湿地生态补偿研究进展

doi:10.19741/j.issn.1673-4831.2019.0377

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 湿地被誉为"地球之肾"，是人类最重要生存环境之一。在梳理湿地生态补偿概念的基础上，系统整理了国内外湿地生态补偿政策与实践，针对补偿载体、方式、融资、标准、模式和绩效评估等进行总结分析，提出当前湿地生态补偿存在的主要问题包括理论研究滞后于实践，系统制度设计存在欠缺，补偿资金渠道相对单一，补偿标准差异大以及严重缺乏相应监管、成效评估机制等。最后展望了湿地生态补偿的优先研究方向:（1）加强湿地生态补偿理论研究；（2）加快湿地生态补偿制度研究；（3）扩大湿地保护试点实践研究；（4）增强湿地生态补偿监管及补偿成效评估研究。同时吸收总结国内外科学有效的补偿模式，助推现阶段我国市场化、多元化生态保护补偿机制建设，为湿地生态补偿和修复提供科学依据与决策参考。

关键词: 湿地银行, 生态补偿, 生态系统服务

Abstract: Known as the "kidney of the earth", wetland is one of the most important living environments for human beings. On the basis of analyzing the concept of wetland ecological compensation, the policies and practices of wetland ecological compensation at domestic and abroad have been systematically sorted out, and the compensation carriers, methods, financing, standards, models and performance evaluation have been summarized. Moreover, the following main existing problems of wetland ecological compensation are proposed: theoretical research lags behind practice, system design is lacking, channels of compensation funds are relatively simple, compensation standards in different areas are significantly different, and the corresponding supervision and effectiveness evaluation mechanisms are seriously lacking. The priority research directions of wetland ecological compensation are prospected: (1) strengthening the theoretical research on wetland ecological compensation; (2) accelerating the study of wetland ecological compensation system; (3) expanding the pilot practice study on wetland protection; (4) strengthening the assessment of wetland ecological compensation supervision and compensation effectiveness. At the same time absorb and summarize the scientific and effective compensation models at domestic and abroad to promote the construction of market-oriented and diversified ecological protection compensation mechanisms in China at this stage. This study can provide scientific basis and decision-making reference for wetland ecological compensation and restoration.

Key words: wetland bank, ecological compensation, ecosystem service

中图分类号:

严有龙, 王军, 王金满, 荆肇睿. 湿地生态补偿研究进展[J]. 生态与农村环境学报, 2020, 36(5): 618-625.

YAN You-long, WANG Jun, WANG Jin-man, JING Zhao-rui. Study of Wetland Ecological Compensation: A Review[J]. Journal of Ecology and Rural Environment, 2020, 36(5): 618-625.

