-214.]
[33] 张秀芝,李强,彭畅,等.不同添加量重金属对水稻产量及籽粒重金属富集的影响[J].吉林农业科学,2015,40(4):13-16.[ZHANG Xiu-zhi,LI Qiang,PENG Chang,et al.Effect of Heavy Metals With Different Additional Amount on Rice Yield and Heavy Metal Concentration in Grain[J].Journal of Jilin Agricultural Sciences,2015,40(4):13-16.]
[34] 胡雪芳,田志清,梁亮,等.不同改良剂对铅镉污染农田水稻重金属积累和产量影响的比较分析[J].环境科学,2018,39(7):3409-3417.[HU Xue-fang,TIAN Zhi-qing,LIANG Liang,et al.Comparative Analysis of Different Soil Amendment Treatments on Rice Heavy Metal Accumulation and Yield Effect in Pb and Cd Contaminated Farmland[J].Environmental Science,2018,39(7):3409-3417.]
[35] CHAUHAN R,AWASTHI S,TRIPATHI P,et al.Selenite Modulates the Level of Phenolics and Nutrient Element to Alleviate the Toxicity of Arsenite in Rice (Oryza sativa L.)[J].Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety,2017,138:47-55.