3种不同抗除草剂转基因大豆对田间节肢动物多样性的影响

doi:10.19741/j.issn.1673-4831.2022.0233

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 转基因大豆对田间节肢生物多样性的影响是转基因生物生态安全性评价的重要组成部分。采用直接观察法对3种转基因大豆及其非转基因受体的田间节肢动物进行调查,分析了大豆田节肢动物群落的功能群、丰富度指数、Shannon-Wiener多样性指数、Pielou均匀度指数、优势集中性指数随时间的变化规律,并比较了其差异。结果显示,种植在不同试验地点的不同品种转基因大豆的各类多样性指数变化趋势稍有不同,但不同转基因大豆与非转基因对照相比,主要功能团组成数量及其丰富度、多样性、均匀度、优势集中性指数间均无显著差异,各类指数随时间变化的动态趋于一致。综合分析表明,3种抗除草剂转基因大豆的种植对大豆田间节肢动物无显著影响,这为转基因大豆的生态安全性评价提供了数据支持。

关键词: 转基因大豆, 生物安全, 生物多样性, 节肢动物群落, 多样性指数

Abstract: The effect of transgenic soybean on arthropod biodiversity in the field is an important part of biosafety assessment. Arthropods in the fields of three transgenic soybean varieties and their non-GM counterparts were investigated with direct observation, and the functional groups in the arthropod communities, richness index, Shannon-Wiener diversity index, Pielou evenness index, and dominant concentration index were analyzed, and the differences were then compared. The results show that although the trends of those indexes of different transgenic varieties and their counterparts were slightly different, but there were no significant differences in the above indexes between transgenic soybean and the control. The dynamics of various indexes of arthropods in GM soybean fields and its non-GM control showed similar tendencies over time. It was suggested that GM soybean had no significant effects on arthropods in the fields, which provides data to support the biosafety assessment of transgenic soybeans.

Key words: transgenic soybean, biosafety, biodiversity, arthropod community, diversity index

中图分类号:

Q968

杨晓然, 刘靖, 姚淑军, 沈文静, 郭慧, 刘标, 薛堃. 3种不同抗除草剂转基因大豆对田间节肢动物多样性的影响[J]. 生态与农村环境学报, 2023, 39(4): 504-510.

YANG Xiao-ran, LIU Jing, YAO Shu-jun, SHEN Wen-jing, GUO Hui, LIU Biao, XUE Kun. Effects of Three Different Herbicide-resistant Transgenic Soybeans on Arthropod Diversity in Field[J]. Journal of Ecology and Rural Environment, 2023, 39(4): 504-510.