参考文献 52

[1]	刘继伟,赖旭.GIS在湿地生态系统设计和管理中的应用研究[J].安徽农业科学,2012,40(23):11746-11748,11845.[LIU Ji-wei,LAI Xu.Research on GIS Application in Design and Management of Wetland Ecosystem[J].Journal of Anhui Agricultural Sciences,2012,40(23):11746-11748,11845.]
[2]	胡曾曾,赵志龙,张贵祥,等.国家公园湿地生态补偿研究进展[J].湿地科学,2018,16(2):259-265.[HU Zeng-zeng,ZHAO Zhi-long,ZHANG Gui-xiang,et al.Review of Researches on Eco-compensation for Wetlands in National Parks[J].Wetland Science,2018,16(2):259-265.]
[3]	JUNK W J,AN S Q,FINLAYSON C M,et al.Current State of Knowledge Regarding the World's Wetlands and Their Future Under Global Climate Change:A Synthesis[J].Aquatic Sciences,2013,75(1):151-167.
[4]	但新球,廖宝文,吴照柏,等.中国红树林湿地资源、保护现状和主要威胁[J].生态环境学报,2016,25(7):1237-1243.[DAN Xin-qiu,LIAO Bao-wen,WU Zhao-bai,et al.Resources,Conservation Status and Main Threats of Mangrove Wetlands in China[J].Ecology and Environmental Sciences,2016,25(7):1237-1243.]
[5]	段艺璇,林田苗,赵晓迪,等.湿地生态补偿标准与模式研究进展[J].林业经济,2018,40(7):76-81.[DUAN Yi-xuan,LIN Tian-miao,ZHAO Xiao-di,et al.Research Progress on Standards and Models of Wetland Ecological Compensation[J].Forestry Economics,2018,40(7):76-81.]
[6]	靳乐山.中国生态保护补偿机制政策框架的新扩展:《建立市场化、多元化生态保护补偿机制行动计划》的解读[J].环境保护,2019,47(2):28-30.[JIN Le-shan.Emerging Policy Framework on China's Market-based and Diverse Ecological Compensation Mechanism[J].Environmental Protection,2019,47(2):28-30.]
[7]	王亮,王云.湿地与城市湿地公园建设[J].科技创新导报,2012,9(17):43.
[8]	姜宏瑶.中国湿地生态补偿机制研究[D].北京:北京林业大学,2011.[JIANG Hong-yao.Study on Wetland Ecological Compensation Mechanism of China[D].Beijing:Beijing Forestry University,2011.]
[9]	ENGEL S,PAGIOLA S,WUNDER S.Designing Payments for Environmental Services in Theory and Practice:An Overview of the Issues[J].Ecological Economics,2008,65(4):663-674.
[10]	RIBAUDO M,GREENE C,HANSEN L,et al.Ecosystem Services From Agriculture:Steps for Expanding Markets[J].Ecological Economics,2010,69(11):2085-2092.
[11]	MURADIAN R,CORBERA E,PASCUAL U,et al.Reconciling Theory and Practice:An Alternative Conceptual Framework for Understanding Payments for Environmental Services[J].Ecological Economics,2010,69(6):1202-1208.
[12]	SCHOMERS S,MATZDORF B.Payments for Ecosystem Services:A Review and Comparison of Developing and Industrialized Countries[J].Ecosystem Services,2013,6:16-30.
[13]	TACCONI L.Redefining Payments for Environmental Services[J].Ecological Economics,2012,73:29-36.
[14]	袁伟彦,周小柯.生态补偿问题国外研究进展综述[J].中国人口·资源与环境,2014,24(11):76-82.[YUAN Wei-yan,ZHOU Xiao-ke.Review of Research Progress Abroad in Payments for Ecosystem Services[J].China Population,Resources and Environment,2014,24(11):76-82.]
[15]	吴乐,孔德帅,靳乐山.中国生态保护补偿机制研究进展[J].生态学报,2019,39(1):1-8.[WU Le,KONG De-shuai,JIN Le-shan.Research on the Progress of the Eco-compensation Mechanism in China[J].Acta Ecologica Sinica,2019,39(1):1-8.]
[16]	高正.我国湿地生态补偿制度研究[D].苏州:苏州大学,2012.[GAO Zheng.The Research on Chinese Wetland Ecological Compensation System[D].Suzhou:Soochow University,2012.]
[17]	万容.水资源生态补偿模式分析与机制构建[J].社会科学家,2010(2):83-86.
[18]	赵光洲,陈妍竹.我国流域生态补偿机制探讨[J].经济问题探索,2010(1):6-11.
[19]	刘子刚,刘喆,卫文斐.湿地生态补偿概念和基本理论问题探讨[J].生态经济,2016,32(2):186-189.[LIU Zi-gang,LIU Zhe,WEI Wen-fei.The Concept and Theoretical Problems of Wetland Ecological Compensation[J].Ecological Economy,2016,32(2):186-189.]