参考文献

[1] 国际农业生物技术应用服务组织.2019年全球生物技术/转基因作物商业化发展态势[J].中国生物工程杂志,2021,41(1):114-119.
[2] 强胜,宋小玲,戴伟民.抗除草剂转基因作物面临的机遇与挑战及其发展策略[J].农业生物技术学报,2010,18(1):114-125.[QIANG Sheng,SONG Xiao-ling,DAI Wei-min.The Opportunity and Challenge Faced by Transgenic Herbicide-Resistant Crops and Their Development Strategy[J].Journal of Agricultural Biotechnology,2010,18(1):114-125.]
[3] 蔡洪生.认识转基因大豆[J].大豆科技,2020(3):46-47.[CAI Hong-sheng.A New Cognitive of Transgenic Soybeans[J].Soybean Science & Technology,2020(3):46-47.]
[4] 余永亮,梁慧珍,王树峰,等.中国转基因大豆的研究进展及其产业化[J].大豆科学,2010,29(1):143-150.[YU Yong-liang,LIANG Hui-zhen,WANG Shu-feng, et al.Research Progress and Commercialization on Transgenic Soybean in China[J].Soybean Science,2010,29(1):143-150.]
[5] 崔宁波,张正岩.转基因大豆研究及应用进展[J].西北农业学报,2016,25(8):1111-1124.[CUI Ning-bo,ZHANG Zheng-yan.Advance of Research and Application of Transgenic Soybean[J].Acta Agriculturae Boreali-Occidentalis Sinica,2016,25(8):1111-1124.]
[6] 张凤,贺晓云,黄昆仑,等.转基因耐除草剂大豆的食用安全评价研究进展[J].生物技术进展,2021,11(4):489-495.[ZHANG Feng,HE Xiao-yun,HUANG Kun-lun, et al.Food Safety Evaluation of Transgenic Herbicide Tolerant Soybean[J].Current Biotechnology,2021,11(4):489-495.]
[7] GILBER T N.Case Studies:A Hard Look at GM Crops[J].Nature,2013,497(7447):24-26.
[8] 赵波,张鹏飞.抗除草剂转基因大豆的生态安全评价进展[J].山地农业生物学报,2012,31(1):70-76.[ZHAO Bo,ZHANG Peng-fei.Ecological Assessment of Transgenic Soybean Tolerant to Herbicide[J].Journal of Mountain Agriculture and Biology,2012,31(1):70-76.]
[9] 丁伟,王振华,李新海.转基因抗除草剂大豆的效益、潜在风险及其环境安全性评价[J].作物杂志,2010(6):15-19.[DING Wei,WANG Zhen-hua,LI Xin-hai.Benefits,Potential Risks and Environmental Safety Assessment of Herbicide-resistant Transgenic Soybean[J].Crops,2010(6):15-19.]
[10] ANDOW D A,ZWAHLEN C.Assessing Environmental Risks of Transgenic Plants[J].Ecology Letters,2006,9(2):196-214.
[11] 贾士荣.转基因作物的环境风险分析研究进展[J].中国农业科学,2004,37(2):175-187.[JIA Shi-rong.Environmental Risk Assessment of GM Crops:Progress in Risk Assessment[J].Scientia Agricultura Sinica,2004,37(2):175-187.]
[12] 康岭生,马瑞,杨向东,等.高油酸转基因大豆HOA₈₀对生物多样性影响的检测[J].吉林农业科学,2014,39(2):33-36.[KANG Ling-sheng,MA Rui,YANG Xiang-dong, et al.Assess of Impact of High Oleic Transgenic Soybean HOA₈₀ on Biodiversity[J].Journal of Jilin Agricultural Sciences,2014,39(2):33-36.]
[13] 李云河,彭于发,李香菊,等.转基因耐除草剂作物的环境风险及管理[J].植物学报,2012,47(3):197-208.[LI Yun-he,PENG Yu-fa,LI Xiang-ju, et al.Ecological Risks of Herbicide-tolerant Genetically Modified Crops and Associated Management[J].Chinese Bulletin of Botany,2012,47(3):197-208.]
[14] 戈峰,欧阳芳,赵紫华.基于服务功能的昆虫生态调控理论[J].应用昆虫学报,2014,51(3):597-605.[GE Feng,OUYANG Fang,ZHAO Zi-hua.Ecological Management of Insects Based on Ecological Services at a Landscape Scale[J].Chinese Journal of Applied Entomology,2014,51(3):597-605.]
[15] 陈彦君,李俊生,闫冰,等.转 Cry1Ah基因抗虫玉米HGK60对生物多样性的影响[J].环境科学研究,2021,34(4):964-975.[CHEN Yan-jun,LI Jun-sheng,YAN Bing, et al.Impact of Transgenic Insect-resistant Maize HGK60 with Cry1Ah Gene on Biodiversity in the Fields[J].Research of Environmental Sciences,2021,34(4):964-975.]
[16] 王成,姚俊津,高越,等.转 G2-EPSPS和GAT基因的耐除草剂大豆ZH10-6对田间生物多样性的影响[J].中国油料作物学报,2021,43(1):141-148.[WANG Cheng,YAO Jun-jin,GAO Yue, et al.Impacts of Transgenic Herbicide-tolerant Soybean ZH10-6 with G2-EPSPS and GAT Genes on Field Biodiversity[J].Chinese Journal of Oil Crop Sciences,2021,43(1):141-148.]
[17] 刘来盘,沈文静,薛堃,等.转 g10-epsps基因耐除草剂大豆ZUTS-33对农田生物多样性的影响[J].应用生态学报,2020,31(1):122-128.[LIU Lai-pan,SHEN Wen-jing,XUE Kun, et al.Impacts of Herbicide-resistant Soybean ZUTS-33 with g10-epsps Gene on Field Biodiversity[J].Chinese Journal of Applied Ecology,2020,31(1):122-128.]
[18] LEE S Y.Effects of Bt Rice Expressing Cry1Ac on Ecological Functional Guilds and Community of Non-target Insects[J].Entomological Research,2021,51(4):196-205.
[19] 夏敬源,崔金杰,马丽华,等.转 Bt基因抗虫棉在害虫综合治理中的作用研究[J].棉花学报,1999,11(2):57-64.[XIA Jing-yuan,CUI Jin-jie,MA Li-hua, et al.Study on the Role of Bt Transgenic Insect-resistant Cotton in Integrated Pest Management[J].Acta Gossypii Sinica,1999,11(2):57-64.]
[20] 李凡,孙红炜,赵维,等.抗除草剂转基因大豆对田间节肢动物群落多样性的影响[J].山东农业科学,2013,45(7):83-86.[LI Fan,SUN Hong-wei,ZHAO Wei, et al.Effects of Herbicide-Tolerant Transgenic Soybean on Biodiversity of Arthropod Community in Field[J].Shandong Agricultural Sciences,2013,45(7):83-86.]
[21] TAYLOR C.Monarch Butterflies May Be Threatened in Their North American Range[J].Environ Review,1999,6(4):1-9.
[22] 全国农业转基因生物安全管理标准化技术委员会.转基因植物及其产品环境安全检测耐除草剂除大豆第4部分:生物多样性影响[R].北京:中国农业出版社,2013.
[23] SHANNON C E.A Mathematical Theory of Communication[J].The Bell System Technical Journal,1948,27(3):379-423.
[24] BELCHER P R.Measurement of Myocardial Contractility[J].Journal of Cardiothoracic and Vascular Anesthesia,1997,11(6):812.
[25] 陈伟,李娜,曹越平.抗草甘膦转基因大豆SHZD32-01田间节肢动物和杂草多样性研究[J].上海交通大学学报(农业科学版),2019,37(1):54-60,73.[CHEN Wei,LI Na,CAO Yue-ping.Assessment of Glyphosate-resistant Transgenic Soybean SHZD32-01 on Biodiversity of Arthropod and Weed[J].Journal of Shanghai Jiao Tong University (Agricultural Science),2019,37(1):54-60,73.]
[26] AMIN M R,OH S D,SUH S J.Comparing the Effects of GM and Non-GM Soybean Varieties on Non-target Arthropods[J].Entomological Research,2020,50(9):423-432.
[27] YU H L,LI Y H,LI X J, et al.Arthropod Abundance and Diversity in Transgenic Bt Soybean[J].Environmental Entomology,2014,43(4):1124-1134.
[28] BHATTI M A,DUAN J,HEAD G P, et al.Field Evaluation of the Impact of Corn Rootworm (Coleoptera:Chrysomelidae)-protected Bt Corn on Foliage-dwelling Arthropods[J].Environmental Entomology,2005,34(5):1336-1345.
[29] XING Y J,QIN Z F,FENG M Y, et al.The Impact of Bt Maize Expressing the Cry1Ac Protein on Non-target Arthropods[J].Environmental Science and Pollution Research,2019,26(6):5814-5819.
[30] PRIESTLEY A L,BROWNBRID G E M.Field Trials to Evaluate Effects of Bt-transgenic Silage Corn Expressing the Cry1Ab Insecticidal Toxin on Non-target Soil Arthropods in Northern New England,USA[J].Transgenic Research,2009,18(3):425-443.
[31] MARQUES L H,SANTOS A C,CASTRO B A, et al.Impact of Transgenic Soybean Expressing Cry1Ac and Cry1F Proteins on the Non-target Arthropod Community Associated with Soybean in Brazil[J].PLoS One,2018,13(2):e0191567.