[20]	孙博,谢屹,温亚利.中国湿地生态补偿机制研究进展[J].湿地科学,2016,14(1):89-96.[SUN Bo,XIE Yi,WEN Ya-li.Advance in Ecological Compensation Mechanism for Wetlands in China[J].Wetland Science,2016,14(1):89-96.]
[21]	李斯佳,王金满,张兆彤.矿产资源开发生态补偿研究进展[J].生态学杂志,2019,38(5):1551-1559.[LI Si-jia,WANG Jin-man,ZHANG Zhao-tong.Ecological Compensation for Mineral Resources Exploitation:A Review[J].Chinese Journal of Ecology,2019,38(5):1551-1559.]
[22]	PAGIOLA S,PLATAIS G.Payments for Environmental Services:From Theory to Practice[R].Washington DC,USA:World Bank,2007.
[23]	陈克林,杨秀芝,陈晶.若尔盖高原湿地生态补偿政策研究[J].湿地科学,2014,12(4):419-423.[CHEN Ke-lin,YANG Xiu-zhi,CHEN Jing.Ecological Compensation Policy of Zoigê Plateau Wetlands[J].Wetland Science,2014,12(4):419-423.]
[24]	杨丽韫,甄霖,吴松涛.我国生态补偿主客体界定与标准核算方法分析[J].生态经济(学术版),2010(1):298-302.[YANG Li-yun,ZHEN Lin,WU Song-tao.An Analysis of Identification of Provider and Receiver for Eco-compensation and Methods of Compensation Standard Calculation in China[J].Ecological Economy,2010(1):298-302.]
[25]	陈兆开.我国湿地生态补偿问题研究[J].生态经济,2009,25(5):155-158.[CHEN Zhao-kai.The Study on Eco-compensation of the Wetlands[J].Ecological Economy,2009,25(5):155-158.]
[26]	刘慧杰.洞庭湖区湿地恢复生态补偿机制研究[D].长沙:湖南师范大学,2012.[LIU Hui-jie.Research on the Wetland Recovery Ecological Compensation Mechanism in the Dongting Lake Region[D].Changsha:Hunan Normal University,2012.]
[27]	CLEMENTS T,JOHN A,NIELSEN K,et al.Payments for Biodiversity Conservation in the Context of Weak Institutions:Comparison of Three Programs From Cambodia[J].Ecological Economics,2010,69(6):1283-1291.
[28]	CRANFORD M,MOURATO S.Community Conservation and a Two-stage Approach to Payments for Ecosystem Services[J].Ecological Economics,2011,71:89-98.
[29]	李连英,马智胜,朱青,等.我国矿产资源开发生态补偿机制的基本构建[J].中国水土保持,2009(6):55-57.
[30]	PETROLIA D R,MOORE R G,KIM T G.Preferences for Timing of Wetland Loss Prevention in Louisiana[J].Wetlands,2011,31(2):295-307.
[31]	毛显强,钟瑜,张胜.生态补偿的理论探讨[J].中国人口·资源与环境,2002,12(4):38-41.[MAO Xian-qiang,ZHONG Yu,ZHANG Sheng.Conception,Theory and Mechanism of Eco-compensation[J].China Population,Resources and Environment,2002,12(4):38-41.]
[32]	饶云聪.生态补偿应用研究:以海南省为例[D].重庆:重庆大学,2008.[RAO Yun-cong.Application Research on Ecological Compensation:a Case Study on Hainan Province[D].Chongqing:Chongqing University,2008.]
[33]	周莉,苏宁,温亚利.试论我国湿地生态效益补偿制度框架构建[J].林业经济,2008,30(6):53-57.[ZHOU Li,SU Ning,WEN Ya-li.Construction on the Framework of Wetland Ecological Benefit Compensation System in China[J].Forestry Economics,2008,30(6):53-57.]
[34]	吴成亮,武小萍,宋洋.我国湿地生态效益补偿融资渠道分析研究[J].林业经济,2013(7):88-92.[WU Cheng-liang,WU Xiao-ping,SONG Yang.Analysis on to Wetland Ecological Benefits Compensation Financing Channels in China[J].Forestry Economics,2013(7):88-92.]
[35]	李家才.水质交易与太湖流域水污染物排放交易[J].环境科学与管理,2010,35(12):4-9.[LI Jia-cai.Water Quality Trading and Effluent Trading in Taihu Lake Basin[J].Environmental Science and Management,2010,35(12):4-9.]
[36]	崔丽娟.鄱阳湖湿地生态系统服务功能价值评估研究[J].生态学杂志,2004,23(4):47-51.[CUI Li-juan.Evaluation on Functions of Poyang Lake Ecosystem[J].Chinese Journal of Ecology,2004,23(4):47-51.]
[37]	MERINO J,AUST C,CAFFEY R.Cost-Efficacy in Wetland Restoration Projects in Coastal Louisiana[J].Wetlands,2011,31(2):367-375.
[38]	徐大伟,刘春燕,常亮.流域生态补偿意愿的WTP与WTA差异性研究:基于辽河中游地区居民的CVM调查[J].自然资源学报,2013,28(3):402-409.[XU Da-wei,LIU Chun-yan,CHANG Liang.A Study on the Disparity of WTP and WTA of the Basin's Willingness to Compensate:Based on the Residents' CVM Investigation in the Middle Liaohe Drainage Basin[J].Journal of Natural Resources,2013,28(3):402-409.]
[39]	唐圣囡,李京梅.美国湿地补偿银行制度运转的关键点及对中国的启示[J].湿地科学,2018,16(6):764-770.[TANG Sheng-nan,LI Jing-mei.Key Points of the Operation of the US Wetland Mitigation Banking System and Its Inspiration to China[J].Wetland Science,2018,16(6):764-770.]
[40]	杨莉菲,郝春旭,温亚利,等.世界湿地生态效益补偿政策与模式[J].世界林业研究,2010,23(3):13-17.[YANG Li-fei,HAO Chun-xu,WEN Ya-li,et al.The Policy and Model of World Wetland Ecological Compensation[J].World Forestry Research,2010,23(3):13-17.]
[41]	王青瑶,马永双.湿地生态补偿方式探讨[J].林业资源管理,2014(3):27-32.[WANG Qing-yao,MA Yong-shuang.Discussion on Wetland Ecological Compensation Modes[J].Forest Resources Management,2014(3):27-32.]
[42]	柳荻,胡振通,靳乐山.生态保护补偿的分析框架研究综述[J].生态学报,2018,38(2):380-392.[LIU Di,HU Zhen-tong,JIN Le-shan.Review on Analytical Framework of Eco-compensation[J].Acta Ecologica Sinica,2018,38(2):380-392.]
[43]	郝海广,勾蒙蒙,张惠远,等.基于生态系统服务和农户福祉的生态补偿效果评估研究进展[J].生态学报,2018,38(19):6810-6817.[HAO Hai-guang,GOU Meng-meng,ZHANG Hui-yuan,et al.Assessing Ecological Compensation Policies Based on Ecosystem Services and Human Wellbeing:A Review of Recent Progress[J].Acta Ecologica Sinica,2018,38(19):6810-6817.]
[44]	孟兵站,董琳琳,彭刚.美国湿地缓释银行对我国的借鉴与启示[J].林业经济,2013,35(8):14-15,23.[MENG Bing-zhan,DONG Lin-lin,PENG Gang.American Wetland Mitigation Bank and Its Inspiration[J].Forestry Economics,2013,35(8):14-15,23.]
[45]	赵云峰,侯铁珊,徐大伟.生态补偿银行制度的分析:美国的经验及其对我国的启示[J].生态经济,2012,28(6):34-37,41.[ZHAO Yun-feng,HOU Tie-shan,XU Da-wei.Analysis on Banking System of Ecological Compensation:American Experience and Its Reference to China[J].Ecological Economy,2012,28(6):34-37,41.]
[46]	PORRAS I,BARTON D N,MIRANDA M,et al.Learning From 20 Years of Payments for Ecosystem Services in Costa Rica[R].London,England:International Institute for Environment and Development,2013.
[47]	朱文博,王阳,李双成.生态系统服务付费的诊断框架及案例剖析[J].生态学报,2014,34(10):2460-2469.[ZHU Wen-bo,WANG Yang,LI Shuang-cheng.A Diagnostic Framework of Payments for Ecosystem Services and Associated Case Studies[J].Acta Ecologica Sinica,2014,34(10):2460-2469.]
[48]	朱丹."整体性治理":国外生态补偿政策的执行经验与启示[J].生态经济,2016,32(11):175-178.[ZHU Dan.Overall Treatment:Experience and Enlightenment on Implement Policies for Eco-Compensation Abroad[J].Ecological Economy,2016,32(11):175-178.]
[49]	柳荻,胡振通,靳乐山.美国湿地缓解银行实践与中国启示:市场创建和市场运行[J].中国土地科学,2018,32(1):65-72.[LIU Di,HU Zhen-tong,JIN Le-shan.American Wetland Mitigation Bank Practice and Its Implications for China:Market Creation and Operation[J].China Land Science,2018,32(1):65-72.]
[50]	ROBERTSON M,HOUGH P.Wetlands Regulation:The Case of Mitigation Under Section 404 of the Clean Water Act[M]//LEPAGE B A.Wetlands.Dordrecht,Netherlands:Springer Netherlands,2011:171-187.DOI:10.1007/978-94-007-0551-7-10
[51]	鲁冰清,文海光.我国湿地保护立法现状与问题分析[J].中国市场,2013(20):64-65.
[52]	靳乐山,刘晋宏,孔德帅.将GEP纳入生态补偿绩效考核评估分析[J].生态学报,2019,39(1):24-36.[JIN Le-shan,LIU Jin-hong,KONG De-shuai.Evaluation of the Incorporation of Gross Ecosystem Product Into Performance Appraisals for Ecological Compensation[J].Acta Ecologica Sinica,2019,39(1):24-36.]